Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original
The client was brought to trial on charges of defrauding money from a victim by inducing the purchase of unlisted stocks together with accomplices.
In the 1 instance, considering factors such as the fact that the full amount of damage was not recovered despite reaching a settlement with the victim, a sentence of 2 year of imprisonment was handed down.
In the appellate trial, Attorney Jin-Bae Kim consulted with the defense attorneys of the accomplices to repay the full amount of damage and contested the legal issues regarding the special act related to telecommunications-based financial fraud applied to the crime.
As a result, the appellate court accepted the argument regarding the misunderstanding of legal principles concerning the portion involving the violation of the special act, vacated the original judgment, and sentenced the client to 1 year and 6 months of imprisonment, suspended for 3 years.
- Outcome
- Vacatur of Original Judgment, Suspended Sentence
- Case type
- Fraud
Background
The client was indicted on charges of defrauding money in the process of soliciting the purchase of unlisted stocks to a victim together with 2 accomplices.
The prosecution applied charges of fraud and violation of the special act related to telecommunications-based financial fraud to the acts of the client and others deceiving the victim using telephone or other means and receiving wire transfers of money under the pretext of stock purchase price.
Initially, among the 3 accomplices, only the client was apprehended first. Due to financial circumstances, the client paid 000원, representing part of the damage amount, and reached a settlement with the victim, but could not recover the remainder of the damage amount.
Despite the favorable circumstances that the client was a first-time offender and had settled with the victim, the 1 instance court sentenced the client to 2 year of imprisonment, considering that the recovery of damages was insufficient.
Accordingly, the client appealed on the grounds that the sentence was excessively heavy and that there were issues with the statute applied to the crime.
Issues
① Effect of Full Repayment of the Damage Amount on Sentencing
In the 1 instance, the client settled with the victim, but the entire damage amount was not recovered.
Therefore, in the appellate trial, whether the remaining damage could be recovered and whether the victim maintained the intention of not wanting punishment were critical sentencing issues.
② Whether the Special Act Related to Telecommunications-Based Financial Fraud Applies
Another core issue was whether the client's crime fell under telecommunications-based financial fraud as defined in the Telecommunications-Based Financial Fraud Damage Refund Act.
The former 통신사기피해환급법 제2조 제2호 단서 excluded acts pretending to supply goods or provide services, etc. from the scope of telecommunications-based financial fraud.
In this case, it was contested whether the act of receiving money under the pretext of the purchase price of unlisted stocks fell under that exception.
Response
① Full Repayment of Damage Amount Through Consultations with the Accomplices' Side
During the appellate trial, Attorney Jin-Bae Kim conducted consultations with the defense attorneys of the accomplices who were apprehended late.
Although it was difficult for the client alone to repay the entire damage amount due to financial circumstances, through consultations with the accomplices' side, he succeeded in fully repaying the entire damage amount.
Subsequently, he argued as favorable sentencing factors that all damages were recovered, the victim's expression of not desiring punishment, and the client's status as a first-time offender.
② Argument of Misunderstanding of Legal Principles Regarding Application of the Special Act
Attorney Jin-Bae Kim focused on the fact that the client's act did not constitute simple telecommunications-based financial fraud, but rather a transaction pretending to supply goods, namely unlisted stocks.
Accordingly, he raised a legal argument that it should be excluded from the scope of application of the special act pursuant to the former 통신사기피해환급법 제2조 제2호 단서.
Furthermore, he argued to the effect that fraud under the former Criminal Act should apply to the crime, rather than the special act related to telecommunications-based financial fraud.
The appellate court accepted this argument regarding the misunderstanding of legal principles.
Result
The appellate court took into account that the client's crime was an act of receiving money under the pretext of unlisted stock purchase price.
Accordingly, viewing it as falling under an act pretending to supply goods, etc., it judged that it was difficult to recognize the crime as telecommunications-based financial fraud under the former Telecommunications-Based Financial Fraud Damage Refund Act.
In addition, the court considered as favorable sentencing factors that the full amount of damage was repaid, the victim did not want punishment, and the client was a first-time offender.
As a result, the court vacated the judgment of the original instance and sentenced as follows.
Final Judgment
- Vacatur of the original judgment
- Judgment to the effect of innocence regarding the portion involving the violation of the special act related to telecommunications-based financial fraud
- 1 year and 6 months of imprisonment, suspended for 3 years
The client received a suspended sentence instead of the actual prison sentence handed down in the 1 instance.
Significance of the Case Outcome
This case demonstrates that even if a prison sentence is handed down in the 1 instance, the outcome can change by specifically contesting damage recovery and legal issues in the appellate trial.
In particular, the fact that the entire damage amount was repaid through consultations with the accomplices' side was favorably considered in sentencing.
Furthermore, it is significant in that it examined whether fraudulent acts pretending to trade unlisted stocks fall under the scope of application of the special act related to telecommunications-based financial fraud, and the argument of misunderstanding of legal principles was accepted.
In fraud cases, one must examine not only whether damages have been recovered, but also the specific method of the crime and the applicable statutes.
This is because even for the same deceptive act, the applicable statute may vary depending on the transaction structure and the legal elements of the crime.
This case is a reconstruction of an actual case handled by Veteran Law Firm, prepared so that the parties cannot be identified. The outcome of a case varies depending on the facts and evidence of the individual matter and does not guarantee the same result in other cases.
Request a consultation
Use the form to send a consultation request.