A Problem with an Insurance Claim Does Not Automatically Constitute Insurance Fraud
An insurance fraud conviction does not follow simply because an insurance claim contains information that differs from the actual facts.
It is necessary to examine how the insured event occurred, how the claim was submitted, whether any information was false or exaggerated, and whether there was an intent to obtain insurance proceeds through deception.
This analysis becomes particularly important when an insurer’s internal investigation develops into a police investigation.
Medical records, insurance claim documents, accident records, materials collected by the insurer, and statements from the persons involved may all be reviewed together. The facts should therefore be organized accurately from the earliest stage of the investigation.
Veteran Law Firm analyzes insurance policies, claim histories, medical records, accident evidence, insurer investigation materials, and other relevant evidence to determine whether conduct constituting insurance fraud can be established, the individual’s actual scope of participation, the amount of insurance proceeds at issue, and the appropriate strategy for the investigation and trial.
WHAT IS INSURANCE FRAUD?
Under Korea’s Special Act on Prevention of Insurance Fraud, insurance fraud generally involves deceiving an insurer concerning the occurrence, cause, or circumstances of an insured event and making a claim for insurance proceeds on that basis.
Accordingly, the analysis does not end with determining whether insurance proceeds were actually paid.
It is necessary to determine whether deception occurred during the claims process and whether the person acted with the intent required for insurance fraud.
The following issues should be examined carefully.
Did the Insured Event Actually Occur?
It is necessary to determine whether the traffic accident, illness, bodily injury, property damage, or other event forming the basis of the insurance claim actually occurred.
Was Any Part of the Claim False or Exaggerated?
The investigation may focus on whether an accident that never occurred was reported, whether the duration of treatment was misrepresented, or whether the extent of loss or damage was intentionally overstated.
Was There Intent to Obtain Insurance Proceeds Through Deception?
Even where information submitted in an insurance claim is inaccurate, it is necessary to distinguish an intentional misrepresentation from an error, misunderstanding, or other circumstance that does not establish fraudulent intent.
Was There a Common Plan, and What Was Each Person’s Role?
Where policyholders, patients, medical personnel, repair shops, accident participants, insurance agents, or other persons are involved, it is necessary to determine whether the alleged conduct was planned in advance and what each person actually knew and did.
COMMON TYPES OF INSURANCE FRAUD CASES
Claims Based on Fictitious Accidents
This type of allegation arises where a person is suspected of making an insurance claim based on a traffic accident, bodily injury, or other event that did not actually occur.
The existence of the accident, relationships among the participants, and communications before and after the alleged event may become important evidence.
Claims Based on Intentionally Caused Accidents
These cases involve allegations that a traffic collision, property loss, or other insured event was intentionally caused for the purpose of obtaining insurance proceeds and then presented as an accidental occurrence.
Driving circumstances, dashcam footage, accident history, communications, and repeated claims may all become relevant.
Exaggeration of Loss or Damage
An actual accident may have occurred, but the insurer may allege that repair costs, treatment expenses, or the extent of the loss were intentionally inflated.
A central issue is why the amount claimed differed from the actual loss and whether the claimant knew of and intended that discrepancy.
False or Excessive Medical Treatment Claims
These cases may involve allegations that hospitalization or treatment that was not medically necessary was falsely documented or that the nature or extent of actual treatment was overstated for purposes of an insurance claim.
Medical records, the treatment actually provided, and communications among the patient, medical provider, and other participants should be reviewed carefully.
Automobile Insurance Fraud
These cases may involve intentionally causing a collision or exaggerating the circumstances or consequences of an accident to seek bodily injury or property-damage insurance proceeds.
Dashcam recordings, CCTV footage, vehicle data, accident reports, and communications among the persons involved may be critical evidence.
Organized or Coordinated Insurance Fraud
Where several individuals allegedly divide roles in planning accidents or repeatedly submit claims in coordination with medical providers, repair shops, or others, the prosecution may allege an organized scheme.
The alleged common plan, number of incidents, total insurance proceeds, and actual role and benefit attributable to each individual should be analyzed separately.
PENALTIES AND LEGAL STANDARDS FOR INSURANCE FRAUD
Insurance fraud is distinct from an ordinary contractual dispute over whether an insurer must pay a claim.
Criminal liability requires examination of conduct constituting deception and the intent associated with obtaining insurance proceeds through that conduct.
Insurance Fraud
A person who obtains insurance proceeds, or causes a third party to obtain insurance proceeds, through insurance fraud may be subject to:
Imprisonment for up to 10 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million
For this form of insurance fraud, imprisonment and a fine may also be imposed together where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
Attempted Insurance Fraud
An offense may still be punishable even where the insurer discovers the alleged fraud before making payment.
The Special Act on Prevention of Insurance Fraud expressly provides for punishment of attempts.
Habitual Insurance Fraud
A person who habitually commits an offense under Article 8 may be subject to an increase of up to one-half of the punishment prescribed for that offense.
Insurance Fraud Involving KRW 500 Million or More
Where the insurance fraud benefit reaches KRW 500 million but is less than KRW 5 billion:
Imprisonment for at least 3 years
Insurance Fraud Involving KRW 5 Billion or More
Where the insurance fraud benefit reaches KRW 5 billion or more:
Life imprisonment or imprisonment for at least 5 years
In cases subject to these aggravated provisions, an additional fine up to the amount of the insurance fraud benefit may also be imposed.
The actual outcome of a case may vary depending on the amount involved, number of offenses, degree of planning and repetition, existence of accomplices, individual participation, recovery of loss, prior record, and other case-specific circumstances.
WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED IN AN INSURANCE FRAUD CASE?
01. Did the Insured Event Actually Occur?
The first issue is whether the traffic accident, illness, bodily injury, property damage, or other event underlying the claim actually occurred.
02. What Part of the Insurance Claim Is Alleged to Be False?
The specific statement, document, treatment record, repair amount, or other claim item challenged by the insurer or investigative authority should be identified and compared with the actual facts.
03. Was There Intent to Obtain Insurance Proceeds Through Deception?
It is necessary to distinguish between an innocent mistake, reliance on information provided by a hospital, repair shop, or insurance agent, and a deliberate attempt to use false information to obtain insurance proceeds.
04. How Much Insurance Money Was Actually Paid or Is at Issue?
The total amount received under all insurance policies should be distinguished from the particular proceeds associated with the conduct under investigation.
Each policy, accident, and payment should be reviewed separately.
05. Was There an Agreement or Common Plan with Other People?
Where accident participants, hospital personnel, repair shops, insurance agents, or others are involved, communications, financial arrangements, and conduct before and after the claim should be examined to determine whether there was a shared criminal plan.
06. Were There Repeated Insurance Claims?
Past accidents and claims may be reviewed to determine whether similar claims occurred repeatedly or whether each incident arose independently.
07. Does the Insurer’s Investigation Match the Objective Evidence?
An insurer’s investigation report should not be examined in isolation.
Dashcam footage, CCTV recordings, medical records, financial transactions, call records, messages, and other objective evidence should be compared with the allegations.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR INSURANCE FRAUD CASES
DURING THE INITIAL INVESTIGATION
STEP 01 | Identify the Insurance Claims and Allegations at Issue
We determine which insured events and claims are under investigation and identify precisely what the insurer or investigative authority considers false or exaggerated.
STEP 02 | Analyze the Insurance Policies, Claims, and Accident Evidence
We review insurance policies and terms, claim applications, accident records, medical records, and related evidence to reconstruct both the insured event and the claims process.
STEP 03 | Examine the Alleged Deception and Fraudulent Intent
Where information in the claim differs from the actual facts, we examine who prepared or provided that information, whether the accused knew it was inaccurate, and whether there was an intent to obtain insurance proceeds through deception.
STEP 04 | Determine the Scope of Any Common Plan and Individual Participation
Where multiple suspects are involved, we examine communications, accident circumstances, division of insurance proceeds, and assigned roles to distinguish alleged joint conduct from the individual’s actual participation.
STEP 05 | Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews
Based on the objective evidence, we distinguish facts that can properly be acknowledged from matters that should be disputed.
We reconstruct the chronology from formation of the insurance contract through the insured event and submission of the claim so that the individual can respond accurately during questioning.
DURING TRIAL
STEP 01 | Review the Applicable Offense and Amount of Insurance Proceeds at Issue
We examine whether the Special Act on Prevention of Insurance Fraud applies and determine which claim amounts are alleged to constitute insurance fraud proceeds and what amount was actually obtained.
STEP 02 | Analyze Deception and Intent
We review the evidence concerning what the accused knew when the claim was submitted and whether there was an intent to deceive the insurer.
STEP 03 | Compare Accomplice Statements with Objective Evidence
Statements by other defendants or suspects are compared with accident records, communications, financial transactions, medical records, and insurance payment records to assess their consistency and reliability.
STEP 04 | Prepare Loss-Recovery and Sentencing Materials
Where criminal responsibility is acknowledged, we consider repayment of improperly received insurance proceeds, settlement or other loss-recovery measures, the absence of prior offenses, the individual’s degree of participation, and other relevant sentencing materials.
STEP 05 | Distinguish Individual Responsibility in Multi-Participant Cases
In an organized or multi-defendant case, we examine whether it is appropriate to attribute every incident or the entire amount of insurance proceeds to a particular individual.
The number of incidents in which that person actually participated, the role performed, and the financial benefit actually obtained should be identified separately.
IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS WHEN FACING INSURANCE FRAUD ALLEGATIONS
Insurance claim records or mobile phone communications should not be deleted simply because an insurer has begun an investigation or the police have requested an interview.
Contacting other persons involved in order to coordinate accounts of the accident or align statements may also be interpreted unfavorably during the investigation.
At the same time, the fact that an insurer suspects fraud does not mean that every allegation should immediately be accepted.
It is necessary to identify whether an actual insured event occurred, who prepared each part of the insurance claim, what information was inaccurate, and whether the individual knew of the inaccuracy.
Where a hospital, repair shop, insurance agent, or other third party assisted in preparing the claim, it is generally not enough simply to state, “I did not know.”
Messages, explanations received at the time, documents prepared by each person, and the actual claims process should be reviewed objectively.
Where the allegations are substantially supported by the evidence, a blanket denial may not be an effective response.
It may instead be important to define accurately the particular claims involved, the individual’s actual scope of participation, and the amount attributable to the conduct while preparing appropriate materials concerning recovery of loss, settlement, and sentencing.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
01. We Analyze Whether the Conduct Constitutes Insurance Fraud
We compare the insurance claim materials with the actual accident or insured event to determine whether information was false or exaggerated and whether the conduct may satisfy the statutory definition of insurance fraud.
02. We Distinguish Fraudulent Intent from Error or Misunderstanding
We examine whether an inaccurate claim resulted from mistake, reliance on information provided by another person, or a deliberate attempt to obtain insurance proceeds through deception.
03. We Identify the Specific Insurance Proceeds at Issue
We do not automatically treat all insurance proceeds received by the individual as fraudulent.
Each accident, policy, and claim item is reviewed to distinguish the amount actually at issue from unrelated or legitimately paid insurance proceeds.
04. We Analyze the Alleged Common Plan and the Individual’s Actual Role
In cases involving multiple participants, we examine communications, conduct before and after the incident, allocation of proceeds, and assigned roles to determine whether a common criminal plan existed and what responsibility can properly be attributed to each individual.
05. We Respond to Both Insurer Investigations and Criminal Investigations
We review materials collected by the insurer together with medical records, accident evidence, financial records, communications, and digital evidence obtained by investigative authorities and prepare a response consistent with the objective facts.
06. We Maintain a Coordinated Strategy from Investigation Through Trial
From the initial investigation, we examine whether the offense can be established, the amount of insurance proceeds at issue, and the scope of alleged participation.
Where appropriate, we also prepare loss-recovery measures, settlement materials, and sentencing evidence for the later stages of the case.
IN AN INSURANCE FRAUD CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER INSURANCE MONEY WAS CLAIMED OR PAID, BUT WHETHER THERE WAS DECEPTION AND THE INTENT REQUIRED FOR INSURANCE FRAUD.
The fact that insurance proceeds were paid or that part of an insurance claim was inaccurate does not by itself determine the outcome of a criminal case.
It is necessary to establish whether the insured event actually occurred, precisely what part of the claim differed from the facts, and whether the individual knowingly used deception in seeking insurance proceeds.
Where several people are involved, the case should not be assessed solely on the statements of other suspects. Each insurance claim, communication, distribution of proceeds, and individual role should be examined separately.
Veteran Law Firm analyzes insurance policies and claims, accident and medical records, insurer investigation materials, and digital evidence to assess whether insurance fraud can be established, whether the required intent existed, the scope of individual participation, and the insurance proceeds actually at issue.
If you are being investigated by an insurer for suspected insurance fraud or have been asked to appear for police questioning, preserve the relevant records and first identify the specific claims and conduct being challenged before making assumptions or speculative statements.