Veteran Law Firm

[Suwon] Violation of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes (Fraud) Non-Referral | Defense Against Allegations by Contesting the Credibility of Disadvantageous Operative Instruments in an Accusation Case of Approximately 00억 원

Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original

The client was accused of fraud amounting to approximately KRW 3,000,000,000 and became subject to a police investigation.

As the complaint amount was substantial and the complainant submitted numerous dispositive documents as evidence, defending against the allegations was not an easy situation.

In particular, because the documents related to the case were open to being interpreted disadvantageously to the client, it was important to review whether the contents stated in the documents coincided with the actual background and circumstances of the transactions. Veteran Law Firm responded by focusing on contesting the credibility of the disadvantageous dispositive documents among the complainant's evidentiary materials.

As a result, the police rendered a decision of non-referral regarding the client.

This case is an example demonstrating that in high-amount economic crime allegations, it is important to closely examine the credibility and probative value of the contents rather than the mere existence of the documents submitted by the opposing party.

Outcome
Non-referral
Case type
Violation of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes (Fraud)

Background

A Fraud Complaint Amounting to Approximately KRW 3,000,000,000 and Multiple Disadvantageous Evidentiary Materials

The client was accused to the effect of having defrauded a large sum of money from the complainant.

The complaint amount reached approximately 00억 원, and the investigation of the case proceeded under the charge of violation of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes (Fraud).

To support their claims, the complainant's side submitted various evidentiary materials. In particular, multiple dispositive documents that could work disadvantageously against the client were included.

Dispositive documents are documents in which certain legal acts, such as entering into a contract or assuming an obligation, are stated; when the authenticity of execution is acknowledged, they can serve as critical evidence in determining that the corresponding declaration of intention existed.

Therefore, it was necessary for the client not to stop at merely denying the contents of the complaint, but to legally examine what the submitted documents actually proved.

Issues

Whether the Constitutive Elements of the Crime of Fraud Can Be Recognized Solely Based on Disadvantageous Dispositive Documents

The crux of this case was whether the client's fraud allegations could be established on the basis of the dispositive documents and related evidentiary materials submitted by the complainant's side.

For the crime of fraud to be established, constitutive elements such as deceptive conduct, mistake by the other party, an act of property disposition resulting therefrom, and acquisition of pecuniary advantage must be recognized.

In particular, in high-amount economic crime cases, documents related to monetary transactions can be utilized as important evidence.

However, a distinction must be drawn between the fact that a document exists and whether all constitutive elements of the crime of fraud are proven solely through that document.

In this case, the following matters became important points of contention:

First, whether the contents of the dispositive documents conform to the actual circumstances of the transactions It had to be reviewed under what circumstances the contents stated in the documents were prepared and whether they accurately reflected the actual transactional relationship between the parties.

Second, whether the dispositive documents are sufficient as evidence to prove deceptive conduct Even if a document demonstrates the existence of a monetary transaction, that alone does not immediately establish the fact that the client deceived the other party.

Third, the credibility and probative value of the complainant's evidentiary materials Under circumstances where multiple documents were submitted, it was important to examine whether the contents of each document were mutually consistent and whether they supported the actual background facts of the case.

Response

Defense Against Allegations Focusing on the Credibility of Disadvantageous Dispositive Documents

In this case, Veteran Law Firm set the numerous dispositive documents submitted by the complainant's side as the core target of examination.

Because the complaint amount was an event reaching approximately KRW 3,000,000,000 and the evidentiary materials submitted by the opposing party were also quite specific, it was an uneasy situation to elicit a decision of non-referral.

In particular, because dispositive documents can be utilized as important evidence even in criminal cases, an adequate defense can be difficult through an approach that merely denies the contents of the documents. Accordingly, Veteran Law Firm focused on impeaching the credibility of the documents that were disadvantageous to the client.

Response Distinguishing Between the Existence of Documents and the Establishment of Fraud

In this case, to the extent that the complainant's evidentiary materials had the potential to operate disadvantageously against the client, it was important to distinguish whether the materials in question actually proved the constitutive elements of the crime of fraud.

Even if a certain legal act is stated in a dispositive document, that does not directly prove deceptive conduct or an intention of unlawful appropriation.

Therefore, it was necessary to differentiate the contents stated in the documents from the actual background of the transactions, and to closely scrutinize whether the criminal facts alleged by the complainant could be recognized solely with the materials in question.

Veteran Law Firm defended against the client's allegations by contesting the credibility of the disadvantageous evidentiary materials centering on these points of contention.

Result

Police Non-Referral on Violation of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes (Fraud)

As a result of investigating the case regarding the client's violation of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes (Fraud), the police made a decision of non-referral.

Although it was a case in which the complaint amount reached approximately 00억 원 and the complainant's side submitted multiple dispositive documents, the client obtained the outcome of concluding the case at the police investigation stage without referral to the prosecution.

The attorney in charge also explained regarding this case that although obtaining a non-referral decision was not easy because multiple disadvantageous dispositive documents existed, a non-referral result of clearing the suspicions was achieved after concentrating on contesting the credibility of the documents in question.

However, because specific reasons for non-referral are not indicated in the attached case inquiry materials, it cannot be definitively determined which evidence the police rejected or for what reasons the allegations were not recognized.

Significance of the Case Outcome

Why It Is Important to Contest the Probative Value of Disadvantageous Dispositive Documents in High-Amount Fraud Cases

This case shows that even in situations where the complaint amount is substantial and the opposing party has submitted numerous dispositive documents, it is important to examine the credibility of individual evidence and the constitutive elements of fraud distinctively.

In particular, while dispositive documents are important materials for assessing the existence of a legal act, the contents stated in the documents do not immediately prove deceptive conduct or an intention of unlawful appropriation.

Therefore, when facing high-amount economic crime allegations, rather than accepting uniformly or merely denying the documents submitted by the opposing party, one must scrutinize the relationship between the background of the preparation of the documents, the actual transactional relationship, and the facts sought to be proven.

In this case, Veteran Law Firm focused on contesting the credibility of the disadvantageous dispositive documents, and as a result, the client was able to receive a police non-referral decision regarding the charge of violating the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes (Fraud).

This serves as an example demonstrating that even in high-amount fraud cases where multiple disadvantageous documents have been submitted, a legal response that meticulously examines the probative value of the evidence is important.

This case is a reconstruction of an actual matter handled by Veteran Law Firm, rendered so that the parties cannot be identified. The outcome of a case varies depending on the specific facts and evidence of the individual matter, and the same outcome is not guaranteed in other cases.

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.