Veteran Law Firm

[Seoul] 8 or More School Violence Allegations Reported, Only Partially Recognized Resulting in Measures No. 2 and No. 3

Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original

The client is a middle school student who was experiencing conflict with a classmate.

Claiming that the client committed indecent act by compulsion, property damage, special intimidation, assault, and other acts, the other student's side reported more than 8 incidents as school violence.

Veteran Law Firm explained before the School Violence Deliberation Committee that the reported details were based on distorted claims and facts.

As a result, most of the reports were not recognized as facts or were determined not to constitute school violence, and only a portion of the assault allegations (a flick on the forehead) was recognized as school violence.

Outcome
Minor Disposition
Case type
School Violence

Background

Conflict with a Classmate Led to More Than 8 School Violence Reports

The client and the other student were in the same class in year 1 of middle school, and became classmates again in year 2 of middle school.

During school life, conflicts of varying severity continued between the two students. Although the two students had even written a document pledging not to tease each other, quarrels continued thereafter.

The other student's side reported that the client belittled and ridiculed their appearance and engaged in physical contact and sexual remarks. The report also included allegations that the client damaged a bag and pencil case, threatened with a utility knife, and assaulted them.

If recognized as reported, it was a situation that could lead to severe measures.

Issues

Whether the Reported Acts Actually Occurred and Whether They Constitute School Violence

The core of this case was to examine the more than 8 reported allegations one by one to determine whether they were actual facts and whether they met the requirements for school violence.

① Recognition of Facts

Whether serious reported allegations, such as indecent act by compulsion and special intimidation, actually occurred

② Applicability to School Violence

Whether there was intent regarding the acts involving the bag and pencil case and the act of grabbing the arm, and whether they met the requirements for school violence

③ Circumstances of the Conflict

Whether the entirety of the actions could be regarded as unilateral school violence under circumstances where the statements of both parties conflicted

Response

Addressing and Explaining the Distorted Claims and Factual Relations One by One

Attorneys Ye-jin Jeong and Hwan-seon Yoo of Veteran Law Firm argued as follows at the School Violence Deliberation Committee stage:

① Untrue Reported Allegations

They explained that the client never engaged in actions such as appearance belittlement/ridicule, physical contact/sexual remarks, or threats with a utility knife. They also emphasized that there was no objective evidence to prove these claims.

② Acts Without Intent

They argued that the circumstances regarding carrying the bag out to the hallway and the pencil case falling into the trash bin were unclear. They also clarified that the client had no intent to damage or conceal the items.

③ Defensive Reaction

They pointed out that grabbing the other student's arm was a momentary reaction to stop the other student, who had first grabbed the client's leg.

④ Mutual Conflict

There was a fact that the two students pledged in writing not to tease each other. Furthermore, citing the fact that the statements of both parties conflicted regarding the beginning of the conflict, they argued that it could not be regarded as unilateral school violence.

Result

Most Reports Unrecognized, Only a Portion Recognized as School Violence

The School Violence Deliberation Committee did not recognize appearance belittlement/ridicule, physical contact/sexual remarks, and threats with a utility knife as facts, stating that the client denies them and there is no objective evidence to prove them.

Regarding the acts involving the bag and pencil case, it judged that it was difficult to consider them school violence as the circumstances and intent were not clear. It also viewed that there was room to see the act of grabbing the arm as a defensive and accidental reaction to the other student's preceding action.

Furthermore, the School Violence Deliberation Committee stated that it is not desirable to regard and discipline all conflicts or disputes that students experience during school life as school violence.

Ultimately, the only thing recognized as school violence was a portion of the assault allegations (a flick on the forehead). Accordingly, measures of prohibition of contact, intimidation, and retaliation (Measure No. 2), 4 hours of school service (Measure No. 3), and special education for the student and guardian were imposed.

Veteran Law Firm examined and explained the factual relations and requirements for school violence regarding the more than 8 reported allegations one by one.

As a result, all serious allegations such as indecent act by compulsion, special intimidation, and property damage were dismissed, and the case was successfully concluded with minor measures.

This case has been reconstructed from an actual case handled by Veteran Law Firm so that the parties cannot be identified. The outcome of a case varies depending on the facts and evidence of individual matters, and the same outcome is not guaranteed in other cases.

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.