Automatically translated from Korean. Read the Korean original
Veteran Law Firm Partner Attorney Seung-yoon Oh contributed a column titled 「성착취물 제작과 구입의 경계에서」 to the legal media outlet The Sisa Law.
This column addresses the distinction between 'production' and 'purchase', which continuously poses an issue in child and youth sexually exploitative material cases, pointing out that even if the acts appear similar, the level of punishment varies significantly depending on which criminal charge is applied.

Partner Attorney Seung-yoon Oh explained that because recording, transmitting, storing, and duplicating take place consecutively online, it is not easy to divide the legal nature of each act.
Production is an act directly involving the process in which sexually exploitative material is created, and purchase is an act of acquiring already existing materials by paying money. However, he analyzed that when requests for filming, or storage and reprocessing are added, this boundary can become blurred.
In particular, he introduced a case where the investigative agency viewed re-saving photographs received after paying money through screen capture or recording as 'production' rather than 'purchase'.
He emphasized that, given that purchase corresponds to imprisonment for a limited term of 1 year or more, and production corresponds to imprisonment for a limited term of 5 years or more, the outcome can be completely different depending on how the charge is determined.
In addition, he pointed out that viewing simple storage and intervention in production in the same category weakens the distinction between crime types, and conversely, interpreting production too narrowly makes it difficult to properly punish acts that contributed to actual production.
Furthermore, he suggested that criteria for judgment must be established to divide responsibility based on the degree of intervention and the impact on the outcome, thereby securing both the strictness of punishment and the predictability of legal application.
Going forward, Veteran Law Firm will continue activities sharing diverse perspectives and values with the legal community and society, as well as activities based on legal expertise.
[Contribution Information]
- Media: The Sisa Law
- Publication: 2026년 2월 9일
- Author: Partner Attorney Seung-yoon Oh
- Original Article: On the Boundary Between Production and Purchase of Sexually Exploitative Material
[Major Profile of Partner Attorney Seung-yoon Oh]

- Graduated from the Korean National Police University
- Currently Partner Attorney at Veteran Law Firm
- Formerly at Law Firm YK Police Criminal Department
- Investigation Planning Division, National Investigation Headquarters
- Investigation Division, Incheon Yeonsu Police Station
- Traffic Division, Guro Police Station
- Examination preparation and scoring committee member for National Police Agency Regular Promotion Examination
- Examination preparation committee member for Police Officer (Police Constable) Recruitment Examination
- Guest Lecturer at the Police Investigation Academy
Sources
Request a consultation
Use the form to send a consultation request.