Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original
If you photographed someone from behind on the street, does the mere fact that they were wearing clothes mean it cannot become a criminal issue?
Conversely, if you find out that a specific part of your body was filmed without your consent, you may feel at a loss as to what standards to consider when reporting it.
If you are in a situation seeking a Busan illegal filming lawyer, you must examine not only the external appearance of a single photo, but also the subject, the circumstances of the filming, and the intentions at the time.
Requirements for when the offense of filming becomes an issue
특례법 제14조 제1항 provides that a person who, against the will of the person being filmed, films the body of a person which may cause sexual desire or shame using a camera or other similar device shall be punished by imprisonment for not more than 7 years or by a fine not exceeding KRW 50,000,000.
Statutory penalties are ranges prescribed by law and do not indicate the judgment or sentencing outcome of an actual case.
Whether the subject of filming corresponds to a body part prescribed by law and whether the filming was against the subject's will must be checked separately.
It cannot be automatically determined whether the offense is established solely by the fact that the person was wearing clothes or that it was in a public place.
At the same time, it must not be readily concluded that a crime is immediately established solely by the circumstance that another person inadvertently entered the frame.
The key is to examine the specific content of the footage and the filming circumstances to separately determine the sexual implication of the body part and whether the filming was against the subject's will.
While the purpose of filming or surrounding circumstances may serve as evidentiary material, a process of individually examining the content appearing in the image is also necessary.
For example, if multiple people are captured on the screen, one must divide and look at whose body parts appear and in what manner.
If accounts regarding the filming circumstances differ, they must be compared alongside other materials that can verify the situation at the time.
What did the Supreme Court examine?
In its judgment dated 2008년 9월 25일 in case 2008도7007, the Supreme Court explained that whether the filmed body corresponds to a statutory subject must be determined objectively.
While considering the perspective of a general and average person of the same gender and age group as the victim, the filming circumstances, location, clothing, and degree of exposure are comprehensively considered.
Because the angle, distance of filming, and whether a specific body part is emphasized in the original frame must also be examined, it is difficult to reach a conclusion by isolating only one factor.
Factors cited by the court are not a checklist to be applied mechanically, but rather circumstances to be reviewed together when evaluating a specific scene.
Because cropping only a portion of a photo may yield a composition different from the entire original, the scope of the material must be checked.
Outcomes differ depending on the facts and applicable laws, and one cannot directly apply the outcome of another case that appears similar.
The Supreme Court, in its judgment dated 2022년 3월 17일 in case 2021도13203, also ruled that in cases involving multiple recordings, each recording must be examined specifically and individually.
This means that simply because they were taken with the same intent does not mean all photos are evaluated identically.
You must check not only the filming location or attire, but also the content of the photo and the circumstances at the time of filming.
If you are considering a consultation with a Busan illegal filming lawyer, start by checking what that frame depicts and whether the surrounding circumstances can be verified with evidence.

Matters to check if you have suffered harm
Prioritize your safety, and organize the time and place you learned of the filming, as well as the circumstances under which you were contacted, to the extent that you recall.
Preserve any conversation records or screenshots in your possession, distinguishing the originals from the acquisition process, and you can receive guidance on how to submit them to investigative agencies.
There is no need to arbitrarily forward or disclose the relevant image to others in order to confirm the existence of the recording.
Even if you are anxious or your memories are not fully organized, the responsibility for failing to prevent the filming does not fall on the victim.
Inquire with the relevant agency regarding progress following the filing of the case and whether personal protection is needed, and you can organize your questions before giving a statement.
If you are investigated on suspicion of filming
If you are facing an investigation, one method is to organize in chronological order the reason you went to the filming location and the circumstances under which you took the photo.
However, rather than forcibly filling in parts you do not remember, it is more accurate to leave them as matters requiring verification.
If you received a summons, first check the case name, investigation schedule, and your status, and organize the content by distinguishing memory from speculation.
Check whether there is evidence to verify the time of the photo and the circumstances before and after, but do not arbitrarily delete files or conversation records.
You must also avoid actions such as coordinating explanations with others or directly contacting the other party to demand a change in their statement.
If you believed there was consent from the subject, it is important to confirm what formed the basis of that belief, and not to speak of conjectures as if they were facts.
During the investigation process, materials concerning the awareness at the time of filming and the subject's intentions may be reviewed alongside the nature of the recording.
Apart from whether the charges are admitted, the investigation procedures and the scope of document submission require legal review depending on individual circumstances.
When other acts are also at issue
Depending on whether there were other acts such as distribution or storage in addition to filming, separate regulations and requirements must be verified independently.
Statutory penalties in this article pertain to filming under 제14조 제1항 and do not mean they apply identically to all related acts.
View articles on body filming by the Busan office
Examine materials and criteria separately
Because recordings and the circumstances at the time differ in each case, one cannot predict an outcome solely based on a general description of a single photo.
When consulting with a Busan illegal filming lawyer, it is helpful to prepare questions by distinguishing confirmed materials from facts that are not yet known.
Together with a lawyer who graduated from the National Police University, you can calmly organize criminal procedures and methods for verifying facts.
Consult directly with a lawyer from the National Police University
This article provides general legal information and does not constitute legal advice on individual cases.
Sources
Request a consultation
Use the form to send a consultation request.