Veteran Law Firm

Finance

GENERAL FRAUD

Failing to Repay Money Is Not the Same as Obtaining It by Deception from the Start

Failing to Repay Money Is Not the Same as Obtaining It by Deception from the Start

A fraud case is not determined simply by the fact that money was not repaid or a contractual obligation was not fulfilled.

The key issues are whether there was deception at the time of the transaction, whether the other party relied on that deception in transferring money or property, and whether the person receiving the money lacked the intention or ability to perform the promised obligation from the outset.

Drawing on the investigative experience of attorneys who previously served as police officers, Veteran Law Firm analyzes communications before and after the transaction, contractual terms, account activity, and the use of funds to distinguish criminal fraud from a civil breach of contract or failure to repay a debt.

WHAT IS FRAUD?

Fraud is generally committed when a person deceives another and, as a result, receives property or obtains a financial benefit.

Under Article 347 of the Korean Criminal Act, a person who obtains property or a financial benefit by deceiving another person may be punished by imprisonment for up to 20 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million.

In determining whether fraud has been established, the following elements generally require careful examination.

Deception

Deception may involve making a false statement or intentionally concealing an important fact in a manner that causes another person to make a mistaken judgment.

It may involve not only an affirmative false statement, but also the intentional failure to disclose material information that a party had a duty to disclose in the particular transaction.

Mistaken Belief of the Victim

The victim must have formed an incorrect understanding of the actual circumstances as a result of the false statement or concealment.

Disposition of Property

Based on that mistaken belief, the victim must have taken an action affecting his or her property, such as transferring money or goods or releasing a debt.

Financial Loss and Gain

The transaction must result in the transfer of property or a financial benefit to the suspect or a third party, with corresponding financial consequences for the victim.

Intent to Defraud

There must have been an intention to obtain property or a financial benefit through deception.

In contract and loan cases in particular, a central issue is whether the person had the genuine intention and ability to perform the promise at the time the money was received.

COMMON TYPES OF FRAUD

Loan Fraud

This may involve borrowing money for purposes such as business expenses, living costs, or investment while lacking the intention or ability to repay it.

Failure to repay a loan does not automatically constitute fraud.

The borrower’s financial circumstances at the time of borrowing, existing debts, income, repayment plan, and subsequent efforts to repay should all be examined.

Investment Fraud

This may involve obtaining investment funds by promising guaranteed returns or principal protection or by presenting a nonexistent or materially misrepresented business or investment opportunity.

Important issues may include whether the underlying business actually existed, how the investment funds were used, how the proposed returns were supposed to be generated, and what risks were disclosed to investors.

Goods and Commercial Transaction Fraud

This may arise where a person enters into a transaction without any genuine intention to supply the promised goods or pay the agreed price and obtains goods, deposits, or other property as a result.

It is important to distinguish a transaction that was genuinely being performed but later failed because of business circumstances from one that was never intended to be performed from the beginning.

Online and Secondhand Marketplace Fraud

This may involve advertising nonexistent goods through online marketplaces, social media, or other platforms, receiving payment, and then failing to deliver the goods.

Relevant issues may include the identity of the account holder, the identity of the person who actually communicated with the victim, whether the goods existed, and how the account receiving the funds was used.

This may involve obtaining fees, deposits, or other payments by falsely offering employment, loans, guarantees, government assistance, or similar opportunities.

It is important to determine whether the person actually had authority or ability to arrange the promised employment or financing and to identify the stated purpose and actual use of the money received.

Real Estate Fraud

This may involve obtaining purchase money, deposits, or other payments by making false representations concerning ownership of real estate, restrictions on rights, development potential, tenancy arrangements, or other material circumstances.

Relevant evidence may include real estate registration records, contracts, explanations concerning existing rights, and what each party knew at the time of the transaction.

PENALTIES FOR FRAUD

Fraud under the Korean Criminal Act

Statutory Penalty

Imprisonment for up to 20 years or a fine of up to KRW 50 million

Where fraud is committed habitually, the punishment may be increased under the provisions governing habitual fraud.

Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes

Where the value of property or financial benefits obtained through fraud is KRW 500 million or more, enhanced penalties may apply under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes.

Gain of KRW 500 Million or More but Less Than KRW 5 Billion

Imprisonment for at least 3 years

Gain of KRW 5 Billion or More

Life imprisonment or imprisonment for at least 5 years

Where the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes applies, the court may also impose a fine of up to the amount of the financial gain obtained through the offense.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR FRAUD CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Prepare for the Initial Investigation

Before a police or prosecution interview, we review the allegations in the criminal complaint, identify likely areas of questioning, and prepare a consistent approach to the statement.

We work to avoid statements that incorrectly turn a failed transaction into an admission of criminal fraud or that conflict with objective documentary evidence.

STEP 02 | Reconstruct the Facts of the Transaction

We collect and review contracts, messages, recordings, bank transaction records, business documents, and repayment records and organize the events chronologically from the beginning of the transaction through the development of the dispute.

We examine whether the client had the intention and ability to perform the agreement at the time of the transaction and how the money received was actually used.

STEP 03 | Develop a Settlement and Mitigation Strategy

Where the allegations are admitted, we review the possibility of compensating the victim and the victim’s position regarding settlement.

Where appropriate, we prepare settlement agreements, statements expressing the victim’s position regarding punishment, evidence of repayment, mitigation materials, and a concrete compensation plan for submission to the investigative authorities or court.

STEP 04 | Respond at Trial

If the case is prosecuted, we review the evidentiary record and the credibility of the victim’s statements and examine whether deception, mistake, disposition of property, and intent to defraud have been proven.

Where the allegations are admitted, the defense may instead focus on victim compensation, the client’s degree of participation, and other circumstances relevant to sentencing.

We review each legal element of fraud and distinguish criminal fraud from a civil breach of contract or failure to repay a debt.

We organize evidence concerning the client’s financial circumstances at the time of the agreement, preparations for performance, partial repayments, use of funds, and other circumstances that may demonstrate the absence of fraudulent intent.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Review Recovery of Funds and Settlement Options

If the suspect proposes a settlement, we review whether the full amount of the loss will be repaid, when payment will be made, and what conditions are included in the settlement.

We also consider whether separate asset-recovery measures should be pursued, such as provisional attachment, a payment order, or a civil claim for damages.

STEP 02 | Prepare and File the Criminal Complaint

We clearly identify when and how the suspect made false representations, how the victim relied on those representations in transferring property, and the amount of the resulting loss.

The complaint should do more than state that money was not repaid. It should clearly present the facts relevant to the legal elements of fraud.

STEP 03 | Participate in Criminal Proceedings and Exercise the Victim’s Rights

If the defendant is prosecuted, the victim may submit a written statement or, where necessary, testify concerning how the fraud occurred and the extent of the loss that remains uncompensated.

We also assist in communicating the victim’s position regarding settlement and punishment to the court.

STEP 04 | Organize the Facts and Secure Evidence

We collect contracts, bank transfer records, text and messenger communications, recordings, advertisements, business proposals, and other relevant evidence.

We reconstruct the sequence from the alleged deception through the transfer of funds and resulting loss and prepare evidence addressing anticipated arguments by the suspect.

STEP 05 | Respond to the Investigation

We prepare the victim for the police investigation by organizing the relevant facts and evidence and developing a clear and consistent account of what occurred.

If the suspect claims that the matter was merely a normal commercial transaction or that there was a genuine intention to repay, we identify and submit objective evidence that may contradict those claims.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Establish or Challenge the Alleged Intent to Defraud at the Time of the Transaction

The central question in many fraud cases is not simply what happened after the money was received, but what the person intended at the time of receiving it.

Veteran Law Firm examines the financial position, existing debts, status of the business, available means of repayment, and preparations for performance at the time the agreement was made in order to assess whether fraudulent intent can be established.

02. We Reconstruct Scattered Transaction Records into a Clear Chronology

Fraud cases often involve months or even years of communications and financial transactions.

We organize contracts, account records, messages, recordings, and repayment records chronologically so that the relationship between the alleged deception and the resulting transfer of property can be clearly understood.

03. We Prepare for the Police Investigation Based on the Evidence

We analyze the criminal complaint and supporting evidence in advance and identify the issues investigators are likely to examine.

We do not create statements that differ from the facts. Instead, we distinguish matters that should be acknowledged from those that can properly be disputed under the law based on objective evidence.

04. We Take a Practical Approach to Recovery of the Victim’s Loss

For many victims, punishment of the offender is not the only objective. Actual recovery of the money lost may be equally important.

We review the suspect’s financial circumstances and consider the appropriate combination of criminal settlement and civil recovery measures, including provisional attachment, payment orders, and claims for damages.

05. We Carefully Determine the Amount of Loss and the Scope of the Alleged Fraud

The total amount of money involved in a transaction is not necessarily the same as the amount obtained through fraud.

We distinguish portions that were properly performed, amounts that were returned, the actual financial benefit obtained, and individual transactions involving different victims in order to assess the amount relevant to the applicable law and sentencing.

06. We Coordinate the Response in High-Value and Multiple-Victim Fraud Cases

Where there are multiple victims or the amount involved reaches KRW 500 million or more, important issues may arise concerning the number and relationship of the offenses, calculation of the total financial gain, and application of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes.

We analyze the timing and method of each transaction and whether the transactions were carried out pursuant to a common plan or fraudulent intent in order to determine the legal structure of the case as a whole.

A FRAUD CASE ASKS NOT SIMPLY WHY A PROMISE WAS BROKEN, BUT WHETHER THERE WAS A GENUINE INTENTION TO KEEP THAT PROMISE FROM THE BEGINNING.

For a suspect or defendant, objective evidence demonstrating a genuine transaction and actual efforts to perform the agreement may be critical.

For a victim, evidence showing what representations were made and how those representations led to the transfer of money or property may be equally important.

Drawing on the investigative experience of attorneys who previously served as police officers, Veteran Law Firm provides coordinated assistance throughout the case—from organizing the facts and preparing for the police investigation to victim compensation and criminal trial proceedings.

If you are facing a police investigation for fraud or have suffered financial loss as a result of suspected fraud, consult Veteran Law Firm before preparing your first statement or filing a criminal complaint.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.