Veteran Law Firm

Practice Areas

Sex Crimes

In a Rape Case, the Circumstances at the Time of the Incident and the Objective Evidence Must Be Examined Together

Sex Crimes

Practice Areas

RAPE

In a Rape Case, the Circumstances at the Time of the Incident and the Objective Evidence Must Be Examined Together

WHAT IS RAPE?

Rape is a criminal offense under Article 297 of the Korean Criminal Act involving sexual intercourse accomplished through violence or intimidation.

Whether rape is established is not determined by looking at the alleged violence or intimidation in isolation.

The nature and degree of the force or threats, the circumstances in which they were used, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances during and after the alleged incident may all be considered together.

Depending on the condition of the alleged victim at the time and the specific conduct involved, other sexual offenses—such as quasi-rape or quasi-rape involving conduct other than sexual intercourse—may also become relevant.

Where the alleged victim is a minor, or where particular relationships, methods, or circumstances are involved, separate statutes may provide for different or enhanced criminal liability.

PENALTIES FOR RAPE

Under Article 297 of the Korean Criminal Act, rape is punishable by:

Imprisonment for at least 3 years

There is no statutory fine-only penalty for the basic offense of rape under Article 297.

The Korean Sentencing Commission provides sentencing guideline ranges that vary according to the type and seriousness of the offense.

General Rape

Mitigated: 1 year 6 months to 3 years

Standard: 2 years 6 months to 5 years

Aggravated: 4 years to 7 years

Rape of a Juvenile

Mitigated: 2 years 6 months to 5 years

Standard: 4 years to 7 years

Aggravated: 6 years to 9 years

Rape Involving a Familial Relationship / Rape Following Intrusion / Aggravated Rape

Mitigated: 3 years 6 months to 6 years

Standard: 5 years to 8 years

Aggravated: 7 years to 10 years

Robbery-Rape

Mitigated: 5 years to 9 years

Standard: 8 years to 12 years

Aggravated: 10 years to 15 years

Sentencing guideline ranges are not the same as the statutory penalty for a particular offense and do not determine the sentence automatically.

The actual sentence may vary depending on the specific offense charged, the circumstances and seriousness of the conduct, the resulting harm, criminal history, recovery of harm, legally relevant settlement-related circumstances, and other applicable sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN A RAPE CASE

Important issues may include:

whether violence or intimidation actually occurred;

the nature and degree of the alleged violence or intimidation;

whether the conduct satisfied the legal standard applicable to rape;

the circumstances and conduct of the parties at the time of the alleged sexual intercourse;

communications between the parties before and after the incident;

the consistency of statements with objective evidence;

CCTV footage, location data, recordings, and lodging or transportation records;

whether other sexual-offense provisions may apply based on the particular circumstances; and

whether there is evidence that should be preserved before it is deleted or becomes unavailable.

A rape case should not be evaluated from a single statement or isolated circumstance. The statements of the parties must be examined carefully together with the surrounding circumstances and all available objective evidence.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR RAPE CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Facts from the Earliest Stage

We identify the time and location of the incident, the relationship between the parties, their conduct at the relevant time, and communications and events before and after the alleged incident.

A detailed chronology is prepared before substantive investigative statements are made.

STEP 02 | Secure and Analyze Objective Evidence

We identify and review evidence such as:

text and messenger communications;

CCTV footage;

location and movement records;

audio recordings;

lodging records;

transportation records; and

other digital or documentary evidence relating to the circumstances of the incident.

Because some forms of evidence may be deleted automatically after a certain period, preservation should be considered as early as possible.

STEP 03 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview

Before police questioning, we identify the principal legal and factual issues and review the questions likely to arise during the investigation.

The purpose is not to create or rehearse a particular version of events, but to ensure that the individual understands the chronology and can provide accurate statements based on actual memory and objective facts.

STEP 04 | Respond to the Investigation and Address Detention Risk

During the investigation, we analyze whether the facts and evidence support the elements of the alleged offense and submit relevant evidence and legal arguments where appropriate.

Where detention is being considered, we also review the circumstances relevant to the risk of arrest or pretrial detention and prepare the necessary response.

STEP 05 | Respond According to the Charging Decision

At the investigative stage, we present the facts and legal issues relevant to a police decision not to refer the case for prosecution or a prosecutorial non-indictment disposition where supported by the evidence.

If charges are filed, we analyze the indictment and prosecution evidence and prepare for trial.

STEP 06 | Criminal Trial and Defense

At trial, we examine the reliability of the evidence, the consistency of relevant statements, their relationship to objective evidence, and any material contradictions or evidentiary issues.

The defense strategy is developed according to whether the elements of the offense, the factual allegations, or other legal issues are disputed.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Organize the Circumstances of the Incident

We carefully organize the time and location of the incident, the relationship with the accused, the alleged violence or threats, and the circumstances before and after the incident.

The objective is to ensure that the facts can be communicated accurately without unnecessary speculation or distortion.

STEP 02 | Preserve Relevant Evidence

Potential evidence may include:

text and messenger communications;

audio recordings;

CCTV footage;

medical records and certificates;

counseling records;

photographs;

location data; and

other materials documenting the incident or its aftermath.

Evidence should be preserved in its original form wherever possible.

STEP 03 | Prepare for Investigative Interviews

Before an investigative interview, we organize the chronology and principal facts so that the circumstances of the alleged offense can be communicated accurately and concretely.

Where appropriate, we also assist in understanding the investigative process and the materials that may be requested.

STEP 04 | File a Criminal Complaint and Respond During the Investigation

Based on the available facts and evidence, we assist with preparation of the criminal complaint and supporting materials and submit necessary statements or legal opinions during the investigation.

STEP 05 | Assistance During Criminal Trial

After prosecution, we assist with procedures available to the victim and, where appropriate, submit materials explaining the circumstances and impact of the offense.

STEP 06 | Consider a Civil Damages Claim

Separate from the criminal case, we review whether a civil claim may be available for bodily injury, emotional distress, medical expenses, or other legally compensable harm resulting from the offense.

WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED IN A RAPE INVESTIGATION?

01. What Exactly Is Alleged to Have Happened?

The alleged conduct should be identified precisely rather than addressed only through broad conclusions such as “it was consensual” or “it was forced.”

The time, location, conduct, communications, and sequence of events should be reconstructed in detail.

02. What Violence or Intimidation Is Alleged?

The specific conduct alleged to constitute violence or intimidation should be identified and evaluated under the legal standard applicable to rape.

03. What Do the Communications Before and After the Incident Show?

Messages, calls, and other communications may provide context concerning the parties’ relationship and conduct.

Such evidence should not be interpreted from a single message in isolation but examined as part of the complete chronology.

04. What Objective Evidence Exists?

CCTV footage, location records, recordings, transportation records, lodging records, payment records, and digital evidence may corroborate or contradict particular portions of the parties’ accounts.

05. Are the Relevant Statements Consistent with Other Evidence?

The reliability of a statement is evaluated in light of its specific content and the record as a whole.

Consistency or inconsistency should therefore be considered together with objective evidence rather than mechanically determined from minor differences in wording.

06. Does Another Sexual-Offense Provision Apply?

The particular condition of the alleged victim, the nature of the sexual conduct, age, relationship, location, or method may result in application of provisions other than the basic rape offense under Article 297.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

The first investigative statement can become important evidence later in the case.

For that reason, a person under investigation should not attempt to fill gaps in memory with assumptions or provide speculative explanations simply because an immediate answer is expected.

Relevant messages, photographs, recordings, location information, and other digital materials should not be deleted, altered, or selectively edited after an allegation arises.

Likewise, contacting the other party or witnesses for the purpose of persuading them to change or coordinate their statements may create additional investigative concerns.

Where the allegation is disputed, the response should focus on the specific elements of the offense and the objective evidence rather than on attacks against the character of the reporting person.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR VICTIMS

A person reporting sexual violence should preserve relevant evidence where possible and avoid altering or reconstructing records after the incident.

At the same time, the absence of a particular form of physical evidence does not by itself determine whether an offense occurred.

The circumstances of the incident, statements, communications, medical evidence, digital records, and other relevant materials should be considered together.

Where medical care, counseling, or other support is needed, those needs should not be delayed solely for purposes of preserving a criminal case.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Reconstruct the Facts from the Beginning

We examine the relationship between the parties, the alleged incident, and communications and conduct before and after the event to establish a detailed chronology.

02. We Analyze Objective Evidence

We review CCTV footage, text and messenger communications, recordings, location information, lodging records, medical evidence, and other available materials and compare them with the parties’ statements.

03. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues likely to be examined during the investigation and help organize the facts and evidence before substantive questioning.

04. We Analyze the Elements of the Alleged Offense

For suspects and defendants, we examine whether the evidence establishes the violence or intimidation and other elements required for the charged offense.

For victims, we organize the circumstances and supporting evidence so that the allegations can be presented accurately through the investigative process.

05. We Respond According to the Procedural Stage

We provide assistance from the initial police investigation through prosecution and trial, adapting the strategy to the evidence and issues that arise at each stage.

Where the circumstances support a separate damages claim, we review potential civil remedies alongside the criminal proceedings.

IN A RAPE CASE, THE INITIAL STATEMENTS AND THE OBJECTIVE RECORD CAN SHAPE THE ENTIRE COURSE OF THE CASE.

Rape allegations require careful examination of the particular circumstances at the time of the alleged incident, the applicable legal standard, the parties’ statements, and the objective evidence.

Neither an accusation nor a denial should replace a detailed review of what the evidence actually shows.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the relationship between the parties, the circumstances before and after the incident, and available evidence including CCTV footage, communications, recordings, and location records to identify the central factual and legal issues.

Whether you are facing an allegation or reporting sexual violence, preserving the relevant evidence and organizing the facts accurately from the police investigation stage can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

INDECENT ACT BY COMPULSION

Whether Conduct Constitutes an Indecent Act Depends on the Specific Contact, Circumstances, Intent, and Evidence

WHAT IS AN INDECENT ACT BY COMPULSION?

An indecent act by compulsion is a criminal offense under Article 298 of the Korean Criminal Act involving the commission of an indecent act against another person through violence or intimidation.

An “indecent act” is not limited to any particular form of physical contact.

Under Korean Supreme Court precedent, whether conduct constitutes an indecent act is determined by considering whether, viewed objectively, it infringes the other person’s sexual freedom or sexual self-determination, together with the nature of the conduct and the surrounding circumstances.

Relevant considerations may include the alleged victim’s position and age, the prior relationship between the parties, how the incident arose, the nature of the physical conduct, and the objective circumstances surrounding the incident.

Depending on the condition of the alleged victim, the relationship between the parties, the location, and the manner of the conduct, other offenses may also become relevant, including quasi-indecent act by compulsion, indecent acts involving abuse of occupational authority, indecent acts in crowded public places, and aggravated sexual offenses involving intrusion into a residence or other special circumstances.

PENALTIES FOR INDECENT ACT BY COMPULSION

Under Article 298 of the Korean Criminal Act, an indecent act by compulsion is punishable by:

Imprisonment for up to 10 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million

The offense may be investigated and prosecuted without a criminal complaint from the alleged victim.

Depending on the age of the alleged victim, relationship between the parties, location, method of the offense, and other circumstances, separate statutes may apply and may provide for more severe punishment.

The Korean Sentencing Commission currently provides the following sentencing guideline ranges for relevant categories of indecent-act offenses involving victims aged 13 or older.

Indecent Act in a Crowded Public Place

Mitigated: up to 8 months

Standard: 6 months to 1 year

Aggravated: 10 months to 2 years

General Indecent Act by Compulsion

Mitigated: up to 1 year

Standard: 6 months to 2 years

Aggravated: 1 year 6 months to 3 years

Indecent Act by Compulsion Against a Juvenile

Mitigated: 1 year to 2 years

Standard: 1 year 8 months to 3 years 4 months

Aggravated: 2 years 8 months to 4 years 8 months

Indecent Act by Compulsion Involving a Familial Relationship / Aggravated Indecent Act by Compulsion

Mitigated: 2 years 6 months to 4 years

Standard: 3 years to 6 years

Aggravated: 5 years to 8 years

Indecent Act by Compulsion Following Intrusion into a Residence or Similar Conduct

Mitigated: 3 years 6 months to 5 years

Standard: 4 years to 7 years

Aggravated: 6 years to 9 years

Indecent Act by Compulsion Connected with Aggravated Robbery

Mitigated: 5 years to 8 years

Standard: 7 years to 11 years

Aggravated: 9 years to 13 years

These are sentencing guideline ranges, not the statutory penalties automatically applicable to every case.

The actual sentence depends on the offense charged, the nature and seriousness of the conduct, degree of harm, relationship between the parties, criminal history, legally relevant settlement or loss-recovery circumstances, and other applicable sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN AN INDECENT ACT BY COMPULSION CASE

Important issues may include:

whether the alleged physical conduct actually occurred;

what specific conduct constituted the alleged violence or intimidation;

whether the conduct legally qualifies as an indecent act;

whether the accused had the intent required for the alleged indecent conduct;

the part of the body involved and the manner and duration of any contact;

the circumstances immediately before, during, and after the alleged incident;

the relationship between the parties;

communications between the parties before and after the incident;

the alleged victim’s statements and their relationship to the other evidence;

CCTV footage, recordings, messages, witness statements, and other objective evidence; and

whether another sexual-offense provision applies based on the particular circumstances.

Under current Korean Supreme Court precedent, the violence or intimidation required for an indecent act by compulsion does not have to be so strong that it makes resistance difficult.

The Supreme Court has held that “violence” may consist of an unlawful exercise of physical force against another person and that “intimidation” may consist of communicating a threat of harm capable, viewed generally, of causing fear.

Whether particular conduct satisfies this standard is determined by considering the purpose and intent of the conduct, its specific nature and manner, the circumstances in which it occurred, the relationship between the parties, and its effect on the other person.

Accordingly, the absence of severe physical force does not, by itself, mean that the offense cannot be established.

At the same time, the prosecution must still prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the conduct satisfying the statutory elements actually occurred and that the accused possessed the required intent.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR INDECENT ACT BY COMPULSION CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Incident and the Alleged Contact

We examine whether physical contact occurred, what part of the body was allegedly involved, how the contact occurred, the location and surrounding circumstances, and the conduct of the parties before and after the incident.

A detailed chronology is prepared based on actual memory and available evidence.

STEP 02 | Analyze the Alleged Indecent Conduct and Intent

We examine whether the particular conduct legally constitutes an indecent act and whether the evidence supports the intent required for the charged offense.

The relationship between the parties and the circumstances in which the conduct occurred are reviewed together with the physical act itself.

STEP 03 | Secure and Analyze Objective Evidence

Relevant evidence may include:

CCTV footage;

text and messenger communications;

audio recordings;

photographs;

location information;

witness statements; and

other digital or documentary records.

We compare this evidence with the parties’ accounts to identify points of consistency, contradiction, or uncertainty.

STEP 04 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview

Before questioning, we identify the principal factual and legal issues and review the chronology of the incident.

The objective is not to rehearse a predetermined statement, but to reduce speculation and ensure that responses are based on actual memory and objective facts.

STEP 05 | Respond During the Investigation

We submit relevant evidence and legal arguments concerning matters that are unsupported or disputed and review whether the evidence establishes each element of the alleged offense.

Where supported by the record, we pursue an appropriate investigative outcome, including a police decision not to refer the case for prosecution or a prosecutorial non-indictment disposition.

STEP 06 | Criminal Trial and Sentencing Response

If charges are filed, we analyze the indictment, statements, and objective evidence and prepare the defense for trial.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we separately prepare legally appropriate sentencing materials concerning matters such as the individual’s degree of participation, efforts toward recovery of harm, relevant settlement circumstances, remorse, and other case-specific factors.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Organize the Circumstances of the Incident

We carefully identify the nature and location of the alleged contact, statements or conduct by the accused, surrounding circumstances, and events before and after the incident.

STEP 02 | Preserve Relevant Evidence

Potential evidence may include:

CCTV footage;

text and messenger communications;

audio recordings;

photographs;

clothing or other relevant physical materials;

medical or counseling records where applicable; and

witness information.

Because CCTV footage and some digital records may be deleted with the passage of time, preservation should be considered promptly.

STEP 03 | Prepare for Investigative Interviews

Before an investigative interview, we organize the chronology and principal facts so that the incident can be explained accurately and concretely.

The focus is on accurately communicating what was experienced and remembered rather than attempting to create artificial consistency.

STEP 04 | File a Criminal Complaint and Respond During the Investigation

Where appropriate, we assist with preparation of a criminal complaint and supporting evidence and submit necessary statements and legal opinions during the investigation.

STEP 05 | Assistance During Criminal Trial

After prosecution, we assist with procedures available to the victim, including submission of appropriate materials concerning the circumstances and impact of the alleged offense.

Alongside the criminal proceedings, we consider available protective measures and whether a separate civil damages claim may be appropriate for legally compensable harm.

WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED IN AN INDECENT ACT BY COMPULSION CASE?

01. What Physical Conduct Actually Occurred?

The exact act should be identified rather than described only through broad conclusions.

The location, manner, duration, physical movement, surrounding circumstances, and sequence of events should be reconstructed as precisely as possible.

02. Does the Conduct Legally Constitute an Indecent Act?

Physical contact alone does not automatically answer the legal question.

The nature of the act, its context, the relationship between the parties, and the surrounding objective circumstances must be considered together.

03. Was the Required Intent Present?

The prosecution must establish the intent required for the alleged offense.

The fact that physical contact occurred does not necessarily establish, without further analysis, that the accused acted with the intent associated with an indecent act.

04. What Constituted the Alleged Violence or Intimidation?

Under current Supreme Court precedent, violence or intimidation need not rise to the level of making resistance difficult.

The specific physical force or threatening conduct alleged should nevertheless be identified and analyzed under the current legal standard.

05. What Do the Objective Records Show?

CCTV footage, communications, recordings, location data, photographs, and witness evidence may be important in determining what occurred and whether the parties’ accounts are supported by the surrounding record.

06. How Should the Parties’ Statements Be Evaluated?

Statements should be examined in their entirety and compared with the objective evidence.

Minor differences in wording do not automatically determine credibility, just as consistency alone does not automatically establish that a statement is accurate.

7. DOES ANOTHER SEXUAL-OFFENSE PROVISION APPLY?

The condition or age of the alleged victim, the relationship between the parties, use of occupational authority, location of the incident, intrusion into a residence, or other circumstances may result in a different offense or enhanced statutory penalty.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

The initial police interview may become important throughout the later investigation and trial.

Relevant messages, CCTV footage, recordings, photographs, and other digital evidence should therefore be preserved rather than deleted or altered after an allegation arises.

A person under investigation should also avoid filling gaps in memory with assumptions simply to provide an immediate explanation.

Likewise, contacting the reporting person or witnesses for the purpose of coordinating, changing, or influencing statements may create additional legal concerns.

Where the allegation is disputed, the response should focus on the specific conduct, statutory elements, and objective evidence rather than personal attacks against the reporting person.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR VICTIMS

Relevant evidence should be preserved as early as reasonably possible, particularly where CCTV footage or digital information may later become unavailable.

However, the absence of CCTV footage, physical injury, or a particular type of evidence does not by itself determine whether an offense occurred.

The circumstances of the incident, statements, communications, witness evidence, and other available records should be considered together.

A person seeking medical care, counseling, or other support should not delay necessary assistance solely because of concerns about the criminal proceedings.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Reconstruct the Incident in Detail

We examine the time, location, relationship between the parties, alleged physical contact, surrounding circumstances, and events before and after the incident.

We assess the alleged indecent conduct, violence or intimidation, required intent, and whether another sexual-offense provision may apply.

03. We Examine Objective Evidence

We analyze CCTV footage, text and messenger communications, recordings, witness statements, photographs, and other objective records and compare them with the parties’ statements.

04. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the chronology and evidence before substantive questioning.

05. We Develop a Strategy Appropriate to Each Party’s Position

For suspects and defendants, we focus on whether the statutory elements are established, the required intent, the objective evidence, and the reliability of the evidentiary record.

For victims, we organize the circumstances of the incident and available evidence so that the allegations and resulting harm can be communicated accurately throughout the investigation and trial.

Veteran Law Firm provides representation from the initial police investigation through prosecution and criminal trial and, where appropriate, reviews related protective measures and civil damages claims.

IN AN INDECENT ACT BY COMPULSION CASE, THE LEGAL QUESTION CANNOT BE ANSWERED BY THE FACT OF PHYSICAL CONTACT ALONE.

The specific nature of the conduct, the circumstances in which it occurred, the required intent, the parties’ statements, and the objective evidence must all be examined together.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the chronology of the incident, the relationship between the parties, the alleged physical conduct, CCTV footage, communications, recordings, and other evidence to identify the central factual and legal issues.

Whether you are facing an allegation or reporting an indecent act, preserving the relevant evidence and organizing the facts accurately from the police investigation stage can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

DIGITAL SEX CRIMES

Digital Evidence Can Spread in Seconds—and It Can Become the Central Evidence in a Criminal Case

WHAT ARE DIGITAL SEX CRIMES?

Digital sex crimes are sexual offenses committed through smartphones, the internet, social media, messaging platforms, artificial intelligence, and other digital technologies.

They may involve non-consensual recording, distribution of intimate images or videos, creation or distribution of manipulated sexual content and deepfakes, possession or viewing of certain unlawful materials, and conduct involving child or youth sexual exploitation materials.

One increasingly significant category involves sexually explicit or humiliating deepfake content created by using artificial intelligence or other technology to manipulate a person’s face, body, or voice.

Under Korea’s Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes, criminal liability may arise from editing, synthesizing, or processing images, video, or audio of an identifiable person against that person’s will in a form capable of causing sexual desire or sexual humiliation.

Distribution of such manipulated material may constitute a separate offense, and possession, purchase, storage, or viewing may also be punishable under the circumstances prescribed by law.

Depending on the content, age of the person depicted, manner of distribution, and other circumstances, additional statutes—including the Act on the Protection of Children and Youth Against Sex Offenses—may apply.

Digital sex crimes are particularly serious because unlawful material can spread to large numbers of people within a very short period of time.

Once an image or video has been uploaded, copied, or redistributed, complete removal may become difficult, allowing the harm to continue long after the initial act.

COMMON TYPES OF DIGITAL SEX CRIMES

Non-Consensual Recording

Criminal liability may arise where a person uses a camera, smartphone, or similar device to record another person’s body against that person’s will under circumstances covered by the applicable sexual-offense statute.

The precise nature of what was recorded, the circumstances of the recording, and whether consent existed are important issues.

Distribution of Unlawfully Recorded Material

Separate liability may arise from distributing, selling, leasing, providing, publicly displaying, or otherwise disseminating unlawfully recorded sexual material.

Even where the original recording was made with consent, subsequent distribution against the subject’s will may constitute an offense under applicable law.

Deepfake and Manipulated Sexual Content

These cases involve editing, synthesizing, or processing another person’s face, body, or voice into sexualized images, video, or audio without that person’s consent.

Artificial intelligence is frequently used, but the legal issue is not limited to any particular technology.

The actual method of manipulation, the identity of the person depicted, the nature of the resulting material, and the accused person’s knowledge and intent should all be examined.

Distribution of Manipulated Sexual Content

Distributing or otherwise making manipulated sexual material available to others may constitute a separate offense from creating the material itself.

The platform used, number of recipients, public accessibility, repetition, and whether the conduct was committed for profit may significantly affect the legal analysis.

Possession, Purchase, Storage, or Viewing

Under current law, certain unlawful recordings and manipulated sexual materials may give rise to criminal liability not only when produced or distributed but also when knowingly possessed, purchased, stored, or viewed.

It is therefore important to distinguish precisely what material was present on a device, how it was obtained, whether it was knowingly retained or accessed, and what the digital evidence actually demonstrates.

Child or Youth Sexual Exploitation Materials

Where the material constitutes child or youth sexual exploitation material, substantially different statutory provisions and more severe penalties may apply.

Production, distribution, purchase, possession, and viewing must therefore be analyzed separately under the law applicable to children and youth.

Under Article 14-2 of the Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes, a person who, against the will of the person depicted, edits, synthesizes, or processes an image, video, or audio recording of that person’s face, body, or voice into a form capable of causing sexual desire or sexual humiliation may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million

Distribution of Manipulated Sexual Content

A person who distributes or otherwise disseminates qualifying manipulated material may also be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million

Distribution for Profit Through an Information and Communications Network

Where the statutory requirements for profit-motivated distribution are satisfied:

Imprisonment for at least 3 years

Possession, Purchase, Storage, or Viewing

Possession, purchase, storage, or viewing of qualifying manipulated sexual material may be punishable by:

Imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 30 million

Habitual offenses may be subject to enhanced punishment where the statutory requirements are satisfied.

CURRENT SENTENCING GUIDELINES

The Korean Sentencing Commission provides the following guideline ranges for offenses involving false or manipulated sexual images.

Editing, Synthesis, or Processing

Mitigated: up to 8 months

Standard: 6 months to 1 year 6 months

Aggravated: 10 months to 2 years 6 months

Distribution and Similar Conduct

Mitigated: up to 8 months

Standard: 6 months to 1 year 6 months

Aggravated: 10 months to 2 years 6 months

Distribution for Profit

Mitigated: 4 months to 1 year 4 months

Standard: 1 year to 2 years 6 months

Aggravated: 1 year 6 months to 4 years

These are sentencing guideline ranges rather than the statutory punishment automatically imposed in every case.

The actual sentence may vary depending on the offense charged, method of conduct, number of victims, extent of distribution, profit motive, repetition, degree of harm, prior criminal history, efforts to prevent further dissemination or repair the harm, and other applicable sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN A DIGITAL SEX CRIME CASE

Important issues may include:

whether the conduct involved recording, creation, editing, synthesis, processing, storage, transmission, distribution, or another act;

whether the relevant material was an actual recording or manipulated content;

whether the person depicted can be identified;

whether the recording, creation, or distribution occurred against that person’s will;

what the accused knew about the content and circumstances;

whether the material was intentionally possessed, stored, purchased, or viewed;

whether transmission or broader distribution actually occurred;

who created, uploaded, forwarded, or downloaded the material;

whether the material concerns a child or youth;

whether the conduct was repeated or committed for profit; and

what the forensic and digital records actually establish.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR DIGITAL SEX CRIME CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Identify the Specific Conduct and Applicable Law

We distinguish among recording, creation, editing, synthesis, processing, possession, storage, transmission, distribution, and other alleged conduct.

We also identify the person or material involved, whether consent existed, and which statutory provision may apply.

STEP 02 | Determine How the Investigation Began and Analyze the Digital Evidence

We examine whether the investigation began through a criminal complaint, platform report, digital monitoring, another suspect’s statement, or another source.

We then identify the scope of digital evidence obtained from smartphones, computers, cloud accounts, messaging applications, and other sources.

STEP 03 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview

Before substantive questioning, we organize the chronology and key issues, including knowledge, intent, creation of the material, storage, and alleged distribution.

The objective is to ensure that statements are based on actual facts and are consistent with the available digital evidence rather than speculation.

STEP 04 | Analyze How the Digital Material Was Created, Stored, and Transmitted

Digital files may contain information concerning creation, download, modification, transmission, access, and deletion.

We examine how the evidence relates to each alleged act and whether the material supports the prosecution’s interpretation.

STEP 05 | Respond During the Investigation

Where allegations are unsupported or overstated, we submit relevant evidence and legal arguments and distinguish conduct that can be established from conduct that cannot.

Where supported by the record, we pursue an appropriate investigative outcome, including a police decision not to refer the case for prosecution or a prosecutorial non-indictment disposition.

STEP 06 | Criminal Trial and Sentencing Response

If charges are filed, we analyze the indictment and digital evidence and prepare for trial.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we consider legally appropriate sentencing materials, including genuine efforts to prevent further dissemination, recovery of harm, settlement-related circumstances, remorse, and other relevant factors.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Identify How the Material Was Created and Distributed

We determine how the photograph, video, or manipulated content was created, when distribution began, where it was uploaded, and which platforms, websites, chat rooms, or accounts were involved.

STEP 02 | Preserve Evidence

Relevant evidence may include:

URLs;

screenshots;

account and profile information;

transmission records;

upload dates and times;

messages and chat records;

platform information; and

other records showing creation or distribution.

Evidence should be preserved carefully without unnecessarily redistributing the unlawful material.

STEP 03 | Prepare for Investigative Interviews and Victim Protection Procedures

We organize the circumstances of the offense before investigative questioning and review available procedures designed to reduce unnecessary secondary harm during the investigation.

STEP 04 | Seek Removal and Prevention of Further Distribution

Where appropriate, we assist in organizing the information necessary to request removal, blocking, or other measures intended to limit continued circulation.

We also review whether specialized victim-support organizations or platform procedures can assist with removal efforts.

STEP 05 | Assistance During Criminal Trial

If the accused is prosecuted, we assist with available victim procedures and, where appropriate, submit materials addressing the scope and continuing impact of the harm.

STEP 06 | Consider Civil Damages

Separate from the criminal proceedings, we review whether a civil damages claim may be available for emotional distress, economic loss, or other legally compensable harm caused by the digital sexual offense.

WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED IN A DIGITAL SEX CRIME INVESTIGATION?

01. What Exactly Did the Individual Do?

“Digital sex crime” is a broad category rather than a single criminal offense.

Creating a file, editing it, possessing it, transmitting it to one person, uploading it publicly, and selling it are legally distinct acts that may be governed by different provisions.

02. What Does the Digital Evidence Actually Show?

The existence of a file on a device does not necessarily answer every question about how it was created or obtained.

File information, application records, cloud synchronization, communications, transmission history, and other forensic evidence should be examined in context.

03. Was the Person Depicted Identifiable?

In manipulated-content cases, it may be necessary to determine whether the image, video, or audio concerns an identifiable person and what parts of that person’s face, body, or voice were used.

04. What Was the Accused Person’s Knowledge and Intent?

The relevant mental element depends on the particular offense.

It is necessary to examine what the person knew about the material, how it was obtained or created, and what conduct was intentionally performed.

Consent to a photograph or recording does not necessarily constitute consent to editing or later distribution.

The scope and timing of consent should therefore be examined separately for recording, manipulation, and dissemination.

06. Was the Material Merely Stored, or Was It Distributed?

Possession or storage and distribution are distinct forms of conduct.

However, under current law, certain forms of knowing possession, purchase, storage, or viewing can themselves be punishable.

The legal analysis therefore requires more than simply asking whether the material was publicly uploaded.

07. DOES THE MATERIAL INVOLVE A CHILD OR YOUTH?

Where child or youth sexual exploitation material is involved, separate and substantially more severe statutes may apply.

The age of the person depicted and the legal classification of the material should therefore be confirmed at the beginning of the case.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

Digital evidence should not be deleted, altered, reformatted, or selectively removed after an investigation begins or is anticipated.

Attempts to delete accounts, messages, cloud records, or files may create additional evidentiary issues and may not eliminate copies already preserved by platforms or investigative authorities.

A person under investigation should also avoid contacting other participants for the purpose of aligning accounts or coordinating explanations.

Before making substantive statements, it is important to identify precisely which files and acts are under investigation and distinguish actual memory from assumptions about how a file appeared on a device.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR VICTIMS

Because digital material can be copied and redistributed rapidly, preservation and removal efforts may need to proceed at the same time.

However, repeatedly forwarding unlawful material merely to create evidence may unnecessarily expand its circulation.

Where possible, evidence such as URLs, screenshots, account information, upload times, and platform records should be preserved in a way that minimizes further dissemination.

The continuing circulation of material can also make prompt removal and blocking efforts particularly important.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Identify the Specific Conduct and Applicable Offense

We distinguish recording, editing, synthesis, processing, possession, storage, transmission, and distribution and determine which statutory provisions may apply to each alleged act.

02. We Analyze Digital Evidence

We examine available information concerning smartphones, messaging applications, cloud accounts, digital files, communications, and transmission history and compare it with the allegations and statements.

03. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the digital and factual issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the chronology and evidence before substantive questioning.

04. We Analyze Knowledge, Intent, and Individual Responsibility

Where several individuals or accounts are involved, we determine who created, edited, possessed, transmitted, or distributed the material and what conduct and intent can properly be attributed to each person.

05. We Assist Victims with Evidence Preservation and Removal Measures

For victims, we organize evidence concerning creation and distribution, assist with investigative procedures, and review available measures for removal and prevention of further circulation.

Veteran Law Firm provides representation from the initial police investigation through prosecution and criminal trial and, where appropriate, reviews victim protection measures and related civil damages claims.

IN A DIGITAL SEX CRIME CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A FILE EXISTED, BUT WHO CREATED, POSSESSED, TRANSMITTED, OR DISTRIBUTED IT—AND WHAT THE DIGITAL EVIDENCE ACTUALLY SHOWS.

Digital sex crime cases may involve multiple distinct acts and multiple statutes within a single set of facts.

The type of material, consent, identity of the person depicted, creation and transmission history, knowledge and intent, and scope of distribution should therefore be examined separately.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the circumstances of the incident together with smartphone, messenger, cloud, platform, and other digital evidence to identify the conduct that can actually be established and the law applicable to each part of the case.

Whether you are facing an allegation or seeking assistance as a victim, preserving the digital evidence and accurately identifying the creation and distribution history from the police investigation stage can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING AND DISTRIBUTION

The Legal Issues Depend Not Only on Whether a Recording Was Made, but Also on Consent, the Content Recorded, and What Happened to the Material Afterwards

WHAT IS NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING?

Under Article 14 of Korea’s Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes, criminal liability may arise where a person uses a camera or similar device to record another person’s body against that person’s will where the recording is capable of causing sexual desire or sexual humiliation.

The statute also prohibits certain forms of distribution, sale, lease, provision, public exhibition, or screening of such recordings or copies.

Importantly, criminal liability may also arise where the original recording was made with the subject’s consent—or even where the person recorded his or her own body—but the material is later distributed against that person’s will.

For that reason, an investigation should not focus solely on whether a recording exists.

Relevant issues may include:

whether the person consented to the recording;

what part of the body was recorded;

whether the recording falls within the scope protected by Article 14;

how and why the recording was made;

whether the material was subsequently stored, transmitted, or distributed; and

what the accused knew and intended at each stage.

PENALTIES FOR NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING AND DISTRIBUTION

The statutory penalty depends on the specific conduct involved.

Non-Consensual Recording

Recording another person’s body in violation of Article 14(1) may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million

Distribution and Similar Conduct

Distributing, selling, leasing, providing, publicly exhibiting, or screening qualifying recordings or copies—including certain recordings that were originally made with consent but later distributed against the subject’s will—may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million

Distribution for Profit Through an Information and Communications Network

Where the statutory requirements for profit-motivated distribution are satisfied:

Imprisonment for at least 3 years

Possession, Purchase, Storage, or Viewing

The possession, purchase, storage, or viewing of qualifying recordings or copies may also constitute a separate offense and may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 30 million

Habitual commission of certain offenses under Article 14 may result in enhanced punishment.

CURRENT SENTENCING GUIDELINES

The Korean Sentencing Commission provides sentencing guideline ranges according to the type and seriousness of the conduct.

Recording

Mitigated: 4 months to 10 months

Standard: 8 months to 2 years

Aggravated: 1 year to 3 years

Distribution and Similar Conduct

Mitigated: 4 months to 1 year 4 months

Standard: 1 year to 2 years 6 months

Aggravated: 1 year 6 months to 4 years

Distribution for Profit

Mitigated: 1 year 6 months to 4 years

Standard: 2 years 6 months to 6 years

Aggravated: 4 years to 8 years

These are sentencing guideline ranges, not statutory penalties automatically imposed in every case.

The actual sentence may vary depending on the nature of the recording, number of offenses, extent of distribution, profit motive, degree of harm, prior criminal history, efforts to prevent further dissemination or recover the harm, and other applicable sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN A NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING CASE

The existence of a photograph or video does not, by itself, resolve every legal issue.

Important questions may include:

whether the recording actually occurred;

whether it was made against the subject’s will;

whether the body part and manner of recording fall within the scope of Article 14;

whether consent existed at the time of recording;

the scope of any consent that was given;

the circumstances and purpose of the recording;

whether the accused intentionally engaged in the conduct at issue;

whether the material was merely created or was also transmitted or distributed;

whether the material or copies were knowingly possessed, purchased, stored, or viewed; and

what the digital evidence demonstrates concerning creation, storage, transmission, and distribution.

Consent to being recorded and consent to distribution are separate legal questions.

Even where a person agreed to the original recording, later distribution against that person’s will may constitute a criminal offense.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Circumstances of the Recording

We examine where and how the recording was made, what was recorded, the relationship between the parties, the circumstances at the time, and whether consent was given.

STEP 02 | Identify the Specific Conduct and Applicable Offense

We distinguish among recording, possession, storage, transmission, distribution, sale, provision, and other alleged conduct and determine which provisions may apply to each act.

STEP 03 | Analyze Digital Evidence

We examine relevant information from smartphones, computers, messaging applications, cloud services, and other digital sources.

The creation, storage, transmission, and distribution history of the material is compared with the statements made during the investigation.

STEP 04 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview

Before police questioning, we identify the principal factual and legal issues and organize the chronology based on actual facts and objective evidence.

The purpose is not to prepare an artificial or predetermined account, but to avoid speculation and unnecessary inconsistencies during questioning.

STEP 05 | Respond During the Investigation

Where the allegations are disputed, we analyze whether the evidence establishes non-consensual recording, the required intent, distribution, or other charged conduct and submit supporting materials and legal arguments where appropriate.

Where supported by the evidence, we pursue an appropriate investigative outcome, including a police decision not to refer the case for prosecution or a prosecutorial non-indictment disposition.

STEP 06 | Criminal Trial and Sentencing Response

If charges are filed, we analyze the indictment, digital evidence, and other prosecution materials and prepare for trial.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review appropriate measures concerning prevention of further dissemination, recovery of harm, legally appropriate settlement efforts, remorse, and other sentencing considerations.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Identify How the Recording Was Made

We organize when and where the recording occurred, what was recorded, whether consent existed, and how the victim became aware of the recording.

STEP 02 | Preserve Evidence

Potential evidence may include:

screenshots;

URLs;

messages and transmission records;

account or profile information;

recordings or photographs relating to the incident;

platform information;

witness information; and

other digital records showing possession or distribution.

Evidence should be preserved carefully without unnecessarily redistributing the unlawful material.

STEP 03 | Organize the Facts Before the Police Investigation

We organize the circumstances of the recording and any subsequent distribution so that the relevant facts can be communicated accurately during the investigation.

STEP 04 | Seek Removal and Prevention of Further Distribution

Where the material has been distributed online, we review available procedures for requesting removal, blocking, and prevention of further dissemination and consider assistance through relevant victim-support services.

STEP 05 | Respond During Investigation and Trial

We assist with criminal complaints, submission of supporting evidence and legal opinions, and procedures available to victims after prosecution.

STEP 06 | Review Civil Damages and Other Remedies

Separate from the criminal proceedings, we consider whether a civil damages claim or other legal remedy may be available for emotional distress, economic loss, or other legally compensable harm.

WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED IN A NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING INVESTIGATION?

01. What Was Actually Recorded?

It is necessary to examine the content and composition of the photograph or video rather than assuming that every unauthorized recording automatically falls within Article 14.

The body part depicted, clothing, angle, distance, location, manner of recording, and overall circumstances may all become relevant.

02. Was the Recording Against the Subject’s Will?

Consent is a central issue in many cases.

The communications between the parties, circumstances of the recording, prior conduct, and other objective evidence should be examined to determine whether consent existed.

Consent to one particular photograph or recording does not necessarily amount to consent to additional recordings or to later transmission or distribution.

The precise scope of the consent should therefore be identified.

04. Was the Recording Distributed?

Creation of a recording and distribution of that recording are legally distinct forms of conduct.

Messages, upload records, platform activity, cloud data, and other digital evidence may be important in determining whether and how the material was transmitted.

05. Was the Material Knowingly Possessed or Viewed?

Under current law, certain forms of possession, purchase, storage, or viewing may themselves be punishable.

The existence of a file on a device should therefore be examined together with how the file was obtained, stored, accessed, or viewed.

06. What Does the Digital Evidence Actually Show?

A file discovered on a device does not necessarily establish every allegation concerning its creation or distribution.

Metadata where available, application records, cloud synchronization, transmission history, communications, and other digital information should be examined in context.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

Do not delete or alter photographs, videos, messages, cloud data, or other digital records after an investigation begins or is anticipated.

Deleting data may create additional evidentiary concerns and may not remove copies already preserved by platforms, recipients, or investigative authorities.

A person under investigation should also avoid contacting the reporting person or other relevant individuals for the purpose of coordinating statements or persuading them to change their account.

Where the allegations are disputed, the response should focus on the specific recording, consent, statutory elements, and digital evidence rather than assumptions about what investigators may have obtained.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR VICTIMS

Where unlawful distribution is suspected, evidence preservation and efforts to prevent further dissemination may need to proceed simultaneously.

Screenshots, URLs, account information, transmission records, and platform details should be preserved where possible without repeatedly forwarding the material.

Because online material can be copied rapidly, prompt consideration of removal and blocking measures may be important.

Necessary medical, counseling, or other support should not be delayed solely because a criminal investigation is pending.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Analyze Whether the Recording Falls Within the Applicable Statute

We examine the content of the recording, body part depicted, circumstances, consent, and method of recording to determine whether the alleged conduct falls within Article 14.

02. We Distinguish Recording from Distribution and Other Conduct

We separately analyze recording, possession, storage, transmission, distribution, and profit-motivated dissemination rather than treating all digital activity as a single offense.

03. We Analyze Digital Evidence

We review available smartphone, messaging, cloud, platform, and other digital evidence to determine how the material was created, stored, accessed, or transmitted.

04. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the facts and evidence before substantive questioning.

05. We Develop a Strategy Appropriate to the Evidence

Where the allegations are disputed, we examine consent, intent, the scope of the statutory offense, and the objective digital record.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review measures concerning prevention of further dissemination, recovery of harm, settlement-related circumstances, and sentencing.

Veteran Law Firm provides representation from the initial police investigation through prosecution and criminal trial and, where appropriate, assists victims with evidence preservation, removal measures, and related civil damages claims.

IN A NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A CAMERA WAS USED, BUT WHAT WAS RECORDED, WHETHER THERE WAS CONSENT, AND WHAT HAPPENED TO THE MATERIAL AFTERWARDS.

The legal analysis may change significantly depending on the nature of the recording, the circumstances and scope of consent, whether the material was distributed, and what the digital evidence shows.

Veteran Law Firm examines the circumstances of the recording together with smartphone data, communications, transmission records, and other objective evidence to identify the conduct that can actually be established and the law applicable to each part of the case.

Whether you are facing an allegation or seeking assistance as a victim, preserving the relevant digital evidence and accurately reconstructing the recording and distribution history from the police investigation stage can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

COMMERCIAL SEX ACTS

A Commercial Sex Act Case Depends Not Only on Whether Sexual Conduct Occurred, but Also on Whether There Was an Exchange of Money or Other Economic Benefit and What Role Each Person Played

WHAT ARE COMMERCIAL SEX ACTS?

Under Korea’s Act on the Punishment of Arrangement of Commercial Sex Acts, a commercial sex act generally means engaging in sexual intercourse or specified forms of similar sexual conduct with an unspecified person—or becoming the counterpart to such conduct—in exchange for receiving or agreeing to receive money or another property benefit.

Criminal liability is not limited to the person purchasing or selling sex.

The Act also regulates conduct such as arranging, soliciting, inducing, or coercing commercial sex acts, providing a place for such acts, and knowingly providing funds, land, or buildings for use in commercial sex acts.

Where arrangement is carried out as a business or where compensation is received for recruiting or arranging persons to sell sex, more serious statutory penalties may apply.

For that reason, a commercial sex act case requires more than simply determining whether sexual conduct occurred.

The investigation may need to examine:

whether money or another property benefit was exchanged or promised;

whether the sexual conduct was provided in return for that benefit;

the specific role of each person involved;

how and why money was transferred;

communications between the parties;

where and how the meeting was arranged; and

whether another person operated, arranged, advertised, or provided a location for the conduct.

COMMON TYPES OF COMMERCIAL SEX ACT CASES

Purchasing or Selling Commercial Sex

These cases involve allegations that sexual intercourse or similar sexual conduct occurred in exchange for money or another economic benefit.

The existence of sexual conduct alone does not resolve whether a commercial sex act occurred.

The alleged exchange relationship between the benefit and the sexual conduct must be examined.

Arrangement of Commercial Sex Acts

Criminal liability may arise where a person arranges, solicits, induces, or otherwise facilitates commercial sex acts.

The investigation may focus on communications, introductions, reservation records, payment arrangements, and the person’s actual role in connecting the parties.

Providing a Place for Commercial Sex Acts

Providing a room, business premises, or another location for commercial sex acts may fall within the statutory definition of arrangement-related conduct.

Whether the provider knew how the premises were being used can become an important issue.

Operating a Commercial Sex Business

Where commercial sex acts are arranged or facilitated as an ongoing business, substantially more serious punishment may apply.

The investigation may examine the duration and scale of the operation, number of persons involved, revenue, division of roles, advertising, communications, and financial records.

Recruiting or Referring Persons to Sell Sex

Recruiting individuals to sell sex or providing employment introductions or referrals for that purpose may also constitute a separate form of prohibited conduct.

Where compensation is received for recruitment or referral, enhanced statutory provisions may apply.

ONLINE AND MESSENGER-BASED ARRANGEMENT

Commercial sex act investigations increasingly involve messaging applications, online advertisements, community platforms, reservation messages, call records, location information, and electronic payments.

It is therefore important to determine who operated an account, who communicated with the parties, and what the digital records actually show about each person’s involvement.

STATUTORY PENALTIES

The applicable punishment depends significantly on the specific role and conduct involved.

Engaging in a Commercial Sex Act

A person who engages in a commercial sex act under the Act may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 1 year or a fine of up to KRW 3 million, detention, or a minor fine

Arrangement and Similar Conduct

A person who arranges commercial sex acts, recruits persons to sell sex, or provides employment introductions or referrals for such purposes may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 30 million

Arrangement as a Business

A person who engages in arrangement of commercial sex acts as a business, or receives compensation for specified recruitment or job-placement conduct, may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 70 million

The applicable offense should therefore be identified by the person’s actual conduct rather than simply describing everyone involved as a “participant in prostitution.”

CURRENT SENTENCING GUIDELINES FOR ARRANGEMENT OF COMMERCIAL SEX ACTS

For offenses involving persons aged 19 or older, the Korean Sentencing Commission currently provides the following guideline ranges.

Arrangement of Commercial Sex Acts and Similar Conduct

Mitigated: up to 6 months

Standard: 4 months to 10 months

Aggravated: 8 months to 1 year 6 months

Commercial Arrangement or Arrangement Involving Compensation

Mitigated: up to 8 months

Standard: 6 months to 1 year 4 months

Aggravated: 1 year to 3 years

These are sentencing guideline ranges and should not be confused with the statutory maximum penalties.

The actual outcome may vary depending on the specific offense, duration and scale of the conduct, commercial nature of the operation, amount of profit, degree of participation, criminal history, and other applicable sentencing factors.

Where a child or youth is involved, separate legislation applies and substantially different penalties may be imposed.

KEY ISSUES IN A COMMERCIAL SEX ACT CASE

01. What Was the Individual’s Actual Role?

One of the first questions is whether the person was alleged to have purchased or sold sex, arranged the meeting, operated a business, recruited participants, provided a location, advertised the service, or performed another role.

Different conduct may fall under different statutory provisions and penalty structures.

02. Was There an Exchange Relationship?

The fact that sexual conduct occurred does not necessarily establish a commercial sex act.

It is necessary to determine whether money or another property benefit was received or promised in exchange for the sexual conduct.

Messages, payment records, the timing of the transfer, and the circumstances of the meeting may all be relevant.

03. What Was the Purpose of the Payment?

A transfer of money does not automatically establish payment for a commercial sex act.

The amount, timing, communications between the parties, and reason for the payment should be examined together.

04. Was the Person Actually Involved in Arrangement?

In multi-person cases, the fact that someone communicated with an operator, drove another person, handled a payment, or was present at a location does not by itself determine the precise scope of criminal liability.

What the person knew and what role the person intentionally performed must be examined individually.

05. Was the Conduct Part of a Business Operation?

Because operating an arrangement business can carry substantially heavier statutory punishment than non-business arrangement, investigators may examine repetition, profit, organizational structure, advertising, customer management, and division of proceeds.

06. What Do the Communications and Financial Records Show?

Relevant evidence may include:

text and messenger communications;

online advertisements;

call records;

bank transfers;

cash withdrawal records;

reservation records;

CCTV footage;

location information;

accommodation or business records; and

statements from other persons involved.

These materials should be reviewed together rather than relying on any single message or payment in isolation.

  1. DOES THE CASE INVOLVE A PERSON LEGALLY TREATED AS A VICTIM OF COMMERCIAL SEX ACTS?

Korean law separately defines persons who are victims of commercial sex acts, including certain persons subjected to coercion, trafficking, or other circumstances specified by statute.

That distinction can fundamentally change the legal analysis.

Accordingly, the circumstances under which a person became involved should be examined before assuming that every person who appears to have sold sex bears the same criminal responsibility.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR COMMERCIAL SEX ACT CASES

STEP 01 | Identify How the Investigation Began and Reconstruct the Incident

We examine whether the case began through police enforcement, a report, another suspect’s statement, digital evidence, or another investigative source.

We then reconstruct the location, communications, payment circumstances, and the client’s actual conduct.

STEP 02 | Determine Whether an Exchange Relationship Can Be Established

We examine whether money or another economic benefit was provided or promised and whether the evidence establishes that it was given in exchange for sexual conduct.

STEP 03 | Identify the Individual’s Role and Applicable Offense

We distinguish among purchasing or selling commercial sex, arranging, providing a location, recruiting, advertising, business operation, and other alleged conduct.

The applicable legal provision and potential punishment are analyzed according to the actual role.

STEP 04 | Analyze Objective Evidence

We review relevant messages, account records, payment history, CCTV footage, accommodation records, location information, and other objective materials and compare them with investigative statements.

STEP 05 | Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Before questioning, we identify the principal facts and legal issues and organize the chronology based on actual memory and objective evidence.

The purpose is not to create a predetermined account, but to ensure that statements accurately distinguish what the person personally did, knew, and observed.

STEP 06 | Respond Through Investigation and Trial

Where the allegations are disputed, we identify discrepancies between the investigative theory and the objective record and submit relevant evidence and legal arguments.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review the person’s actual role, whether the conduct was isolated or repeated, prior criminal history, degree of profit or participation, remorse, and other legally relevant sentencing considerations.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS WHEN FACING A COMMERCIAL SEX ACT INVESTIGATION

Police enforcement or a request to appear for questioning can occur unexpectedly.

However, the fact that a person was present at a particular location, communicated with another participant, or transferred money does not answer every legal question.

The precise conduct alleged should first be identified.

Messages, call records, payment records, and other digital evidence should not be deleted or altered after an investigation begins or is anticipated.

Likewise, contacting other persons involved for the purpose of coordinating statements or creating a common explanation may create additional investigative concerns.

A person under investigation should also avoid making speculative statements about matters that are not actually remembered simply because investigators request an immediate answer.

WHERE THE ALLEGATIONS ARE DISPUTED

The response should focus on the specific statutory elements and objective evidence.

Relevant questions may include:

whether commercial sexual conduct actually occurred;

whether the required exchange relationship existed;

whether the payment had another purpose;

whether the accused arranged or facilitated the conduct;

whether the accused knew that a location or funds would be used for commercial sex acts; and

whether the evidence accurately establishes the alleged role.

WHERE RESPONSIBILITY IS ACKNOWLEDGED

A blanket denial may not be appropriate where the objective evidence clearly establishes the relevant conduct.

Instead, it may be important to define the actual scope of participation accurately.

For example, the analysis may distinguish an isolated act from repeated conduct, an individual participant from a commercial operator, or limited assistance from organized arrangement.

The person’s criminal history, actual benefit obtained, duration and scale of the conduct, genuine remorse, and other legally relevant sentencing materials should then be considered.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Determine Whether the Statutory Requirements for a Commercial Sex Act Are Met

We analyze the sexual conduct, alleged consideration, communications, and payment circumstances to determine whether the statutory definition is satisfied.

02. We Distinguish Each Person’s Actual Role

We separately examine whether the alleged conduct involved purchasing or selling sex, arranging, recruiting, providing premises, advertising, or commercial operation.

03. We Analyze Communications and Financial Evidence

We review messages, call records, bank transactions, reservation records, location information, and other evidence to determine what the objective record actually establishes.

04. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the relevant facts and evidence before substantive questioning.

05. We Distinguish Disputed Allegations from Sentencing Issues

Where the offense is disputed, we focus on the statutory elements and evidentiary issues.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we accurately define the individual’s role and scope of participation and prepare legally relevant materials concerning sentencing.

06. We Provide Representation from Investigation Through Trial

Veteran Law Firm assists from the initial police investigation through prosecution and, where necessary, criminal trial, adapting the response to the evidence and procedural stage of the case.

IN A COMMERCIAL SEX ACT CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER SEXUAL CONDUCT OCCURRED, BUT WHETHER THERE WAS AN EXCHANGE OF ECONOMIC BENEFIT AND WHAT EACH PERSON ACTUALLY DID.

Commercial sex act cases may involve substantially different forms of responsibility depending on whether a person was a party to the transaction, arranged the conduct, provided premises, recruited participants, or operated a business.

The payment history, communications, location, digital records, and each person’s actual knowledge and conduct should therefore be examined separately.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the circumstances of the investigation together with messages, financial records, location information, and other objective evidence to identify the applicable offense and the proper scope of individual responsibility.

If you are facing a commercial sex act investigation, accurately identifying the alleged conduct, payment circumstances, and your actual role before the first substantive police interview can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

CHILD OR YOUTH SEXUAL EXPLOITATION MATERIALS

The Existence of a File Is Only the Beginning of the Analysis—Its Content, How It Was Obtained, and What the Person Knew Must Be Examined Separately

WHAT ARE CHILD OR YOUTH SEXUAL EXPLOITATION MATERIALS?

Under Korea’s Act on the Protection of Children and Youth Against Sex Offenses, “child or youth sexual exploitation materials” are materials depicting a child or youth—or a person or representation clearly recognizable as a child or youth—engaging in sexual conduct specified by law or other sexual acts.

Such material may take the form of films, videos, images, game content, or material displayed or transmitted through computers and other communications media.

Conduct involving child or youth sexual exploitation materials is strictly regulated.

Depending on the specific conduct, criminal liability may arise from:

production;

import or export;

sale or rental;

distribution or provision;

advertising or introduction;

public exhibition or display;

procurement of a child or youth for production;

purchase;

knowing possession; or

knowing viewing.

The fact that a child or youth appeared to consent to the creation of the material does not, by itself, remove the conduct from the statutory protections applicable to child or youth sexual exploitation materials.

Accordingly, an investigation requires more than simply determining whether a file existed on a device.

The content of the material, how it was obtained, whether it was stored or transmitted, what the accused knew about the material, and what conduct was intentionally performed must all be examined carefully.

SEXUAL MATERIAL INVOLVING ADULTS MUST BE DISTINGUISHED

“Sexual exploitation material” is not a single statutory category covering every sexual image or video involving an adult.

Where an adult is depicted, criminal liability may instead arise under different statutes depending on the conduct involved, including laws concerning non-consensual recording, distribution of intimate material, manipulated sexual content, or other sexual offenses.

For that reason, the age and identity of the person depicted and the legal classification of the particular material should be confirmed at the outset.

STATUTORY PENALTIES FOR CHILD OR YOUTH SEXUAL EXPLOITATION MATERIAL OFFENSES

The applicable penalty depends substantially on the specific conduct.

Production, Import, or Export

A person who produces, imports, or exports child or youth sexual exploitation materials may be punished by:

Life imprisonment or imprisonment for at least 5 years

Sale or Distribution for Profit

A person who, for commercial purposes, sells, lends, distributes, or provides such material—or engages in specified conduct for those purposes—may be punished by:

Imprisonment for at least 5 years

Distribution and Similar Conduct

A person who distributes or provides child or youth sexual exploitation materials, advertises or introduces them for distribution, or publicly exhibits or displays them may be punished by:

Imprisonment for at least 3 years

Procuring a Child or Youth for Production

A person who procures a child or youth for the production of child or youth sexual exploitation materials may be punished by:

Imprisonment for at least 3 years

Purchase, Possession, or Viewing

A person who purchases child or youth sexual exploitation materials, or knowingly possesses or views such material, may be punished by:

Imprisonment for at least 1 year

An attempt to commit the production offense is also punishable, and habitual production offenses may be subject to enhanced punishment.

CURRENT SENTENCING GUIDELINES

The Korean Sentencing Commission provides the following sentencing guideline ranges for child or youth sexual exploitation material offenses.

Production and Similar Conduct

Mitigated: 2 years 6 months to 6 years

Standard: 5 years to 9 years

Aggravated: 7 years to 13 years

Sale and Similar Conduct for Profit

Mitigated: 2 years 6 months to 5 years

Standard: 4 years to 8 years

Aggravated: 6 years to 12 years

Distribution and Similar Conduct

Mitigated: 1 year 6 months to 4 years

Standard: 2 years 6 months to 6 years

Aggravated: 4 years to 8 years

Procuring a Child or Youth for Production

Mitigated: 1 year 6 months to 4 years

Standard: 2 years 6 months to 6 years

Aggravated: 4 years to 8 years

Purchase and Similar Conduct

Mitigated: 6 months to 1 year 4 months

Standard: 10 months to 2 years

Aggravated: 1 year 6 months to 3 years

These are sentencing guideline ranges and should not be confused with the statutory penalties applicable to the individual offense.

The actual sentence may vary depending on the specific conduct, number and nature of the materials, duration and repetition of the offense, commercial motive, degree of participation, criminal history, steps taken to prevent further harm, and other legally relevant sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN A SEXUAL EXPLOITATION MATERIAL CASE

01. What Type of Conduct Is Actually Alleged?

Production, distribution, sale, purchase, possession, and viewing are legally distinct forms of conduct.

The first step is therefore to identify precisely what the individual is alleged to have done.

02. Does the Material Meet the Statutory Definition?

It must be determined whether the material actually constitutes child or youth sexual exploitation material under the statute.

The content, person or representation depicted, apparent age, and nature of the sexual conduct should be examined rather than relying solely on a file name or description.

03. How Was the Material Obtained?

The circumstances in which the material appeared on a smartphone, computer, cloud account, or messaging application may be important.

Relevant issues may include whether it was actively downloaded, purchased, received through a message, synchronized through a cloud service, or stored through another process.

04. Did the Individual Know What the Material Was?

Knowledge may become a particularly important issue in possession and viewing cases.

The investigation should distinguish deliberate acquisition or viewing from circumstances in which a file may have been received or technically stored without the person knowingly engaging with the material.

05. Was the Material Stored, Transmitted, or Distributed?

The presence of a file and its subsequent transmission are separate issues.

Messages, upload records, account activity, cloud synchronization, and other digital evidence may help determine whether the material was merely present or was intentionally sent or distributed.

06. What Does the Digital Evidence Actually Establish?

Digital investigations may involve smartphones, computers, cloud accounts, messaging applications, browsing records, and other electronic data.

The fact that data is recovered from a device does not necessarily establish every allegation concerning who created, downloaded, viewed, or transmitted it.

The evidence should be analyzed together with the surrounding chronology and the individual’s actual conduct.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR SEXUAL EXPLOITATION MATERIAL CASES

STEP 01 | Identify the Alleged Conduct and Relevant Material

We distinguish among production, distribution, sale, purchase, possession, viewing, and other alleged conduct and examine how the material was obtained, stored, or transmitted.

STEP 02 | Analyze the Applicable Law and the Classification of the Material

We determine whether the material meets the statutory definition of child or youth sexual exploitation material and identify the provision applicable to the specific conduct alleged.

STEP 03 | Prepare for Police Investigation

We review the evidence likely to be examined by investigators and organize the facts before substantive questioning.

The purpose is to ensure that statements are based on actual memory and the objective record rather than assumptions about how particular files appeared on a device.

STEP 04 | Respond to Search, Seizure, and Digital Forensic Investigation

Where smartphones, computers, cloud accounts, or other digital sources become subject to investigative measures, we review the scope and significance of the evidence obtained and analyze how individual files relate to the allegations.

STEP 05 | Analyze Knowledge and Intent

We examine whether the accused knew the nature of the material, how it was acquired, and whether possession, viewing, transmission, or other alleged conduct was intentional.

Where multiple files or transactions are involved, each category of conduct should be distinguished rather than treated as a single undifferentiated allegation.

STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Trial

Based on the investigative record, we submit relevant evidence and legal arguments concerning disputed allegations.

If charges are filed, we analyze the indictment and digital evidence and prepare for trial.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review legally relevant sentencing considerations, including prior criminal history, the individual’s actual scope of conduct, genuine efforts to prevent further harm or reoffending, and other case-specific circumstances.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS WHEN FACING AN INVESTIGATION

Digital evidence should not be deleted, reformatted, altered, or selectively removed because a police investigation or search is anticipated.

Attempts to delete files, messages, accounts, or cloud records may create separate evidentiary concerns and may not remove copies already preserved elsewhere.

A person under investigation should also avoid contacting other participants for the purpose of coordinating statements or explanations.

Where the allegations are disputed, it is important to determine precisely what files and acts are under investigation rather than generally denying knowledge of all digital material.

In particular, the following issues should be separated carefully:

Was the material actively acquired or merely received?

Was it knowingly possessed or viewed?

Was it intentionally transmitted or distributed?

Did the individual know that the material constituted child or youth sexual exploitation material?

What does the forensic evidence actually show about each alleged act?

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Identify the Specific Conduct at Issue

We distinguish production, sale, distribution, purchase, possession, viewing, and other conduct and determine the legal significance of each alleged act.

02. We Review Whether the Material Falls Within the Statutory Definition

We analyze the content of the material, the person or representation depicted, and the surrounding evidence to determine whether the relevant statutory definition is satisfied.

03. We Analyze Digital Evidence

We examine available information concerning smartphones, computers, messaging applications, cloud accounts, file history, and transmission records and compare the digital evidence with the investigative allegations.

04. We Examine Knowledge and Intent

We review how the material was acquired, stored, accessed, or transmitted and whether the evidence establishes the required knowledge and intentional conduct.

05. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the chronology and relevant evidence before substantive questioning.

06. We Provide Representation from Investigation Through Trial

Veteran Law Firm provides representation from the initial police investigation and digital forensic process through prosecution and criminal trial and, where responsibility is acknowledged, prepares legally appropriate sentencing materials based on the individual circumstances of the case.

IN A SEXUAL EXPLOITATION MATERIAL CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A FILE WAS FOUND, BUT WHAT THE MATERIAL WAS, HOW IT WAS OBTAINED, AND WHAT THE INDIVIDUAL ACTUALLY KNEW AND DID.

These cases frequently depend on detailed digital evidence.

The legal analysis may differ substantially depending on whether the alleged conduct involved production, distribution, purchase, possession, or viewing and whether the evidence establishes the required knowledge and intent.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the content and acquisition history of the material together with smartphone, computer, cloud, messaging, and other digital evidence to identify the conduct that can actually be established and the law applicable to each part of the case.

If you are facing an investigation involving child or youth sexual exploitation materials, preserving the relevant digital evidence and accurately identifying how the material was obtained, stored, viewed, or transmitted from the police investigation stage can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

STALKING

A Stalking Case Requires Review of the Entire Pattern of Contact, Not Just a Single Message or Encounter

WHAT IS STALKING?

Under Korea’s Act on Punishment of Stalking Crimes, stalking generally refers to conduct carried out against another person’s will and without justifiable reason that causes anxiety or fear to that person or certain persons connected to them.

Typical conduct may include repeatedly approaching or following another person, contacting them by phone or message, waiting or watching near their residence or workplace, or delivering objects to them.

Whether conduct constitutes stalking should not be determined by examining an isolated act alone.

The circumstances and frequency of the contact, the other person’s expressed refusal, the relationship between the parties, and the overall pattern of conduct should be reviewed together.

PENALTIES FOR STALKING

The Korean Sentencing Commission provides the following sentencing guideline ranges for stalking offenses.

General Stalking Offense

Mitigated: up to 8 months or a fine of KRW 1 million to KRW 10 million

Standard: 6 months to 1 year or a fine of KRW 5 million to KRW 20 million

Aggravated: 10 months to 2 years 6 months

Stalking Involving a Weapon or Other Dangerous Object

Mitigated: up to 10 months or a fine of KRW 3 million to KRW 20 million

Standard: 8 months to 1 year 6 months

Aggravated: 1 year to 3 years 6 months

The actual outcome may vary depending on the nature and duration of the conduct, number of incidents, degree of fear or harm caused, relationship between the parties, use of a weapon or dangerous object, prior criminal history, and other applicable sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN A STALKING CASE

Important issues may include:

whether the conduct was against the other person’s will;

whether there was a justifiable reason for the contact;

whether the conduct was repeated or continued over time;

how often and in what manner contact occurred;

whether the other person clearly expressed a desire for the contact to stop;

the relationship between the parties before the alleged conduct;

the content and tone of messages or calls;

CCTV footage, location information, call records, and social media messages;

whether a weapon or other dangerous object was carried or used; and

whether emergency or provisional protective measures have been imposed.

WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED IN A STALKING INVESTIGATION?

01. What Contact Actually Occurred?

The specific form of contact should be identified, including calls, text messages, social media messages, visits, following, waiting near a residence or workplace, or delivery of objects.

02. Was the Conduct Against the Other Person’s Will?

It is important to determine whether the other person clearly expressed a desire not to be contacted and what the accused knew about that position.

03. Was There a Justifiable Reason?

The existence of a prior relationship or a legitimate purpose for contact does not automatically resolve the legal issue.

The reason for the contact, its frequency, manner, and continuation after a request to stop should be examined together.

04. Was the Conduct Repeated or Continuous?

Stalking cases often turn on the overall pattern of conduct.

Individual acts should therefore be reviewed chronologically to determine whether they form a repeated or continuing course of behavior.

05. What Does the Objective Evidence Show?

Relevant evidence may include:

text messages;

call records;

social media messages;

CCTV footage;

location and movement records;

recordings;

delivery records; and

witness statements.

These materials should be compared with the statements of the parties to determine what actually occurred.

06. Was a Weapon or Dangerous Object Involved?

Where a weapon or other dangerous object was carried or used during the conduct, the potential criminal responsibility may be substantially greater.

The nature of the object, how it was carried or used, and the surrounding circumstances should be examined carefully.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR STALKING CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Relationship and Contact History

We review the relationship between the parties, the timing and method of contact, communications, visits, and other relevant conduct to organize the overall chronology.

STEP 02 | Analyze the Key Legal Issues Before Police Questioning

We examine whether the conduct was against the other person’s will, whether there was a justifiable reason, and whether the alleged conduct was repeated or continued over time.

STEP 03 | Review Objective Evidence and Respond to the Investigation

We analyze text messages, call records, social media communications, CCTV footage, location data, and other objective evidence and prepare for police questioning based on the actual record.

STEP 04 | Respond to Emergency and Provisional Measures

Where emergency measures, restrictions on approaching or contacting the other person, or other protective measures are imposed, we review the factual and legal basis of those measures and prepare the appropriate response.

Where the allegations are disputed, we organize the relevant evidence and legal arguments and submit appropriate written opinions.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we prepare legally relevant sentencing materials, including efforts to prevent recurrence and other case-specific circumstances.

STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Trial

Based on the investigative record and the central issues in the case, we submit necessary arguments at the prosecution stage and, if charges are filed, continue representation through trial.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS WHEN FACING A STALKING INVESTIGATION

A request from the other person to stop contact should be taken seriously.

Continuing to call, send messages, visit, follow, or otherwise approach the person after a clear refusal may significantly affect how the conduct is evaluated.

Relevant messages, call logs, social media records, CCTV footage, and location information should not be deleted or altered after an investigation begins or is anticipated.

A person under investigation should also avoid contacting the other person for the purpose of persuading them to withdraw a complaint or change their statement.

Where the allegations are disputed, the response should focus on the actual chronology, the purpose and manner of contact, the other person’s expressed wishes, and the objective evidence.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Reconstruct the Full Contact History

We examine the relationship between the parties, communications, visits, movements, and surrounding circumstances to determine the overall pattern of conduct.

We review whether the conduct was against the other person’s will, whether there was a justifiable reason, and whether the conduct was repeated or continued as required by the applicable law.

03. We Analyze Objective Evidence

We review text messages, call records, social media communications, CCTV footage, location data, recordings, and other evidence and compare them with the parties’ statements.

04. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the chronology and evidence before substantive questioning.

05. We Respond to Emergency and Provisional Protective Measures

Where restrictions on approaching or contacting the other person are imposed, we review the factual basis and legal effect of those measures and prepare the necessary response.

06. We Provide Representation from Investigation Through Trial

Veteran Law Firm assists from the initial police investigation through prosecution and criminal trial and, where responsibility is acknowledged, prepares appropriate materials concerning recurrence prevention and sentencing.

IN A STALKING CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT A SINGLE CONTACT, BUT THE ENTIRE PATTERN OF CONDUCT.

The timing, frequency, purpose, and manner of contact, the other person’s expressed refusal, the relationship between the parties, and the objective evidence must all be examined together.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes communications, call records, CCTV footage, location information, and the full history between the parties to identify whether the legal requirements for stalking are satisfied and what response is appropriate at each stage of the case.

If you are facing a stalking investigation, organizing the complete contact history and preserving the relevant evidence before the first substantive police interview can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

VIOLATIONS OF THE ACT ON THE PROTECTION OF CHILDREN AND YOUTH AGAINST SEX OFFENSES

Cases Involving Children and Youth Require Careful Analysis of Age, the Specific Conduct, and the Evidence from the Earliest Stage

WHAT ARE VIOLATIONS OF THE ACT ON THE PROTECTION OF CHILDREN AND YOUTH AGAINST SEX OFFENSES?

Korea’s Act on the Protection of Children and Youth Against Sex Offenses establishes special criminal provisions for sexual offenses involving children and youth.

Sexual conduct involving children or youth is subject to particularly strict legal protection, and the applicable offense and potential punishment may vary substantially depending on the nature of the conduct, the age of the person involved, and the circumstances of the case.

The Act addresses a wide range of conduct, including sexual offenses against children and youth and offenses involving child or youth sexual exploitation materials.

Production, distribution, purchase, possession, or viewing of child or youth sexual exploitation materials may be subject to separate criminal provisions, while sexual conduct involving a child or youth may also result in enhanced or specialized criminal liability.

For that reason, these cases require careful identification of the person’s age, the specific conduct alleged, how the parties came into contact, and the evidence supporting each allegation.

PENALTIES AND SENTENCING GUIDELINES

The potential punishment varies significantly depending on the specific offense.

The Korean Sentencing Commission provides different sentencing guideline ranges according to the type and seriousness of the conduct.

Statutory Indecent Act Against a Minor

Mitigated: up to 10 months

Standard: 8 months to 2 years

Aggravated: 1 year 6 months to 3 years

Statutory Rape

Mitigated: 1 year 6 months to 3 years

Standard: 2 years 6 months to 5 years

Aggravated: 4 years to 6 years

Indecent Act by Compulsion Against a Child or Youth

Mitigated: 2 years 6 months to 5 years

Standard: 4 years to 7 years

Aggravated: 6 years to 9 years

Quasi-Rape Involving a Child or Youth

Mitigated: 4 years to 7 years

Standard: 6 years to 9 years

Aggravated: 8 years to 12 years

Rape of a Child or Youth

Mitigated: 6 years to 9 years

Standard: 8 years to 12 years

Aggravated: 11 years to 15 years

These are sentencing guideline ranges and should not be confused with the statutory punishment applicable to each specific offense.

The actual sentence may vary depending on the conduct charged, the age of the victim, degree of force or coercion, relationship between the parties, resulting harm, criminal history, and other applicable sentencing factors.

A final conviction may also result in additional measures depending on the offense and circumstances, including:

registration of personal information;

disclosure or notification orders;

restrictions on employment at certain institutions; and

other measures prescribed by law.

KEY ISSUES IN CHILD AND YOUTH SEX OFFENSE CASES

01. Does the Person Meet the Statutory Age Requirement?

The actual age of the person involved is a fundamental issue.

It may also be necessary to determine what the accused knew or believed about that person’s age and whether that issue is legally relevant to the particular offense charged.

02. What Specific Conduct Is Alleged?

Different conduct may fall under substantially different statutory provisions.

The investigation should identify whether the allegation involves sexual intercourse, another sexual act, indecent contact, exploitation material, online solicitation, inducement, or another form of conduct.

03. Was Force, Intimidation, or Another Form of Compulsion Involved?

For offenses requiring force, intimidation, or another form of compulsion, the specific conduct and surrounding circumstances should be examined carefully.

The applicable legal standard depends on the offense charged.

04. How Did the Parties First Come into Contact?

Where contact began through a chat application, social media platform, online community, or messaging service, the entire communication history may become important evidence.

The timing and content of conversations before and after an in-person meeting should be reviewed in context.

05. Was There Online Solicitation or Inducement?

Certain communications or conduct directed toward children or youth may themselves create separate legal issues even before any physical meeting occurs.

The content, purpose, and progression of online communications should therefore be examined carefully.

06. What Does the Digital Evidence Show?

Potential evidence may include:

chat application records;

social media messages;

text messages;

photographs and videos;

call records;

location information;

account activity;

payment records; and

other digital data.

The evidence should be examined as a whole rather than relying on isolated messages or screenshots.

07. DOES THE CASE INVOLVE CHILD OR YOUTH SEXUAL EXPLOITATION MATERIALS?

Where photographs, videos, or other materials involving a child or youth are at issue, separate provisions governing child or youth sexual exploitation materials may apply.

Production, distribution, purchase, possession, and viewing should be analyzed independently according to the person’s actual conduct and knowledge.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR CHILD AND YOUTH SEX OFFENSE CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Confirm the Facts and the Age of the Person Involved

We identify the person’s actual age, the accused person’s understanding of that age where legally relevant, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances in which contact began.

STEP 02 | Identify the Specific Conduct and Applicable Offense

We distinguish the particular sexual or online conduct alleged and determine which provisions of the applicable statutes may apply.

STEP 03 | Review Digital Evidence and Prepare for Search and Seizure Issues

We examine chat applications, social media communications, photographs, videos, and other digital records relevant to the case.

Where smartphones, computers, or other electronic devices may become subject to search and seizure or forensic examination, we also review the scope and significance of the relevant digital evidence.

STEP 04 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview

Before questioning, we organize the chronology and principal factual and legal issues.

The objective is to ensure that statements are based on actual memory and objective evidence rather than speculation or assumptions.

STEP 05 | Respond During the Investigation

Where the allegations are disputed, we analyze age-related issues, communications, the specific conduct alleged, and other objective evidence and submit appropriate factual and legal arguments.

Where supported by the record, we seek an appropriate investigative outcome, including a police decision not to refer the case for prosecution or a prosecutorial non-indictment disposition.

If charges are filed, we analyze the indictment and prosecution evidence and prepare for trial.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review legally relevant sentencing materials as well as potential additional measures such as personal-information registration, disclosure or notification, and employment restrictions.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS IN CHILD AND YOUTH SEX OFFENSE INVESTIGATIONS

These cases often involve intensive review of digital evidence from the earliest stage.

Messages, social media records, photographs, videos, account information, and other electronic data should not be deleted, altered, or selectively edited after an investigation begins or is anticipated.

A person under investigation should also avoid contacting the other person or potential witnesses for the purpose of coordinating statements or changing their accounts.

Where age is disputed or misunderstood, the issue should be addressed through the actual communications and surrounding circumstances rather than through unsupported assumptions.

Likewise, the existence of online communications does not by itself determine which offense has been committed.

The complete sequence of contact, the content of the communications, the person’s age, the specific conduct, and the objective evidence should all be examined together.

WHERE THE ALLEGATIONS ARE DISPUTED

The defense should identify precisely which statutory elements are in dispute.

Relevant issues may include:

the actual age of the person involved;

what the accused knew or understood about that age where legally relevant;

whether the alleged sexual conduct occurred;

whether force, intimidation, or compulsion was involved;

whether particular communications constitute prohibited solicitation or inducement;

whether digital files were knowingly created, obtained, possessed, or transmitted; and

whether the objective evidence supports the allegations.

WHERE RESPONSIBILITY IS ACKNOWLEDGED

Where the evidence substantially supports the charged conduct, an indiscriminate denial may not be appropriate.

It may instead be important to define the individual’s actual conduct accurately and prepare legally relevant sentencing materials.

Depending on the circumstances, those materials may address:

the individual’s criminal history;

the specific scope of the conduct;

genuine remorse;

efforts to prevent reoffending;

counseling or educational measures;

recovery of harm where appropriate; and

other factors legally relevant to sentencing and additional court orders.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Analyze Age and the Applicable Statutory Framework

We identify the actual age of the person involved and determine which provisions of the Act on the Protection of Children and Youth Against Sex Offenses or other applicable statutes govern the alleged conduct.

02. We Distinguish the Specific Conduct and Criminal Liability

We separately analyze sexual intercourse, indecent contact, force or compulsion, online communications, solicitation, exploitation materials, and other alleged conduct rather than treating every allegation as the same offense.

03. We Analyze Digital Evidence

We review chat records, social media messages, photographs, videos, location information, account activity, and other digital evidence to determine what the objective record actually establishes.

04. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the chronology and supporting evidence before substantive questioning.

05. We Respond to Search, Seizure, and Digital Forensic Investigation

Where smartphones, computers, cloud accounts, or other digital sources are investigated, we review the scope and significance of the evidence and analyze how it relates to each allegation.

Veteran Law Firm provides representation from the initial police investigation through prosecution and criminal trial and, where necessary, addresses sentencing issues and additional measures such as personal-information registration, disclosure or notification orders, and employment restrictions.

IN A CHILD AND YOUTH SEX OFFENSE CASE, AGE, THE SPECIFIC CONDUCT, AND THE DIGITAL RECORD MUST BE ANALYZED TOGETHER.

Cases involving children and youth may carry substantially different legal consequences depending on the person’s age, the nature of the alleged sexual conduct, the use of force or compulsion, online communications, and the involvement of sexual exploitation materials.

Veteran Law Firm examines the relationship between the parties, the circumstances of their contact, chat and social media records, digital evidence, and the specific conduct alleged to identify the applicable offense and the appropriate response.

If you are facing an investigation involving an alleged sexual offense against a child or youth, organizing the age-related facts, communications, digital evidence, and the precise conduct alleged before the first substantive police interview can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATIONS

A Sexual Expression Alone Does Not Determine the Offense—the Purpose, Context, and Manner of Communication Must Be Examined Together

WHAT ARE SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATIONS?

Article 13 of Korea’s Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes prohibits the use of a telephone, mail, computer, or other means of communication to cause another person to receive words, sounds, writings, pictures, images, or other material capable of causing sexual shame or aversion, when done for the purpose of arousing or satisfying the sexual desires of the sender or another person.

The offense may arise through various means of communication, including text messages, telephone calls, messaging applications, social media, and email.

Whether the offense is established depends not simply on whether sexually explicit language or material was communicated.

The purpose and circumstances of the conduct, the relationship between the parties, the method of communication, and the content and context of the communication should all be examined together.

The Korean Supreme Court has also held that whether the required purpose of arousing or satisfying sexual desire exists should be determined reasonably according to social norms by considering the relationship between the accused and the alleged victim, the motive and circumstances of the conduct, the means and method used, and the nature and manner of the communication.

PENALTIES FOR SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATIONS

Under Article 13 of the Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes, the offense is punishable by:

Imprisonment for up to 2 years or a fine of up to KRW 20 million

The Korean Sentencing Commission currently provides the following sentencing guideline ranges:

Mitigated: up to 6 months

Standard: 4 months to 10 months

Aggravated: 8 months to 1 year 6 months

These are sentencing guideline ranges rather than penalties automatically imposed in every case.

The actual outcome may vary depending on the content and circumstances of the conduct, repetition, degree of harm, relationship between the parties, conduct following the incident, and other applicable sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATION CASES

01. WAS THERE A PURPOSE TO AROUSE OR SATISFY SEXUAL DESIRE?

The offense is not automatically established merely because a message contains sexual language or expressions.

The purpose and motive at the time of the communication, the overall course of the conversation, and the relationship between the parties must be considered together.

The required “sexual desire” is not necessarily limited to a desire for sexual intercourse or direct sexual activity.

Depending on the circumstances, an intent to obtain psychological satisfaction by sexually humiliating or degrading another person may also become relevant to the legal analysis.

02. WAS THE CONTENT CAPABLE OF CAUSING SEXUAL SHAME OR AVERSION?

The analysis should not be limited to an isolated word, photograph, or video.

The entire content of the communication, the surrounding conversation, and the circumstances in which the material was sent should be examined to determine whether it objectively falls within the statutory standard.

03. WHAT WAS THE OVERALL CONTEXT OF THE COMMUNICATION?

The prior relationship between the parties, how the conversation began, what was communicated before and after the material at issue, and the circumstances in which it was sent may all be important.

A partial screenshot or isolated message may not necessarily reveal the complete context of the communication.

04. WAS THE CONDUCT REPEATED?

Whether the same or similar material was sent repeatedly, particularly after the recipient expressed a desire for the communications to stop, may affect both the evaluation of the conduct and sentencing.

The complete communication history should therefore be reviewed rather than focusing only on a single transmission.

HOW A FORMER POLICE OFFICER-TURNED-ATTORNEY CAN ASSIST

Cases involving sexually obscene communications often depend heavily on text messages, messenger conversations, social media records, call history, images, and other digital evidence.

For that reason, accurately organizing the facts and evidence from the police investigation stage can be critical.

Drawing on prior experience investigating criminal cases, our former police officer-turned-attorneys examine the issues investigators are likely to focus on and develop an appropriate response from the earliest stage.

In particular, it is important to review the complete conversation rather than allowing the case to be evaluated solely on the basis of selected messages or screenshots.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the entire communication history, the circumstances of transmission, the relationship between the parties, and the objective evidence to identify the central legal and factual issues before police questioning.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATION CASES

STEP 01 | Identify the Incident and How the Investigation Began

We review the criminal complaint, the means of communication involved, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances leading to the alleged incident.

We also identify the current stage of the investigation and the principal issues being examined.

STEP 02 | Analyze the Communications and Evidence

We review relevant materials such as:

text messages;

messenger conversations;

social media communications;

photographs and videos;

call records; and

other digital evidence.

The complete flow of communication before and after the material at issue is examined together with the circumstances in which it was transmitted.

STEP 03 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview

Before questioning, we organize the relevant facts and identify the issues likely to arise during the investigation.

Because statements made during the initial investigation may later be examined throughout the prosecution and trial, preparation should be based on the actual communication records and objective facts rather than speculation.

We examine whether there was a purpose to arouse or satisfy sexual desire, whether the content falls within the statutory standard, the overall context of the communication, the relationship between the parties, and whether the conduct was repeated.

Based on that analysis, we prepare appropriate factual and legal arguments and, where necessary, submit a written attorney opinion.

STEP 05 | Respond Through Investigation and Trial

Depending on the result of the police investigation, we provide the necessary response at the prosecution stage.

If charges are filed, we analyze the evidence and central legal issues and prepare for criminal trial.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we also review legally relevant sentencing circumstances and prepare appropriate sentencing materials.

IN A SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER SEXUAL WORDS OR IMAGES WERE SENT, BUT WHY THEY WERE SENT, IN WHAT CONTEXT, AND WHAT THE COMPLETE COMMUNICATION RECORD SHOWS.

Text messages, messenger conversations, social media records, call history, and other digital evidence can become central evidence in these cases.

Veteran Law Firm examines the entire course of communication, the relationship between the parties, the purpose and circumstances of the conduct, and the objective record to determine whether the statutory requirements are satisfied and what response is appropriate.

If you are facing an investigation involving sexually obscene communications, preserving the complete communication history and organizing the facts before the first substantive police interview can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.