Veteran Law Firm

Civil Litigation

EVICTION AND PROPERTY SURRENDER LITIGATION

When a Tenant Refuses to Vacate, the Strategy Should Address Both the Lawsuit and the Risk of a Change in Possession

When a Tenant Refuses to Vacate, the Strategy Should Address Both the Lawsuit and the Risk of a Change in Possession

A landlord may face substantial financial loss when a residential or commercial tenant refuses to vacate after the lease has ended or remains in possession despite prolonged non-payment of rent.

Continuing to wait in the expectation that the tenant will eventually leave voluntarily may increase losses through unpaid rent, financing costs, management expenses, and delays in leasing or using the property.

At the same time, even an owner should not attempt to resolve the situation by forcibly entering the premises, changing locks, or removing the occupant’s belongings without following the appropriate legal process.

Depending on the circumstances, such self-help measures may create separate civil or criminal issues.

Veteran Law Firm approaches these cases by coordinating a provisional injunction prohibiting the transfer of possession, litigation seeking surrender of the property, settlement where appropriate, and compulsory enforcement.

WHAT IS EVICTION AND PROPERTY SURRENDER LITIGATION?

An eviction or property surrender action is a civil proceeding through which an owner or other person entitled to possession seeks delivery of real property from a tenant or other occupant who no longer has a lawful right to remain in possession.

Article 213 of the Korean Civil Act provides that an owner may demand the return of property from a person possessing it, unless that person has a legal right to retain possession.

In lease disputes, the first issue is therefore not simply whether the landlord owns the property.

It is necessary to determine whether the tenant’s or occupant’s legal basis for possession has validly ended and whether the person named in the lawsuit is the person actually occupying the premises.

COMMON SITUATIONS REQUIRING AN EVICTION OR SURRENDER ACTION

Termination for Unpaid Rent

Where rent arrears reach the statutory or contractual threshold for termination and the tenant nevertheless refuses to vacate, the landlord may consider terminating the lease and pursuing surrender of the property.

Under the Korean Civil Act, a lease of a building or other structure may generally be terminated where rent arrears reach the amount of two rental periods.

For leases governed by the Commercial Building Lease Protection Act, termination may be available where the arrears reach the amount of three rental periods.

The applicable statute, lease terms, amount of arrears, and effectiveness of the termination notice should be confirmed in each case.

Expiration of the Lease

Where the lease period has expired but the tenant remains in possession, it is necessary to determine whether the lease actually terminated or was renewed by agreement, statutory renewal, or tacit renewal.

Residential and commercial leases are subject to different statutory renewal and notice rules.

The timing and content of any notice refusing renewal should therefore be reviewed before filing suit.

Unauthorized Occupation or Sublease

A dispute may arise where the tenant transfers the lease or subleases all or part of the premises to another person without the landlord’s consent.

Article 629 of the Korean Civil Act generally prohibits a tenant from assigning a leasehold interest or subleasing the leased property without the landlord’s consent and permits termination in the circumstances prescribed by that provision.

The actual occupant must also be identified accurately before an action for surrender is pursued.

Failure to Vacate After an Auction or Acquisition

A purchaser who acquires real property through an auction may encounter a former owner, tenant, or third-party occupant who refuses to surrender possession.

Depending on the circumstances and procedural deadlines, a statutory delivery order may be available.

Where that procedure is unavailable or the occupant asserts a separate right of possession, ordinary property surrender litigation may be necessary.

WHAT ARE THE KEY ISSUES IN AN EVICTION CASE?

Two questions are particularly important:

Was the lease or other right of possession validly terminated?

and

Who actually possesses the property now?

Relevant documents and evidence may include:

the lease agreement;

a certified copy of the real estate register;

the building register;

bank records showing unpaid rent;

text messages and messenger communications concerning payment or termination;

certified demand and termination notices;

evidence concerning the date and manner of service;

information identifying the current occupants;

photographs and other materials concerning actual possession; and

documents concerning any sublease or transfer of possession.

Where there is a realistic possibility that possession will be transferred to another person during the litigation, a provisional injunction prohibiting the transfer of possession should be considered at an early stage.

WHY IS A PROVISIONAL INJUNCTION PROHIBITING TRANSFER OF POSSESSION IMPORTANT?

Eviction litigation can become substantially more complicated if the person possessing the premises changes while the case is pending.

A provisional injunction prohibiting the transfer of possession is designed to preserve the existing state of possession so that the defendant cannot undermine later enforcement merely by transferring possession to another person.

The injunction should ordinarily identify the actual occupant and the property accurately and must then be executed in accordance with the Civil Execution Act.

Because the statutory period for execution of a provisional disposition is limited, the execution procedure must be handled promptly after the order is issued.

The injunction is an important means of protecting future enforcement, but its legal effect is not unlimited.

Whether a judgment can be enforced against a person who later occupies the premises may depend on whether that person is legally considered a successor to the original defendant’s possession and on the particular circumstances in which possession changed.

ILLUSTRATIVE CASE: WHY PRESERVING POSSESSION MATTERS

Consider a commercial landlord who terminates a lease after several months of unpaid rent and files an eviction action against the tenant.

While the litigation is pending, the tenant transfers the operation of the business and possession of the premises to another person.

If the actual possessor changes without appropriate preservation measures having been taken, the landlord may encounter substantial difficulties when attempting to enforce a judgment obtained against the original tenant.

In such a situation, it may become necessary to address the new occupant separately or pursue additional provisional relief, resulting in further time and expense.

This is why the identity of the actual occupant and the need for a provisional injunction should be considered before or at the beginning of the main action, rather than only after judgment.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S STRATEGY FOR EVICTION AND PROPERTY SURRENDER CASES

“We Address the Risk of a Change in Possession Before It Becomes an Enforcement Problem.”

Veteran Law Firm does not approach an eviction matter as a case in which the only task is to file a complaint and wait for judgment.

From the initial review, we examine whether the lease was validly terminated, whether notice can be served without delay, who actually possesses the property, and whether there is a risk that possession may be transferred while litigation is pending.

Where appropriate, we coordinate provisional relief with the main property surrender action so that obtaining a favorable judgment and actually recovering possession are treated as one connected process.

STEP-BY-STEP PROCESS

STEP 01 | Identify the Current Occupant and Consider a Provisional Injunction

We determine who is actually occupying and controlling the premises and assess whether a provisional injunction prohibiting the transfer of possession should be filed.

Where an injunction is granted, execution must be completed promptly within the period prescribed by law.

STEP 02 | Confirm the Basis for Termination

We review unpaid rent, expiration of the lease, unauthorized subleasing, or other alleged grounds for termination.

We also examine whether any required notice or demand was properly given and received.

STEP 03 | File the Property Surrender Action

We prepare and file the complaint seeking surrender of the property and, where appropriate, related claims such as unpaid rent or damages for continued occupation.

We also prepare for potential defenses involving renewal, deposit repayment, repair expenses, or other alleged rights of the occupant.

STEP 04 | Use Settlement or Mediation Strategically Where Appropriate

Not every case must proceed to a final judgment.

Where a negotiated resolution can achieve actual surrender more efficiently, mediation or settlement may be used to establish a specific move-out date, payment of arrears, allocation of expenses, and consequences if the occupant fails to leave as agreed.

STEP 05 | Prepare for Compulsory Enforcement

If the occupant does not surrender the premises voluntarily after an enforceable judgment or settlement has been obtained, compulsory enforcement through the court enforcement process may be necessary.

The enforcement stage should be anticipated before judgment so that avoidable delays do not arise after the legal right to possession has already been established.

WHAT LANDLORDS SHOULD NOT DO

Do Not Force Entry Simply Because You Own the Property

Ownership does not necessarily authorize a landlord to enter premises that remain in another person’s possession without consent or lawful process.

Changing locks, forcing entry, or removing belongings may create separate legal liability depending on the circumstances.

Do Not Dispose of the Occupant’s Property on Your Own

Furniture, inventory, equipment, and personal belongings remaining at the premises should not simply be discarded or removed without considering the proper procedure.

The ownership and treatment of those items should be addressed separately from the right to recover possession of the real property.

Do Not Assume a Verbal Demand Has Legally Ended the Lease

Whether termination was effective may depend on the applicable legal grounds and whether the notice actually reached the other party.

Important demands and termination notices should therefore be documented carefully.

Do Not Wait Until After Judgment to Determine Who Occupies the Property

Where actual possession has changed during the proceedings, enforcement may become more complicated.

The identity of the occupant should be checked at the outset and monitored where the circumstances give reason for concern.

WHAT SHOULD BE REVIEWED BEFORE FILING?

01. Why Does the Occupant No Longer Have a Right to Possession?

We determine whether the basis is expiration, unpaid rent, unauthorized subleasing, contractual breach, or another ground.

02. Was the Lease Properly Terminated?

We examine the amount of unpaid rent, any required demand, the contents of the termination notice, and proof that the notice reached the tenant.

03. Who Is Actually in Possession?

The name on the lease or business registration may not always be the same as the person currently occupying and controlling the premises.

04. Is a Provisional Injunction Necessary?

We assess whether there is a risk that the tenant will sublease, transfer possession, change the business operator, or otherwise complicate enforcement.

05. Can Notice and Court Documents Be Served Promptly?

A case can be delayed when the defendant’s address is inaccurate or service cannot be completed.

Available addresses and other information relevant to service should therefore be reviewed from the beginning.

Unpaid rent, management fees, damages for continued occupation, restoration costs, and the return or deduction of the security deposit may need to be addressed together.

07. What Will Be Required for Actual Enforcement?

A favorable judgment is not the final objective.

The practical steps necessary to recover the premises should also be considered before the lawsuit is completed.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

We review the lease, rent arrears, expiration date, renewal issues, subleasing, and other relevant circumstances to determine whether the landlord has a current right to demand surrender of the premises.

02. We Identify and Preserve the Actual State of Possession

We determine who actually occupies the property and, where necessary, pursue a provisional injunction prohibiting transfer of possession so that a later judgment is not unnecessarily complicated by a change in occupants.

03. We Coordinate Termination Notices and Litigation

We review whether the requirements for termination have been met and prepare formal notices so that an improper termination does not undermine the subsequent surrender claim.

04. We Address Service Issues at an Early Stage

We examine available addresses and service information from the outset and respond appropriately if ordinary service cannot be completed, reducing avoidable procedural delays.

05. We Use Mediation and Settlement When They Serve the Client’s Objective

Where appropriate, we seek settlement terms that clearly establish the surrender date, unpaid amounts, treatment of the security deposit, and enforceable consequences if the occupant fails to comply.

06. We Prepare for Enforcement from the Beginning

Our objective is not merely to obtain a written judgment.

We connect provisional relief, the main lawsuit, settlement, and compulsory enforcement so that the client can ultimately recover actual possession of the property.

AN EVICTION CASE IS NOT COMPLETE WHEN THE JUDGMENT IS ISSUED—IT IS COMPLETE WHEN POSSESSION IS ACTUALLY RECOVERED.

An owner should not have to abandon legitimate property rights simply because a tenant or unauthorized occupant refuses to leave.

At the same time, attempting to recover possession through unlawful self-help may create new legal problems rather than resolve the existing dispute.

The effective approach is to establish the legal basis for termination, identify the actual occupant, preserve the state of possession where necessary, and prepare for enforcement from the outset.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the lease, the actual possession of the property, and the enforcement risks together to develop a lawful and practical strategy for recovering residential and commercial premises.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.