Veteran Law Firm

Sex Crimes

NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING AND DISTRIBUTION

The Legal Issues Depend Not Only on Whether a Recording Was Made, but Also on Consent, the Content Recorded, and What Happened to the Material Afterwards

The Legal Issues Depend Not Only on Whether a Recording Was Made, but Also on Consent, the Content Recorded, and What Happened to the Material Afterwards

WHAT IS NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING?

Under Article 14 of Korea’s Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes, criminal liability may arise where a person uses a camera or similar device to record another person’s body against that person’s will where the recording is capable of causing sexual desire or sexual humiliation.

The statute also prohibits certain forms of distribution, sale, lease, provision, public exhibition, or screening of such recordings or copies.

Importantly, criminal liability may also arise where the original recording was made with the subject’s consent—or even where the person recorded his or her own body—but the material is later distributed against that person’s will.

For that reason, an investigation should not focus solely on whether a recording exists.

Relevant issues may include:

whether the person consented to the recording;

what part of the body was recorded;

whether the recording falls within the scope protected by Article 14;

how and why the recording was made;

whether the material was subsequently stored, transmitted, or distributed; and

what the accused knew and intended at each stage.

PENALTIES FOR NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING AND DISTRIBUTION

The statutory penalty depends on the specific conduct involved.

Non-Consensual Recording

Recording another person’s body in violation of Article 14(1) may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million

Distribution and Similar Conduct

Distributing, selling, leasing, providing, publicly exhibiting, or screening qualifying recordings or copies—including certain recordings that were originally made with consent but later distributed against the subject’s will—may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million

Distribution for Profit Through an Information and Communications Network

Where the statutory requirements for profit-motivated distribution are satisfied:

Imprisonment for at least 3 years

Possession, Purchase, Storage, or Viewing

The possession, purchase, storage, or viewing of qualifying recordings or copies may also constitute a separate offense and may be punished by:

Imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 30 million

Habitual commission of certain offenses under Article 14 may result in enhanced punishment.

CURRENT SENTENCING GUIDELINES

The Korean Sentencing Commission provides sentencing guideline ranges according to the type and seriousness of the conduct.

Recording

Mitigated: 4 months to 10 months

Standard: 8 months to 2 years

Aggravated: 1 year to 3 years

Distribution and Similar Conduct

Mitigated: 4 months to 1 year 4 months

Standard: 1 year to 2 years 6 months

Aggravated: 1 year 6 months to 4 years

Distribution for Profit

Mitigated: 1 year 6 months to 4 years

Standard: 2 years 6 months to 6 years

Aggravated: 4 years to 8 years

These are sentencing guideline ranges, not statutory penalties automatically imposed in every case.

The actual sentence may vary depending on the nature of the recording, number of offenses, extent of distribution, profit motive, degree of harm, prior criminal history, efforts to prevent further dissemination or recover the harm, and other applicable sentencing factors.

KEY ISSUES IN A NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING CASE

The existence of a photograph or video does not, by itself, resolve every legal issue.

Important questions may include:

whether the recording actually occurred;

whether it was made against the subject’s will;

whether the body part and manner of recording fall within the scope of Article 14;

whether consent existed at the time of recording;

the scope of any consent that was given;

the circumstances and purpose of the recording;

whether the accused intentionally engaged in the conduct at issue;

whether the material was merely created or was also transmitted or distributed;

whether the material or copies were knowingly possessed, purchased, stored, or viewed; and

what the digital evidence demonstrates concerning creation, storage, transmission, and distribution.

Consent to being recorded and consent to distribution are separate legal questions.

Even where a person agreed to the original recording, later distribution against that person’s will may constitute a criminal offense.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Circumstances of the Recording

We examine where and how the recording was made, what was recorded, the relationship between the parties, the circumstances at the time, and whether consent was given.

STEP 02 | Identify the Specific Conduct and Applicable Offense

We distinguish among recording, possession, storage, transmission, distribution, sale, provision, and other alleged conduct and determine which provisions may apply to each act.

STEP 03 | Analyze Digital Evidence

We examine relevant information from smartphones, computers, messaging applications, cloud services, and other digital sources.

The creation, storage, transmission, and distribution history of the material is compared with the statements made during the investigation.

STEP 04 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview

Before police questioning, we identify the principal factual and legal issues and organize the chronology based on actual facts and objective evidence.

The purpose is not to prepare an artificial or predetermined account, but to avoid speculation and unnecessary inconsistencies during questioning.

STEP 05 | Respond During the Investigation

Where the allegations are disputed, we analyze whether the evidence establishes non-consensual recording, the required intent, distribution, or other charged conduct and submit supporting materials and legal arguments where appropriate.

Where supported by the evidence, we pursue an appropriate investigative outcome, including a police decision not to refer the case for prosecution or a prosecutorial non-indictment disposition.

STEP 06 | Criminal Trial and Sentencing Response

If charges are filed, we analyze the indictment, digital evidence, and other prosecution materials and prepare for trial.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review appropriate measures concerning prevention of further dissemination, recovery of harm, legally appropriate settlement efforts, remorse, and other sentencing considerations.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Identify How the Recording Was Made

We organize when and where the recording occurred, what was recorded, whether consent existed, and how the victim became aware of the recording.

STEP 02 | Preserve Evidence

Potential evidence may include:

screenshots;

URLs;

messages and transmission records;

account or profile information;

recordings or photographs relating to the incident;

platform information;

witness information; and

other digital records showing possession or distribution.

Evidence should be preserved carefully without unnecessarily redistributing the unlawful material.

STEP 03 | Organize the Facts Before the Police Investigation

We organize the circumstances of the recording and any subsequent distribution so that the relevant facts can be communicated accurately during the investigation.

STEP 04 | Seek Removal and Prevention of Further Distribution

Where the material has been distributed online, we review available procedures for requesting removal, blocking, and prevention of further dissemination and consider assistance through relevant victim-support services.

STEP 05 | Respond During Investigation and Trial

We assist with criminal complaints, submission of supporting evidence and legal opinions, and procedures available to victims after prosecution.

STEP 06 | Review Civil Damages and Other Remedies

Separate from the criminal proceedings, we consider whether a civil damages claim or other legal remedy may be available for emotional distress, economic loss, or other legally compensable harm.

WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED IN A NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING INVESTIGATION?

01. What Was Actually Recorded?

It is necessary to examine the content and composition of the photograph or video rather than assuming that every unauthorized recording automatically falls within Article 14.

The body part depicted, clothing, angle, distance, location, manner of recording, and overall circumstances may all become relevant.

02. Was the Recording Against the Subject’s Will?

Consent is a central issue in many cases.

The communications between the parties, circumstances of the recording, prior conduct, and other objective evidence should be examined to determine whether consent existed.

Consent to one particular photograph or recording does not necessarily amount to consent to additional recordings or to later transmission or distribution.

The precise scope of the consent should therefore be identified.

04. Was the Recording Distributed?

Creation of a recording and distribution of that recording are legally distinct forms of conduct.

Messages, upload records, platform activity, cloud data, and other digital evidence may be important in determining whether and how the material was transmitted.

05. Was the Material Knowingly Possessed or Viewed?

Under current law, certain forms of possession, purchase, storage, or viewing may themselves be punishable.

The existence of a file on a device should therefore be examined together with how the file was obtained, stored, accessed, or viewed.

06. What Does the Digital Evidence Actually Show?

A file discovered on a device does not necessarily establish every allegation concerning its creation or distribution.

Metadata where available, application records, cloud synchronization, transmission history, communications, and other digital information should be examined in context.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

Do not delete or alter photographs, videos, messages, cloud data, or other digital records after an investigation begins or is anticipated.

Deleting data may create additional evidentiary concerns and may not remove copies already preserved by platforms, recipients, or investigative authorities.

A person under investigation should also avoid contacting the reporting person or other relevant individuals for the purpose of coordinating statements or persuading them to change their account.

Where the allegations are disputed, the response should focus on the specific recording, consent, statutory elements, and digital evidence rather than assumptions about what investigators may have obtained.

IMPORTANT CONSIDERATIONS FOR VICTIMS

Where unlawful distribution is suspected, evidence preservation and efforts to prevent further dissemination may need to proceed simultaneously.

Screenshots, URLs, account information, transmission records, and platform details should be preserved where possible without repeatedly forwarding the material.

Because online material can be copied rapidly, prompt consideration of removal and blocking measures may be important.

Necessary medical, counseling, or other support should not be delayed solely because a criminal investigation is pending.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Analyze Whether the Recording Falls Within the Applicable Statute

We examine the content of the recording, body part depicted, circumstances, consent, and method of recording to determine whether the alleged conduct falls within Article 14.

02. We Distinguish Recording from Distribution and Other Conduct

We separately analyze recording, possession, storage, transmission, distribution, and profit-motivated dissemination rather than treating all digital activity as a single offense.

03. We Analyze Digital Evidence

We review available smartphone, messaging, cloud, platform, and other digital evidence to determine how the material was created, stored, accessed, or transmitted.

04. We Prepare for Police and Prosecution Interviews

Drawing on prior law-enforcement experience, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and organize the facts and evidence before substantive questioning.

05. We Develop a Strategy Appropriate to the Evidence

Where the allegations are disputed, we examine consent, intent, the scope of the statutory offense, and the objective digital record.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review measures concerning prevention of further dissemination, recovery of harm, settlement-related circumstances, and sentencing.

Veteran Law Firm provides representation from the initial police investigation through prosecution and criminal trial and, where appropriate, assists victims with evidence preservation, removal measures, and related civil damages claims.

IN A NON-CONSENSUAL RECORDING CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A CAMERA WAS USED, BUT WHAT WAS RECORDED, WHETHER THERE WAS CONSENT, AND WHAT HAPPENED TO THE MATERIAL AFTERWARDS.

The legal analysis may change significantly depending on the nature of the recording, the circumstances and scope of consent, whether the material was distributed, and what the digital evidence shows.

Veteran Law Firm examines the circumstances of the recording together with smartphone data, communications, transmission records, and other objective evidence to identify the conduct that can actually be established and the law applicable to each part of the case.

Whether you are facing an allegation or seeking assistance as a victim, preserving the relevant digital evidence and accurately reconstructing the recording and distribution history from the police investigation stage can be critical to protecting your legal rights.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.