A Poor Business Decision and Criminal Breach of Trust Must Be Clearly Distinguished
A person entrusted with managing the property or affairs of a company or another person has a duty to protect the interests of the person or entity whose affairs he or she manages.
If that person breaches those duties, obtains a financial benefit for himself, herself, or a third party, and causes financial loss to the company or other principal, criminal liability for breach of trust may arise.
However, the mere fact that a company suffered a loss or that a contract was breached does not automatically establish criminal breach of trust.
It is necessary to examine whether the accused was in a position of managing another person’s affairs, whether there was a specific breach of duty, whether a financial benefit and corresponding loss resulted, and whether the required intent existed.
Drawing on the investigative experience of attorneys who previously served as police officers, Veteran Law Firm analyzes the decision-making process, contractual terms, internal company rules, and evidence relating to financial loss in order to distinguish criminal breach of trust from legitimate business judgment and civil liability.
WHAT IS BREACH OF TRUST?
Breach of trust generally occurs when a person entrusted with managing another person’s affairs acts in violation of his or her duties, thereby obtaining a financial benefit for himself, herself, or a third party and causing financial loss to the person or entity whose affairs were entrusted to that person.
The existence of a loss alone is not enough. The accused person’s position, duties, conduct, financial benefit, resulting loss, and intent must be examined together.
COMMON TYPES OF BREACH OF TRUST
Disposing of Company Assets at a Substantially Undervalued Price
This may arise where a company representative or executive transfers company real estate, shares, business rights, equipment, or other assets to a particular person at a price substantially below their appropriate value.
Relevant issues may include the objective value of the asset at the time of the transaction, the business need for the sale, the relationship with the counterparty, and whether the required internal approval procedures were followed.
Making Improper Loans with Company Funds
Occupational breach of trust may become an issue where company funds are lent to an individual or affiliated company with insufficient ability to repay and without adequate collateral.
The borrower’s ability to repay at the time of the loan, the value of any collateral, applicable interest, the business purpose of providing the funds, and the potential benefit to the company should all be considered.
Providing Company Assets as Security for a Third Party’s Debt
This may arise where company property is pledged or otherwise provided as security for the debt of a third party despite the absence of a direct company interest or meaningful benefit to the company.
The purpose and consideration for providing the security, any board approval, and the financial risk imposed on the company should be examined.
Providing an Improper Benefit to a Particular Company
This may involve purchasing goods at a price substantially above the normal market price or entering into a contract on unusually favorable terms for a particular company, resulting in loss to the company.
Relevant issues may include the actual market or supply price, the bidding and contracting process, the reason the particular company was selected, and whether any improper consideration or relationship was involved.
Diverting a Corporate Business Opportunity for Personal Benefit
This may arise where a company representative or employee pursues in his or her own name, or through a third party, a business opportunity or contract that should properly have belonged to the company.
Important questions may include whether the business opportunity had become sufficiently concrete and attributable to the company and whether the company had the intention and ability to pursue it.
Double Sale of Real Estate
Breach of trust may become an issue where a seller, after receiving a deposit and interim payments and reaching a stage at which the seller is obligated to transfer title to the original purchaser, disposes of the same property to a third party.
The stage of performance under the original contract, the amounts already paid, whether title was transferred, and the seller’s legal position at the relevant time must be examined carefully.
Breach of Trust by Officers of Associations or Organizations
This may arise where the head of an association or organization enters into construction or service contracts contrary to the interests of members or provides an improper benefit to a particular company.
Relevant issues may include the decision-making and approval process, contractual terms, use of project funds, and any relationships or conflicting interests involving the parties.
PENALTIES FOR BREACH OF TRUST
Breach of Trust
Statutory Penalty
Imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million
Occupational Breach of Trust
Where a person who manages another person’s affairs as part of his or her occupational duties commits breach of trust, a heavier penalty may apply.
Statutory Penalty
Imprisonment for up to 10 years or a fine of up to KRW 30 million
Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes
Where the financial benefit obtained by the accused or a third party through breach of trust is KRW 500 million or more, enhanced penalties may apply under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes.
Gain of KRW 500 Million or More but Less Than KRW 5 Billion
Imprisonment for at least 3 years
Gain of KRW 5 Billion or More
Life imprisonment or imprisonment for at least 5 years
Where the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes applies, the court may also impose a fine of up to the amount of the financial gain obtained through the offense.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR BREACH OF TRUST CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Review the Allegations and the Decision-Making Process
We identify the alleged breach of duty, the person who allegedly obtained the financial benefit, the loss claimed by the company, and the accused person’s role in the relevant decision.
STEP 02 | Determine Whether the Accused Was Entrusted with Managing Another Person’s Affairs
We examine the accused person’s position and authority, contractual relationships, and delegated responsibilities to determine whether he or she falls within the category of a person entrusted with managing another person’s affairs under Korean criminal law.
STEP 03 | Analyze Contracts, Accounting Records, and the Alleged Loss
We review contractual terms, the value of the transaction at the relevant time, collateral, consideration received, and other financial circumstances to assess the actual financial loss and the amount of any benefit obtained.
STEP 04 | Prepare for the Police Investigation and Address the Legal Issues
We organize the information available when the decision was made, the basis for that decision, the benefit expected for the company, and the internal approval process.
Based on those materials, we prepare for questions concerning whether there was a breach of duty and whether the required criminal intent existed.
STEP 05 | Address Victim Compensation and Respond at Trial
Where the allegations are admitted, we review appropriate measures for compensating the loss and pursuing settlement.
If the case is prosecuted, we address the legal elements of the offense, the amount of loss, the degree of participation, and whether the conduct was instead a legitimate business judgment made in the company’s interests.
FOR VICTIMS AND COMPLAINANTS
STEP 01 | Identify the Breach of Duty and the Resulting Loss
We identify the specific duty owed by the accused, how that duty was allegedly breached, who obtained the resulting financial benefit, and what loss was caused to the company or other principal.
STEP 02 | Secure Internal Decision-Making Records
We collect articles of incorporation, internal regulations, board minutes, approval records, contract review materials, and other documents relevant to determining whether normal decision-making procedures were followed.
STEP 03 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Supporting Evidence
We prepare the complaint so that the accused person’s position as a person managing another’s affairs, the alleged breach of duty, the financial benefit obtained by the accused or a third party, and the corresponding loss are clearly connected.
STEP 04 | Respond to the Investigation
Where the accused argues that the conduct was a legitimate business decision or an ordinary commercial transaction, we review and submit relevant evidence concerning market prices, contractual terms, conflicts of interest, and internal materials showing objections or concerns at the time.
STEP 05 | Pursue Recovery of Losses and Civil Remedies
Alongside the criminal complaint, we review potential measures for recovering the company’s losses, including provisional attachment of assets, claims for damages, litigation concerning the validity or cancellation of contracts, and potential claims against persons who received the relevant benefit.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
01. We Begin by Determining Whether the Accused Was Actually Managing Another Person’s Affairs
Breach of trust does not apply to every breach of contract or unsuccessful transaction.
Veteran Law Firm first examines whether the accused was merely managing his or her own affairs or had instead been entrusted, based on a relationship of trust, with duties involving the protection or management of another person’s property or interests.
02. We Distinguish Legitimate Business Judgment from a Criminal Breach of Duty
When a business decision results in a loss, the information and procedures available at the time the decision was made are critical.
We analyze market conditions, business prospects, internal reviews, board approval, and the benefits the company reasonably expected to obtain in order to determine whether the decision represented a legitimate business judgment or a breach of duty that may give rise to criminal liability.
03. We Calculate the Alleged Loss and Financial Benefit Based on Objective Evidence
The total transaction amount or an accounting loss does not automatically equal the amount of loss for purposes of a breach-of-trust allegation.
We examine the market value at the time of the transaction, consideration received, collateral value, likelihood of recovery, and actual financial benefit obtained in order to assess the relevant loss and gain.
04. We Respond to Police Investigations and Evidence Obtained Through Search and Seizure
Drawing on the investigative experience of attorneys who previously served as police officers, we analyze contracts, accounting records, emails, messenger communications, and other materials obtained or reviewed by investigative authorities.
We anticipate key areas of questioning and prepare a consistent statement based on the objective evidence.
05. We Distinguish the Role and Degree of Participation of Each Executive or Employee
The fact that several executives or employees were involved in the same transaction does not mean that each person bears the same criminal responsibility.
We examine each person’s authority to approve the transaction, access to relevant information, whether instructions were given or followed, involvement in execution, and whether any personal benefit was obtained in order to distinguish individual roles and responsibilities.
06. We Address Criminal Proceedings and Recovery of Company Losses Together
For a company that has suffered loss, recovering the financial damage may be as important as seeking criminal accountability.
Veteran Law Firm reviews civil recovery measures alongside the criminal complaint, including provisional attachment, claims for damages, challenges to relevant contracts where legally available, and potential claims against persons who received the financial benefit.
IN A BREACH OF TRUST CASE, THE CENTRAL ISSUE IS NOT THE LOSS ITSELF, BUT THE PROCESS BY WHICH AN ENTRUSTED DUTY WAS ALLEGEDLY VIOLATED.
For a suspect or defendant, objective evidence showing that the decision was made through a reasonable process for the benefit of the company may be critical.
For a company that has suffered loss, evidence should clearly show what duty the accused owed, how that duty was breached, who obtained the resulting benefit, and what financial loss resulted.
Drawing on the investigative experience of attorneys who previously served as police officers, Veteran Law Firm analyzes the decision-making process, contractual materials, and financial consequences and provides coordinated assistance from the police investigation through recovery of losses and criminal trial proceedings.
If you are facing a police investigation for breach of trust or believe that a company has suffered an improper financial loss, consult Veteran Law Firm before relevant contracts, approval records, and internal decision-making materials are lost or become incomplete.