Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original
The client took over management duties of a one-room-tel where their spouse had worked as the building manager, because the spouse suddenly collapsed.
However, opposing parties who held no management authority came to the one-room-tel, occupied the management office, and changed the door lock password as they pleased. With the consent of other owners, the client broke the door lock, entered, and moved items necessary for management. Due to this incident, the client was reported on suspicion of property damage and theft.
Veteran Law Firm demonstrated that the client was handling management duties with the consent of the owners, and that it was rather the opposing parties who had been occupying the management office without authority. As a result, the property damage and theft allegations were closed without even being booked.
Afterward, an opposing party refiled a theft complaint with the same allegations. Veteran explained that this was a duplicative complaint identical to the already closed case, and the police dismissed the complaint.
- Outcome
- No Booking / Dismissal
- Case type
- Property Damage, Theft
Background
Occupation of the Management Office Seizing the Void of the Building Manager
The client's spouse was the largest share owner of a one-room-tel co-owned by several persons. With delegations from other owners, the spouse also carried out duties as the building manager.
In the meantime, the spouse suddenly collapsed and was transported to the hospital. To prevent a gap in management, the client took over the building manager duties with the consent of the other owners.
However, opposing parties with no management authority came to the one-room-tel and took over the management office. Claiming that they would manage the building going forward, they even arbitrarily changed the password of the management office door lock.
To prevent documents and other items needed for management from being siphoned off, the client broke the management office door lock and entered with the consent of the owners. The client then moved some items inside the management office outside. When this matter was reported to 112, the client came under suspicion of property damage and theft.
Issues
Does an Act of Management Performed with Owner Consent Constitute a Crime?
The key point in this case was whether the client's acts of breaking the door lock and moving the items were conducted pursuant to legitimate management authority.
① Locus of Management Authority
Whether the client was legitimately handling management duties with the consent of other owners, or whether the management authority belonged to the opposing parties
② Whether Property Damage and Theft Were Established
Whether the acts of breaking the door lock and moving management items with the consent of the owners could be viewed as property damage or theft
③ Handling of the Duplicative Complaint
How to handle a complaint filed again with the same contents as an already closed case
Response
Clarifying Management Authority to Obtain No Booking, and Securing Dismissal for Duplicative Complaint
Veteran Law Firm Attorneys Seung-yoon Oh and Geon-young Lee responded as follows:
① Clarifying Legitimate Management Authority
They organized and submitted the ownership relations and management delegation relations of the one-room-tel. Through this, they established that the client was handling management duties with the consent of the other owners.
② Pointing Out the Opposing Party's Unauthorized Occupation
They pointed out that it was rather the opposing parties who occupied the management office without management authority and arbitrarily changed the door lock password. They emphasized that the client breaking the door lock was an unavoidable measure resulting from this.
③ Response to Duplicative Complaint
When the opposing party filed a theft complaint again with the same allegations, they explained to the assigned investigator that this case was a duplicative complaint identical in substance to the case already concluded with no suspicion.
Result
No Booking for Property Damage and Theft, Dismissal of Re-complaint for Theft
The police did not book the initially reported property damage and theft suspicions, and closed the case as no suspicion at the pre-booking investigation stage.
Afterward, the opposing party filed a theft complaint again with the same allegations, but the police determined that it was a case already closed with no suspicion. Deeming that the same decision would clearly be rendered even if reinvestigated and that there was no practical benefit to investigating further, the police dismissed the complaint.
Veteran Law Firm specifically established the client's legitimate management authority and the fact of the opposing party's unauthorized occupation.
As a result, the client was cleared of the property damage and theft suspicions, and the re-complaint containing the same allegations was also dismissed, bringing the case to a conclusion.
This case is a reconstruction of an actual matter handled by Veteran Law Firm so that the parties cannot be identified. Case results vary depending on the facts and evidence of individual matters, and do not guarantee the same outcome in other cases.
Request a consultation
Use the form to send a consultation request.