Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original
The client pursued legal action in a situation where a father, who had left the household leaving behind young children, demanded inherited property following the child's death.
The father did not participate in child-rearing while the child was growing up, but once the grown child passed away, he appeared at the funeral hall and demanded real estate left by the deceased first.
Veteran Law Firm Attorney Seulki Lee focused on 민법 제1004조의2, commonly known as the 'Goo Hara Act.'
In the process of claiming the forfeiture of inheritance rights against an heir who had gravely breached the duty of support, it was determined necessary to preserve the relevant real estate so that it would not be arbitrarily disposed of.
Accordingly, an application for a provisional injunction against the disposal of real estate was filed with the right to claim forfeiture of inheritance rights as the right to be preserved, and the court granted the application after reviewing the submitted prima facie materials. As a result, a legal measure was secured to restrict the disposal of inherited property while the determination on whether inheritance rights are forfeited is pending.
- Outcome
- Injunction Granted
- Case type
- Provisional Injunction against Disposal of Real Estate in Connection with a Claim for Forfeiture of Inheritance Rights
Background
A Father Who Left His Young Child Demands Inherited Property Following the Child's Death
This case arose when a father who had left his household during his child's youth asserted rights to the inherited property following the child's death.
The father did not participate in child-rearing during the process of the child's upbringing. However, once the child grew into an adult and passed away, he appeared at the funeral hall and demanded inherited property, including land left by the deceased.
The issue was the possibility that the father might exercise rights concerning the inherited property on the sole basis of holding the legal status of an heir.
The client sought to challenge whether it was justifiable for a father who had failed to fulfill his duty of support toward the child in the past to acquire the inherited property. In particular, if the real estate were to be sold or have rights established in favor of a 3rd party before a determination on the forfeiture of inheritance rights was rendered, difficulties could arise in preserving the inherited property.
Accordingly, with the assistance of Veteran Law Firm, the client applied for a provisional injunction against the disposal of real estate to preemptively prevent the disposal of the inherited property.
Issues
Claim for Forfeiture of Inheritance Rights under the Goo Hara Act and the Necessity of Preserving Inherited Property
The core of this case lay in whether it was possible to restrict in advance the disposal of the real estate, which was the inherited property, during the process of disputing the forfeiture of inheritance rights of the father who had failed to fulfill his duty of support.
민법 제1004조의2 stipulates that a claim for forfeiture of inheritance rights may be made where grounds prescribed by law exist, such as gravely breaching the duty of support toward the inheritee.
This is the regime known as the 'Goo Hara Act,' which provides grounds to determine whether it is appropriate for an heir to exercise inheritance rights merely because of a legal family relationship.
In particular, 민법 제1004조의2 제7항 provides for the right to claim prohibition of disposal for the preservation and management of inherited property.
Therefore, two matters were critical in this case:
First, examining whether the circumstances of the father's past child-rearing and performance of support duties fell under circumstances relevant to a claim for forfeiture of inheritance rights.
Second, establishing the legal necessity through prima facie evidence to prevent the real estate from being disposed of before a determination on the forfeiture of inheritance rights is made.
Apart from the conclusion of the claim for forfeiture of inheritance rights itself, whether the inherited property could be preserved until that determination was rendered served as an important issue.
Response
Applying for Prohibition of Disposal of Inherited Property Based on 민법 제1004조의2 제7항
Veteran Law Firm Attorney Seulki Lee did not approach the issue regarding the father's exercise of inheritance rights as a simple property dispute among family members.
Based on the circumstances under which the father, who had left the household leaving behind young children, demanded inherited property after the child's death, counsel examined the legal basis for claiming forfeiture of inheritance rights and preserving inherited property under the amended Civil Act.
In this case in particular, it was essential to prepare for the possibility that the real estate might be disposed of while awaiting the final outcome of the claim for forfeiture of inheritance rights. Accordingly, setting the right to claim prohibition of disposal for the preservation and management of inherited property under 민법 제1004조의2 제7항 as the right to be preserved, an application for a provisional injunction against the disposal of real estate was filed.
① Reviewing Legal Relations Concerning Forfeiture of Inheritance Rights under the Goo Hara Act
Counsel examined the circumstances that the father did not participate in child-rearing during the child's upbringing, along with the background of his demanding inherited property after the child's death. On this basis, counsel organized the legal relations concerning the claim for forfeiture of inheritance rights and substantiated the necessity of preserving the inherited property.
② Responding to Issues of Rights Preservation Arising from Disposal of Inherited Property
With real estate, there is a risk that rights of a 3rd party, such as chonsegwon (registered leasehold) or mortgages, could be established, in addition to sale or gift.
Therefore, it was necessary to restrict acts of disposal regarding the real estate from taking place before whether inheritance rights are forfeited is determined. Veteran Law Firm utilized provisional injunction procedures against the disposal of real estate to resolve this issue.
③ Submitting Prima Facie Materials Based on the Amended Civil Act
The core of this provisional injunction was to substantiate to the court the necessity of preserving and managing the inherited property under 민법 제1004조의2.
Attorney Seulki Lee proceeded with the provisional injunction application based on the relevant statutory provisions, and the court determined that there were grounds for the application based on the submitted prima facie materials. As a result, a decision prohibiting the disposal of the real estate, which constituted the inherited property, was secured.
Result
Provisional Injunction against Disposal of Real Estate Granted; Acts of Disposal such as Sale, Gift, and Establishment of Security Rights Prohibited
The Seoul Family Court granted the provisional injunction against the disposal of real estate applied for by Veteran Law Firm.
The court ordered as follows in its written decision:
“The Obligor shall not commit any and all acts of disposal, including sale, gift, establishment of chonsegwon, mortgages, or leasehold rights, with respect to the real estate described in the attached list.” Furthermore, the right to be preserved was specified as the right to claim prohibition of disposal for the preservation and management of inherited property pursuant to 민법 제1004조의2 제7항.
The court determined that there were grounds for the application and granted the provisional injunction on the condition of submitting a surety bond insurance policy as security. Accordingly, the client was able to secure a legal measure to restrict the disposal of the relevant real estate while the determination on the forfeiture of inheritance rights is being made.
However, this decision concerns a provisional injunction against the disposal of real estate, and the father's forfeiture of inheritance rights has not been finally confirmed.
Significance of the Case Outcome
A Case Where the Necessity of Preserving Inherited Property Prior to the Determination on Forfeiture of Inheritance Rights Was Recognized Using the Goo Hara Act
This case is meaningful in that it secured measures for the preservation of inherited property related to a claim for forfeiture of inheritance rights based on the amended 민법 제1004조의2.
The system of forfeiture of inheritance rights is designed to legally challenge the inheritance rights of an heir or similar party who has gravely breached the duty of support toward the inheritee. However, if the inherited property is disposed of before a determination on the forfeiture of inheritance rights is made, subsequent legal relationships may become complicated.
In this case, to respond to such risks, an application for a provisional injunction against the disposal of real estate was filed based on 민법 제1004조의2 제7항, and the court recognized its necessity. In particular, in a matter where a father who did not participate in child-rearing during the child's lifetime demanded inherited property after the child's death, it is significant that the means for preserving rights under the amended Civil Act were practically utilized.
Veteran Law Firm Attorney Seulki Lee reviewed the legal issues concerning the claim for forfeiture of inheritance rights and the preservation of inherited property, and led to the decision granting the provisional injunction through proper prima facie substantiation.
This decision represents a case where practical measures were secured to protect future legal relationships by restricting the disposal of inherited property prior to the final determination on whether inheritance rights are forfeited.
This case has been reconstructed from an actual matter handled by Veteran Law Firm so that the parties cannot be identified. The outcome of a case depends on the individual facts and evidence of each matter and does not guarantee the same outcome in other cases.
Request a consultation
Use the form to send a consultation request.