Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original
The client is a transacting party who purchased real estate.
Claiming that the final payment date had been falsely reported, the city hall imposed an administrative fine in the tens of millions of KRW on the client for violating the Act on Report on Real Estate Transactions, Etc.
Veteran Law Firm identified the legal doctrine that a licensed real estate agent is the reporting obligor in transactions handled through a licensed real estate agent, and argued this in the objection.
After reviewing this, the city hall accepted the objection and cancelled the administrative fine imposition ex officio.
- Outcome
- Ex Officio Cancellation
- Case type
- Administrative fine for violation of the Act on Report on Real Estate Transactions, Etc.
Background
Hefty Administrative Fine Imposed on Grounds of Change in Final Payment Date
In purchasing the real estate, the client conducted the transaction through a licensed real estate agent and proceeded with the registration through a certified judicial scrivener.
However, the actual final payment date turned out to be different from the reported date, and the city hall regarded this as a false report of the final payment date and imposed an administrative fine in the tens of millions of KRW.
The client took the stance that there was no intentional fault because both the transaction and the registration had been entrusted to professionals. However, the city hall pushed forward with imposing the fine on the grounds that the final payment date had actually changed. In response, a situation arose where filing an objection in court was even being prepared.
Issues
Who Holds the Reporting Obligation in Transactions Handled Through a Licensed Real Estate Agent?
The core of this case was whether the duty of faithful reporting concerning the report of the final payment date could be demanded of the client.
① Scope of the Reporting Obligor
Who constitutes the reporting obligor bearing the duty of faithful reporting under the Act on Report on Real Estate Transactions, Etc.
② Specific Nature of Transactions Involving a Licensed Real Estate Agent
Whether the client, as a transacting party, bears the reporting obligation even in transactions handled through a licensed real estate agent
Response
Identifying the Legal Doctrine on the Reporting Obligor and Filing an Objection
Veteran Law Firm Attorney Hwan-seon Yoo responded as follows:
① Substantiating the Absence of Intentional Fault
It was clarified that there was no intentional fault for a false report, as the client handled the transaction through a licensed real estate agent and the registration through a certified judicial scrivener.
② Asserting the Legal Doctrine on the Reporting Obligor
The duty of faithful reporting is imposed on the legal reporting obligor. However, in transactions handled through a licensed real estate agent, the licensed real estate agent becomes the reporting obligor, and the transacting parties do not bear the reporting obligation. Veteran identified this legal doctrine and argued that there was no basis to impose an administrative fine on the client.
Result
Ex Officio Cancellation of the Administrative Fine Imposition
Upon reviewing the objection statement and supporting materials submitted by the client, the city hall determined that it was necessary to reexamine the grounds and provisions for imposing the administrative fine.
Accordingly, the city hall cancelled the previously imposed administrative fine pursuant to the Act on the Regulation of Violations of Public Order.
In a situation where even court objection proceedings were being prepared, Veteran Law Firm identified the legal doctrine regarding the reporting obligor and led to the outcome of having the administrative fine imposition cancelled at the objection stage.
As a result, the client was able to be relieved from the burden of an administrative fine in the tens of millions of KRW without proceeding all the way to a court trial.
This case is a reconstruction of an actual case handled by Veteran Law Firm such that the parties cannot be identified. Case outcomes vary depending on the facts and evidence of individual matters, and do not guarantee the same outcome in other cases.
Request a consultation
Use the form to send a consultation request.