ROBBERY & THEFT
WHAT ARE ROBBERY AND THEFT?
Robbery and theft are both property crimes involving the property of another person, but their legal character differs significantly depending on whether force or threats were used.
Theft may be established where a person takes another person’s property with the intent to unlawfully appropriate it. Depending on the manner in which the offense is committed, different offenses and penalties may apply, including simple theft, nighttime residential burglary-type theft, aggravated theft involving a weapon or multiple offenders acting jointly, and habitual theft.
Robbery involves taking another person’s property, obtaining a financial benefit, or causing a third party to obtain such a benefit through force or threats.
Not every use of physical force automatically constitutes robbery. A central issue is whether the force or threats were of a degree sufficient to suppress the victim’s ability to resist.
Where a person who has committed theft uses force or threats in order to retain the stolen property, avoid apprehension, or destroy evidence of the crime, the conduct may constitute quasi-robbery under Korean law. If a victim is injured during a robbery, the more serious offense of robbery resulting in injury may apply.
KEY LEGAL ISSUES IN ROBBERY AND THEFT CASES
In robbery and theft cases, the legal analysis should not focus solely on the fact that property was taken.
It is necessary to examine how the property was obtained, the timing and degree of any force or threats, the method of the offense, the extent of the victim’s harm, and the surrounding circumstances.
In a theft case, key issues may include whether the accused intended to unlawfully appropriate another person’s property, whether there was a genuine intention to return the property, and whether the alleged conduct was committed alone or jointly with others.
In a robbery case, it is particularly important to determine whether force or threats were used as a means of obtaining the property or financial benefit and whether they were sufficiently serious to suppress the victim’s resistance.
Where a weapon was carried or used, multiple offenders acted jointly, the offense involved nighttime entry into a residence or other protected premises, or the victim suffered bodily injury, more serious offenses such as aggravated theft, aggravated robbery, or robbery resulting in injury may apply.
For that reason, the precise sequence of events and the role of each person involved should be established from the earliest stage.
PENALTIES FOR ROBBERY AND THEFT
Under the current Korean Criminal Act, simple theft is punishable by imprisonment for up to 6 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
A person who steals property after entering another person’s residence, managed building, vessel, aircraft, or occupied room at night may be punished by imprisonment for up to 10 years.
Aggravated theft involving the carrying of a weapon or two or more persons acting jointly is punishable by imprisonment for 1 to 10 years.
Robbery is punishable by imprisonment for at least 3 years.
Aggravated robbery—including robbery committed after nighttime entry into a residence or certain other premises, robbery committed while carrying a weapon, or robbery committed jointly by two or more persons—is punishable by life imprisonment or imprisonment for at least 5 years.
Where a person who has committed theft uses force or threats to resist recovery of the stolen property, avoid apprehension, or destroy evidence of the crime, the offense may be punished under the provisions applicable to robbery or aggravated robbery, depending on the circumstances.
Where a victim is injured, or injury results, in the course of a robbery, robbery resulting in injury is punishable by life imprisonment or imprisonment for at least 7 years.
The statutory penalty range must be distinguished from the sentence actually imposed in an individual case.
The outcome may vary depending on factors such as the manner of the offense, amount of loss, degree of planning, use of a weapon, role of each participant, prior record for similar offenses, recovery of the victim’s property or losses, settlement with the victim, and other sentencing considerations.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR ROBBERY AND THEFT CASES
WHEN FACING ROBBERY OR THEFT ALLEGATIONS
STEP 01 | Analyze the Incident and Initial Statements
We review the time and location of the incident, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances in which the property was obtained to determine whether the case involves theft, robbery, or another related offense.
STEP 02 | Review Objective Evidence
We examine CCTV footage, vehicle camera recordings, witness statements, mobile phone records, the victim’s statements, and other relevant evidence to determine whether the client’s account is consistent with the objective record.
STEP 03 | Analyze the Applicable Charge and Legal Issues
We examine the degree and timing of any force or threats, the manner in which the property was obtained, whether a weapon was carried or used, whether other participants were involved, and whether the victim suffered injury in order to distinguish among theft, aggravated theft, robbery, quasi-robbery, robbery resulting in injury, and other potentially applicable offenses.
STEP 04 | Respond to the Investigation and Trial
We prepare for police questioning, respond to detention and warrant proceedings where custody is at issue, and, after indictment, review restitution, settlement, sentencing materials, and other matters relevant to the defense through trial.
WHEN YOU ARE THE VICTIM OF ROBBERY OR THEFT
STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Circumstances of the Offense
We organize the time and location of the incident, the property loss, the manner in which any force or threats were used, and the victim’s response in chronological order.
STEP 02 | Secure Evidence of the Offense and Harm
We collect and review objective materials such as CCTV footage, photographs of the scene, medical records, messages, information identifying stolen property, financial transaction records, and other evidence establishing the offense and resulting harm.
STEP 03 | Respond to the Criminal Investigation
We organize the matters that should be addressed in the victim’s statement and review whether additional evidence or written submissions should be provided to the investigative authorities.
STEP 04 | Pursue Recovery and Subsequent Proceedings
We review the return of stolen property, compensation for losses, settlement issues, and, where appropriate, separate civil claims for damages or other follow-up proceedings.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP WITH ROBBERY AND THEFT CASES
The legal character of a robbery or theft case cannot be determined solely from the fact that property was taken.
Veteran Law Firm examines the circumstances in which the property was obtained, the timing and degree of any force or threats, the involvement of other participants, the use of weapons or other objects, and the manner in which any injury or property loss occurred to reconstruct the full course of events.
Even where a person is being investigated for robbery, we closely examine whether the degree of force or threats and the circumstances surrounding the taking actually satisfy the legal requirements for robbery or whether a different offense may be at issue.
Conversely, where force, threats, or injury occurred during or immediately after a theft, we also assess whether the facts may give rise to additional liability for quasi-robbery, robbery resulting in injury, or another aggravated offense.
For victims, we organize the evidence needed to establish both the offense and the resulting harm and review the necessary steps from the criminal investigation through property recovery, compensation, and any appropriate civil proceedings.
DISTINCTIVE REPRESENTATION BY FORMER POLICE OFFICER ATTORNEYS
Robbery and theft cases often require investigators to reconstruct the actual sequence of events by connecting CCTV footage, witness accounts, statements from the victim and suspect, scene evidence, mobile phone records, and other materials in chronological order.
Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys draw on practical experience analyzing evidence and statements in criminal investigations to closely examine whether CCTV footage, video evidence, scene materials, and the statements of the suspect, victim, and witnesses are consistent with one another or contain contradictions requiring further review.
This analysis is particularly important where several people were present at the scene.
Rather than assuming criminal responsibility merely because a person was present, we examine what each individual actually did, when that person became involved, whether there was a shared criminal intent, and the extent to which each participant may legally be held responsible as a principal or accomplice.
Where the same incident also gives rise to civil claims, family-related proceedings, school disciplinary matters, or other legal disputes, we consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
Based on this fact-intensive reconstruction of the incident, Veteran Law Firm develops a case-specific strategy covering police questioning, detention and warrant proceedings, criminal trial, victim compensation, and any necessary follow-up proceedings.
IN A ROBBERY OR THEFT CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER PROPERTY CHANGED HANDS, BUT HOW IT WAS TAKEN, WHETHER FORCE OR THREATS WERE USED, WHEN THEY WERE USED, AND WHAT ROLE EACH PERSON PLAYED.
Carefully reconstructing the sequence of events and analyzing the objective evidence from the earliest stage can determine not only whether criminal liability exists, but also which offense properly applies and the true scope of each person’s responsibility.
OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES
WHAT IS OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES?
Obstruction of official duties may be established where a person uses force or threats against a public official who is lawfully performing official duties and thereby interferes with the performance of those duties.
Article 136 of Korea’s Criminal Act provides criminal punishment for the use of force or threats against a public official in the course of performing official duties.
However, not every confrontation involving a public official constitutes obstruction of official duties. It is necessary to examine whether the official was lawfully performing an authorized duty, whether force or threats actually occurred, and whether the accused acted with the intent required for the offense.
These cases may arise in a wide range of situations, including police responses to emergency calls, DUI enforcement, arrest procedures, public-service complaint settings, and firefighting or emergency rescue activities.
It is therefore important to distinguish between verbal protest or an argument and conduct that crosses the line into criminal obstruction.
KEY LEGAL ISSUES IN OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES CASES
One of the first issues to examine is whether the public official’s performance of duty was lawful.
The offense protects the lawful performance of official duties. The Supreme Court has held that the official conduct must fall within the public official’s general authority, remain within the scope of that authority in the specific circumstances, and comply with essential procedural requirements. Lawfulness is assessed objectively and reasonably in light of the circumstances existing at the time.
The nature and degree of the alleged force or threats are also important.
Rather than focusing solely on whether voices were raised or a physical confrontation occurred, it is necessary to examine the manner of any physical contact, threatening gestures or statements, the surrounding circumstances, and the overall sequence of events.
Where a police officer or other public official is injured, additional offenses such as bodily injury may also be at issue. Where several people participate or a dangerous object is used, the conduct may give rise to additional or more serious criminal liability depending on the specific facts.
PENALTIES FOR OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES
Under Article 136(1) of Korea’s Criminal Act, a person who uses force or threats against a public official in the performance of official duties may be punished by imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
The statutory maximum, however, should be distinguished from the sentence actually imposed in an individual case.
The outcome may vary depending on factors such as the nature and degree of the force or threats, the circumstances leading to the incident, the extent of any injury suffered by the public official, prior convictions for similar conduct, the accused’s conduct after the incident, and any efforts to address the resulting harm.
Where bodily injury occurs during the incident or the conduct involves repeated or serious violence, the case may be evaluated more seriously and additional criminal charges may also need to be considered.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES CASES
WHEN FACING ALLEGATIONS OF OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES
STEP 01 | Analyze the Scene and the Circumstances of the Contact
We review why contact with the public official occurred, how the incident began, what was said and done, and whether any physical contact took place to identify the specific conduct alleged to constitute obstruction.
STEP 02 | Examine the Lawfulness of the Official Conduct
We review the nature of the official duty, the public official’s legal authority, and the procedures followed at the scene to determine whether the conduct constituted lawful performance of official duties.
STEP 03 | Analyze Objective Evidence
We examine CCTV footage, police body-worn camera footage, surrounding video recordings, witness statements, radio communications, and other available materials to determine whether the parties’ statements are consistent with what actually occurred.
STEP 04 | Respond to the Police Investigation and Trial
We prepare for police questioning with a focus on the degree of any alleged force or threats, the accused’s intent, and the lawfulness of the official conduct. If charges are filed, we organize the necessary legal arguments and sentencing materials for trial.
WHEN A PUBLIC OFFICIAL HAS BEEN THE VICTIM OF OBSTRUCTION
STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Performance of Official Duties
We organize what official duty was being performed when the incident occurred and document the other person’s statements and conduct in detail.
STEP 02 | Secure Evidence of the Conduct and Resulting Harm
We collect and review body-worn camera footage, CCTV footage, radio records, witness statements, medical records, and other materials that may establish the force or threats used and the interference with official duties.
STEP 03 | Prepare for Statements to Investigative Authorities
We organize the facts concerning the official duty being performed, the other person’s conduct, and the nature and extent of any injury or other harm so that the incident can be accurately presented during the investigation.
STEP 04 | Review Subsequent Proceedings
Where bodily injury, property damage, or other losses have occurred, we review any necessary follow-up measures, including compensation claims and the submission of the victim’s position during subsequent criminal proceedings.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP WITH OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES CASES
An obstruction of official duties case cannot be properly evaluated based on a single moment described simply as “touching a public official” or “arguing with a police officer.”
Veteran Law Firm reconstructs the incident chronologically, beginning with how the encounter started and examining the nature of the official duty, the degree and timing of any physical contact or statements, and the way the situation developed at the scene.
We do not rely solely on initial statements. We compare those statements with objective evidence such as CCTV footage, body-worn camera recordings, radio communications, and witness accounts to distinguish between facts that should be acknowledged and issues that require challenge.
We also examine the lawfulness of the official conduct, the nature and degree of the alleged force or threats, and whether any injury occurred in order to develop the appropriate strategy for the police investigation and subsequent criminal proceedings.
DISTINCTIVE REPRESENTATION BY FORMER POLICE OFFICER ATTORNEYS
Obstruction of official duties cases often require a detailed understanding of how police officers and other public officials respond to rapidly developing situations in the field.
Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys draw on practical experience involving emergency responses, physical restraint, arrest procedures, suspect questioning, and other field situations to analyze whether the conduct of the officers involved fell within the ordinary and lawful scope of their duties and how the incident actually developed.
We compare police body-worn camera footage, CCTV footage, radio communications, field reports, and statements from both the accused and the officers involved in order to reconstruct the sequence of events that may not be apparent from written investigative records alone.
Where the same incident also gives rise to bodily injury claims, civil proceedings, disciplinary matters, or other related disputes, we consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
Based on this combination of field experience and evidence analysis, Veteran Law Firm develops a case-specific strategy covering the initial police investigation, review of the lawfulness of the official conduct, detention and warrant proceedings where necessary, criminal trial, and any related follow-up procedures.
IN AN OBSTRUCTION OF OFFICIAL DUTIES CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A CONFRONTATION WITH A PUBLIC OFFICIAL OCCURRED, BUT WHETHER THE OFFICIAL DUTY WAS LAWFULLY PERFORMED AND WHETHER THE CONDUCT IN QUESTION LEGALLY CONSTITUTED FORCE OR THREATS AGAINST THAT DUTY.
Carefully reconstructing the scene, reviewing the lawfulness of the official conduct, and comparing the parties’ statements with objective evidence from the earliest stage can be critical to determining the proper scope of criminal responsibility.
GAMBLING OFFENSES
WHAT IS GAMBLING?
Gambling generally refers to wagering money, property, or another financial benefit on an uncertain outcome where gain or loss depends substantially on chance.
Under Korea’s Criminal Act, gambling is subject to criminal punishment, although an exception applies where the conduct amounts only to a temporary form of recreation or entertainment.
A gambling case is not determined solely by whether a person participated on a single occasion. The overall circumstances—including the duration and frequency of gambling, the amounts wagered, the manner of participation, prior gambling history, and degree of repetition—may be relevant in determining whether the conduct constitutes ordinary gambling or habitual gambling.
In particular, online baccarat, unauthorized sports betting, and other forms of illegal internet gambling often generate extensive digital and financial records. Bank transaction histories, account deposits and withdrawals, login records, betting histories, and other site data may become important evidence during an investigation.
For that reason, it is important to identify the actual scope and pattern of use accurately from the earliest stage of the case.
KEY LEGAL ISSUES IN GAMBLING CASES
Criminal responsibility in a gambling case is not determined solely by the total amount deposited into a gambling account.
Important considerations may include what type of gambling was involved, how long and how frequently the person participated, the actual scale of deposits and withdrawals, whether similar gambling occurred previously, and the overall pattern of conduct.
In online gambling cases, closing an account or ceasing to use a gambling site does not erase evidence of past activity. Previous use may still be identified through financial transaction records, materials obtained from site operators, mobile phone data, messenger communications, and other digital evidence.
It is also important to distinguish between an ordinary participant and a person who played a broader role in the gambling operation.
A person who merely placed bets may face a different form and degree of criminal responsibility from someone who operated a gambling site, recruited users, managed accounts, handled deposits or withdrawals, exchanged gambling credits for money, or otherwise participated in the operation of the gambling business.
The client’s actual role should therefore be identified before the legal issues are assessed.
PENALTIES FOR GAMBLING OFFENSES
Under Article 246 of Korea’s Criminal Act, ordinary gambling is punishable by a fine of up to KRW 10 million, except where the conduct amounts only to temporary recreation or entertainment.
Where gambling is committed habitually, habitual gambling may be punished by imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 20 million.
Under Article 247 of the Criminal Act, a person who, for profit, establishes a place or space for gambling may be punished by imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 30 million.
The statutory penalty, however, must be distinguished from the actual disposition or sentence imposed in an individual case.
The outcome may vary depending on factors such as the duration and frequency of the gambling, the amounts involved, whether the conduct was habitual, prior gambling-related convictions or dispositions, the defendant’s degree of participation, the role played in any gambling operation, conduct after the investigation began, and efforts to prevent recurrence.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR GAMBLING CASES
WHEN FACING GAMBLING ALLEGATIONS
STEP 01 | Analyze the Gambling History and Actual Use
We review how the gambling began, the period and frequency of participation, the scale of deposits and withdrawals, the sites or platforms used, and other relevant circumstances to determine the actual form and extent of involvement.
STEP 02 | Examine Habitual Gambling and the Scope of Criminal Responsibility
We assess whether the conduct may constitute ordinary or habitual gambling and determine whether the client had any additional role involving operation, recruitment, account management, money exchange, or other participation beyond placing bets.
We also review any prior gambling-related history that may be relevant to the case.
STEP 03 | Analyze Objective Evidence
We examine bank transaction records, betting histories, site-use records, messenger communications, mobile phone data, and other available evidence to determine whether the client’s statements are consistent with the actual pattern of gambling activity.
STEP 04 | Respond to the Police Investigation and Trial
We prepare for questioning based on the issues investigators are likely to examine. Where responsibility is acknowledged, we also organize case-specific materials concerning remorse, cessation of gambling, recurrence prevention, financial circumstances, and other matters that may be relevant at the prosecution or sentencing stage.
WHEN YOU HAVE SUFFERED FINANCIAL LOSS IN CONNECTION WITH ILLEGAL GAMBLING
STEP 01 | Reconstruct How the Loss Occurred
We identify how the client was introduced or directed to the gambling site, what representations or advertisements were made, how much money was deposited, and what problems occurred during withdrawals or other transactions.
STEP 02 | Secure Relevant Evidence
We collect and review deposit and withdrawal records, screenshots of the website or application, messenger communications, advertisements, account information, and other materials showing how the transactions and alleged loss occurred.
STEP 03 | Determine the Nature of the Potential Offense
We examine whether the loss was simply the result of gambling activity or whether the operation of the site may involve fraud, manipulation, misappropriation, or another criminal offense.
The legal analysis depends on the actual structure of the transactions and conduct of the operators rather than the fact that the matter involved a gambling site.
STEP 04 | Consider Criminal and Civil Remedies
Depending on the circumstances, we review whether a criminal complaint may be appropriate and whether there is a legally viable basis for civil recovery or other follow-up proceedings.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP WITH GAMBLING CASES
A gambling case cannot be properly evaluated based only on the total amount deposited or the length of time a site was used.
Veteran Law Firm examines the full course of conduct, including how the gambling began, the frequency and duration of participation, the flow of deposits and withdrawals, prior gambling history, and the client’s actual role in the relevant activity.
In online gambling cases, we closely analyze objective records such as financial transactions, betting histories, and site-use data to determine whether the person was simply a participant, whether habitual gambling may be at issue, or whether the evidence suggests involvement in operating, recruiting for, or otherwise supporting the gambling operation.
Even where the gambling itself is acknowledged, we do not begin by assuming a particular outcome. We first establish the actual facts and scope of participation and then prepare the response required for the police investigation, prosecution, trial, and any necessary recurrence-prevention or sentencing submissions.
DISTINCTIVE REPRESENTATION BY FORMER POLICE OFFICER ATTORNEYS
Gambling investigations often require investigators to reconstruct the actual pattern of activity by connecting bank transaction histories, mobile phone data, messenger communications, site records, and statements made by the suspect.
Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys draw on practical investigative experience involving financial transactions, digital evidence, and suspect interviews to analyze how investigators are likely to determine the duration and scale of gambling, habituality, and the client’s degree of participation.
In online gambling cases in particular, we do not rely solely on statements such as “I only used the site once or twice.” We compare those statements with the actual account flow, betting history, access records, and other available evidence to identify and address inconsistencies before they become central issues in the investigation.
Where the same conduct also gives rise to related financial disputes, fraud allegations, civil claims, disciplinary matters, or other proceedings, we consider how evidence and statements from the criminal investigation may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
Based on this analysis of the facts and evidence, Veteran Law Firm develops a case-specific strategy covering the initial police investigation, habituality and the scope of participation, detention issues where relevant, criminal trial, and any necessary follow-up proceedings.
IN A GAMBLING CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY HOW MUCH MONEY WAS DEPOSITED, BUT HOW THE GAMBLING OCCURRED, HOW OFTEN AND FOR HOW LONG IT CONTINUED, AND WHAT ROLE THE PERSON ACTUALLY PLAYED.
Carefully reconstructing the financial and digital record from the outset can be critical to distinguishing ordinary participation from habitual gambling or involvement in a gambling operation and to determining the true scope of criminal responsibility.
DEFAMATION
WHAT IS DEFAMATION?
Defamation may arise where a person publicly alleges facts or false facts concerning another person in a manner capable of harming that person’s social reputation.
Under Korea’s Criminal Act, defamation based on true factual allegations and defamation based on false factual allegations are treated separately. The legal analysis therefore extends beyond the wording of the statement or post itself and may include who received it, how widely it was disseminated, and whether the expression alleged a specific fact or instead amounted primarily to an opinion, evaluation, or value judgment.
Expressions made through online posts, social media, group chats, videos, comments, and other channels capable of rapid dissemination require particular attention to the actual and potential scope of distribution and the circumstances in which the content was created and shared.
The fact that a statement is true does not automatically eliminate criminal liability under Korean law. Article 310 of the Criminal Act, however, provides that conduct falling under Article 307(1) is not punishable where the alleged facts are true and relate solely to the public interest. Both truthfulness and public-interest considerations must therefore be carefully examined.
KEY LEGAL ISSUES IN DEFAMATION CASES
A defamation case should not be evaluated by isolating a single sentence from the broader communication.
The background of the statement, the surrounding conversation or context, the intended audience, and the actual or potential scope of dissemination should all be considered together.
For a suspect or defendant, key issues may include whether the statement was true or false, whether it alleged a sufficiently specific fact rather than merely expressing an opinion or evaluation, and whether a truthful statement may fall within the public-interest exception under Korean law.
For a victim, it is important to identify precisely what was said or posted, when and where it was communicated, who received it, and how widely it was disseminated. Objective evidence such as screenshots, URLs, messages, video files, and recordings should be preserved wherever possible.
Defamation under Articles 307 and 309 of the Criminal Act is an offense that cannot be prosecuted against the victim’s clearly expressed wishes. If the victim expressly states that punishment is not desired, prosecution cannot proceed contrary to that position.
PENALTIES FOR DEFAMATION
Under Article 307(1) of the Criminal Act, publicly alleging facts in a manner that defames another person is punishable by imprisonment or detention for up to 2 years or a fine of up to KRW 5 million.
Where false facts are publicly alleged, Article 307(2) provides for imprisonment for up to 5 years, suspension of qualifications for up to 10 years, or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
Where defamation is committed through a newspaper, magazine, radio, or other publication with the purpose of disparaging another person, Article 309 may apply. Defamation based on true facts is punishable by imprisonment or detention for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 7 million, while defamation based on false facts is punishable by imprisonment for up to 7 years, suspension of qualifications for up to 10 years, or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.
The statutory penalty range must be distinguished from the actual prosecutorial disposition or sentence imposed in an individual case.
The outcome may vary depending on the content and manner of the expression, whether the statement was false, the extent of dissemination, the degree of harm caused, whether the content was later deleted or corrected, whether an apology was made, whether a settlement was reached, and other case-specific circumstances.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR DEFAMATION CASES
WHEN FACING DEFAMATION ALLEGATIONS
STEP 01 | Analyze the Expression and the Circumstances in Which It Was Made
We review the content of the statement or post, when it was made, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances leading to the expression to identify precisely what aspect is alleged to be defamatory.
STEP 02 | Examine Truth or Falsity and the Nature of the Expression
We determine whether the expression alleges a specific fact or is closer to an opinion or evaluation and, where it concerns factual allegations, review whether objective materials support their truthfulness.
STEP 03 | Analyze Public-Interest Considerations and the Evidence
We examine posts, messenger communications, recordings, related documents, and other materials to determine whether a truthful factual statement may qualify as an expression made in the public interest.
STEP 04 | Respond to the Police Investigation and Trial
We prepare statements around the issues likely to be examined by investigators and, where appropriate, consider case-specific measures such as deletion or correction of the content, an apology, settlement, or other efforts to address the alleged harm.
WHEN YOU HAVE BEEN THE VICTIM OF DEFAMATION
STEP 01 | Document the Defamatory Content and Its Dissemination
We identify what was said or posted, when and where it was communicated, who received it, and how widely it was distributed or shared.
STEP 02 | Secure Relevant Evidence
We preserve screenshots, URLs, videos, recordings, text messages, messenger communications, and other materials showing both the defamatory content and the circumstances of its dissemination.
STEP 03 | Respond Through the Criminal Process
We assess whether the facts support a criminal complaint, identify the potentially applicable offense, and prepare the complaint and supporting materials describing the alleged harm.
STEP 04 | Pursue Removal, Damage Recovery, and Civil Remedies
We review measures to remove the content or limit further dissemination and, where appropriate, consider a civil claim for compensation for emotional or financial harm.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP WITH DEFAMATION CASES
A defamation case cannot be resolved simply by arguing that “the statement was true” or “the statement was false.”
Veteran Law Firm examines the full context of the expression, including what was said, why it was said, who received it, the surrounding communications, and the actual scope of dissemination.
For suspects and defendants, we distinguish among truth, falsity, factual allegations, opinions or evaluations, and public-interest considerations to identify the central legal issues.
For victims, we connect the defamatory content, the circumstances of dissemination, and the resulting harm with objective evidence to develop an appropriate response strategy.
We also consider issues that may arise alongside the criminal case, including removal of online content, prevention of further dissemination, settlement, and civil claims for damages.
DISTINCTIVE REPRESENTATION BY FORMER POLICE OFFICER ATTORNEYS
In a defamation case, understanding how investigators are likely to evaluate the circumstances of the expression, the accused’s intent, and the possibility of dissemination can be just as important as reviewing the statement itself.
Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys draw on practical experience analyzing statements and digital evidence to examine the relationship among online posts, messenger communications, recordings, communication records, and the statements of the parties.
In online defamation cases in particular, we do not rely solely on a single screenshot. We reconstruct the broader sequence of events by reviewing communications before and after the post, the timing of publication, the intended and actual audience, and any subsequent deletion, correction, or modification of the content.
Where the same expression also gives rise to civil claims, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, school-related matters, family disputes, or other legal proceedings, we consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
Based on this analysis of the facts and evidence, Veteran Law Firm develops a case-specific strategy from the preparation of a criminal complaint or initial police investigation through criminal trial, content removal, civil damages claims, and any necessary follow-up proceedings.
IN A DEFAMATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A STATEMENT WAS TRUE OR FALSE, BUT WHAT WAS COMMUNICATED, IN WHAT CONTEXT, TO WHOM, AND WITH WHAT EFFECT ON THE OTHER PERSON’S REPUTATION.
Carefully preserving the full context of the communication and the evidence of how it was created, transmitted, and disseminated can be critical to determining whether criminal defamation is established and to protecting the rights of both the accused and the victim.
INSULT
WHAT IS CRIMINAL INSULT?
Criminal insult is an offense under Article 311 of Korea’s Criminal Act that may be established where a person publicly insults another person.
Unlike defamation, insult does not require the allegation of a specific fact. Instead, it generally concerns contemptuous or degrading expressions capable of undermining another person’s personal dignity or social reputation.
The offense may arise not only from profanity or derogatory remarks made in person, but also from expressions posted or communicated through online forums, comments, social media, group chats, and other digital platforms.
However, not every rude, offensive, or unpleasant expression constitutes criminal insult.
The legal analysis requires consideration of the specific wording used, the circumstances in which it was expressed, whether the victim was identifiable, whether the expression was made publicly, and the broader context before and after the statement.
Criminal insult is also an offense that requires a complaint by the victim before prosecution may be brought. Accordingly, both the accused and the victim should consider the implications of filing, withdrawing, or resolving a criminal complaint from the earliest stage of the case.
PENALTIES FOR CRIMINAL INSULT
Under Article 311 of the Criminal Act, publicly insulting another person is punishable by:
imprisonment or detention for up to 1 year, or a fine of up to KRW 2 million.
The statutory penalty should be distinguished from the actual disposition or sentence imposed in an individual case.
The outcome may vary depending on the severity and nature of the expression, the circumstances in which it was made, whether the conduct was repeated, the extent of harm caused, whether the parties reached a settlement, whether meaningful efforts were made to address the harm, prior history involving similar conduct, and other case-specific circumstances.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR CRIMINAL INSULT CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Analyze the Facts and Evidence
We examine the exact statement, post, or message at issue, where and when it was made, the surrounding circumstances, and the communications before and after the expression.
We also review relevant evidence such as recordings, messages, online posts, screenshots, and witness statements.
STEP 02 | Determine Whether the Legal Requirements for Criminal Insult Are Satisfied
We examine whether the expression constitutes an insult in its legal context and whether the other requirements of the offense are satisfied, including whether the victim was sufficiently identifiable and whether the statement was made publicly.
STEP 03 | Develop a Strategy for Police Questioning
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we review possible settlement and measures to address the victim’s harm.
Where the allegation is disputed, we develop the defense around the particular issues in the case, including the full context of the expression, whether it was sufficiently insulting in law, identification of the alleged victim, and the requirement of publicity.
STEP 04 | Respond to the Investigation and Trial
We prepare for anticipated questions and the appropriate statement strategy from the initial police investigation.
At the prosecution and trial stages, we submit relevant evidence, legal arguments, and, where appropriate, sentencing materials based on the circumstances of the case.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Document the Harm and Secure Evidence
We organize when and where the insulting expression occurred, the exact language used, the circumstances surrounding the incident, and who was present or able to receive the communication.
We secure objective evidence such as recordings, messages, social media posts, screenshots, and witness statements.
STEP 02 | Review the Basis for a Criminal Complaint and Prepare the Complaint
We examine whether the legal requirements for criminal insult are satisfied and prepare a complaint setting out the relevant conduct and supporting evidence.
STEP 03 | Prepare for the Victim Interview
We organize the chronology and harm so that the circumstances of the incident can be presented consistently and specifically during the police investigation, while identifying any additional evidence that should be submitted.
STEP 04 | Review Settlement and Recovery
Where the accused requests a settlement, we carefully examine the proposed terms and whether withdrawal of the criminal complaint is appropriate.
Where necessary, we also consider civil claims for damages or other measures aimed at meaningful recovery.
STEP 05 | Respond Through the Investigation and Trial
We monitor the progress of the investigation, submit necessary opinions and supporting materials, and assist in ensuring that the victim’s position is appropriately presented through subsequent criminal proceedings.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Understand How an Investigation Develops
A criminal insult case is rarely determined by the disputed expression alone.
It is necessary to examine who heard or received the statement, the circumstances in which it was made, what was said immediately before and after it, what objective evidence exists, and how those facts are likely to be presented during police questioning.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to identify from the outset the issues that investigators are likely to examine and to develop an appropriate response strategy.
01 | Analyze the Key Issues from an Investigative Perspective
Based on practical knowledge of police investigation procedures, we identify the questions investigators are likely to focus on and organize the evidence needed to address those issues.
02 | Prepare the Statement Strategy Before the First Police Interview
We organize the facts and chronology before substantive questioning begins so that the client’s position can be presented accurately and consistently from the first interview.
03 | Analyze the Entire Context, Not Just a Single Expression
We do not isolate the disputed words from the surrounding circumstances.
We examine why the statement was made, the relationship between the parties, preceding remarks, whether third parties could identify the victim, the scope of publication or communication, and the events before and after the expression.
04 | Develop a Case-Specific Strategy Depending on Whether the Allegation Is Contested or Acknowledged
We distinguish between cases in which the legal requirements of the offense should be challenged and cases in which settlement, harm reduction, and other remedial measures should take priority.
The strategy is tailored to the actual facts and objectives of the client.
05 | Maintain a Consistent Strategy from Police Investigation Through Prosecution and Trial
We provide coordinated representation so that the central factual and legal positions remain consistent from the initial investigation through prosecution and, where necessary, criminal trial.
Where the same expression also gives rise to civil claims, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, school-related matters, family disputes, or other legal proceedings, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A CRIMINAL INSULT CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER THE WORDS WERE OFFENSIVE, BUT WHETHER, IN THEIR FULL CONTEXT, THEY SATISFY THE LEGAL REQUIREMENTS OF PUBLIC INSULT UNDER KOREAN LAW.
The exact wording, surrounding conversation, audience, identifiability of the victim, scope of publication, and objective evidence should all be examined together from the earliest stage of the case.
FALSE ACCUSATION
WHAT IS THE OFFENSE OF FALSE ACCUSATION?
The offense of false accusation is established under Article 156 of Korea’s Criminal Act when a person reports false facts to a public office or public official for the purpose of causing another person to be subjected to criminal punishment or disciplinary action.
The offense is not established merely because a report later turns out to be inconsistent with the actual facts.
It is necessary to examine whether the reported facts were objectively false, whether the person making the report knew that they were false, and whether the report was made for the purpose of causing another person to face criminal or disciplinary action.
Even where part of a complaint or report is inaccurate, the offense may not be established if the discrepancy concerns only a minor exaggeration or a detail that does not materially affect whether the alleged offense occurred.
Likewise, where a person accurately reports the underlying facts but reaches an incorrect legal conclusion about those facts, that does not automatically amount to reporting false facts.
For that reason, a false accusation case requires a careful comparison between the original complaint or report and the objective evidence, with particular attention to what the reporting person actually knew and believed at the time the report was made.
PENALTIES FOR FALSE ACCUSATION
Under Article 156 of the Criminal Act, a person who reports false facts to a public office or public official for the purpose of causing another person to be subjected to criminal punishment or disciplinary action may be punished by:
imprisonment for up to 10 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.
Under the Korean Sentencing Commission’s sentencing guidelines for general false accusation offenses, the recommended ranges are:
Mitigated: up to 1 year
Standard: 6 months to 2 years
Aggravated: 1 year to 4 years
The statutory penalty and the sentencing guideline range must be distinguished from the actual sentence imposed in an individual case.
The outcome may vary depending on the nature and seriousness of the false report, the circumstances in which it was made, the extent of harm caused, conduct after the offense, voluntary surrender or confession, recovery of harm, prior criminal history, and other case-specific sentencing factors.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR FALSE ACCUSATION CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Analyze the Original Complaint, Report, and Evidence
We obtain and review the original criminal complaint, petition, or other report that gave rise to the false accusation allegation, together with text messages, messenger communications, call records, photographs, videos, and other materials submitted at the time.
We then compare the reported facts with the objective record.
STEP 02 | Examine Falsity and Intent
We determine whether the reported facts were objectively false and whether, at the time of reporting, the client had a reasonable factual basis for believing them to be true.
This analysis is central to determining whether the legal requirements for false accusation are satisfied.
STEP 03 | Reconstruct the Circumstances and the Client’s State of Knowledge at the Time of the Report
We examine why the original complaint or report was made, what the client knew at the time, what evidence was then available, and the relationship between the parties.
We identify circumstances that may distinguish a mistake, misunderstanding, or subjective interpretation from a knowingly false report.
STEP 04 | Develop a Strategy for Police Questioning
We organize the facts to avoid unnecessary inconsistencies between the original report and statements made during the false accusation investigation.
We prepare for anticipated questions with particular focus on objective falsity, the client’s knowledge and belief at the time of reporting, and the purpose of the original complaint.
STEP 05 | Respond to Prosecution and Criminal Trial
We analyze the evidence obtained during the investigation together with the record of the original case and challenge whether the elements of false accusation are actually established.
If charges are filed, we develop the defense around the objective truth or falsity of the reported facts, the client’s knowledge at the time, and the required intent.
FOR VICTIMS OF AN ALLEGED FALSE ACCUSATION
STEP 01 | Analyze the Original Criminal Case and Its Procedural History
We review the allegations made against the client in the original criminal matter, the outcome of that case, and the complaint, statements, and other materials submitted by the reporting person.
We identify the specific portions that may constitute a knowingly false report.
STEP 02 | Secure Evidence Establishing Falsity
We collect and analyze objective evidence that contradicts the original allegations, including CCTV footage, recordings, text and messenger communications, location or access records, and statements from third parties.
STEP 03 | Assess Whether the Requirements for False Accusation Are Satisfied
The fact that the original case ended without charges or resulted in an acquittal does not, by itself, establish that the reporting person committed false accusation.
We also examine whether the person knew the relevant allegations were false when the report was made and whether the other statutory elements can be established.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Respond to the Police Investigation
We identify precisely which reported facts are alleged to be false and connect each allegation with the objective evidence that contradicts it.
We then prepare for police questioning so that the background of the original case and the circumstances indicating a knowingly false report can be explained clearly and consistently.
STEP 05 | Pursue Criminal Proceedings and Recovery of Harm
As the investigation proceeds, we submit additional evidence and legal arguments where necessary.
Where the false report caused identifiable financial, reputational, or other legally compensable harm, we also review whether separate civil remedies may be available.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Reconstruct the Investigation from the Original Case Forward
A false accusation case cannot be properly analyzed by looking only at the new allegation of false reporting.
It is necessary to examine what was originally alleged, what statements were made during the first police investigation, how those statements compare with the objective evidence, and what the reporting person actually knew at the time of the original complaint.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to review the entire sequence from the original complaint through the subsequent false accusation investigation and develop a consistent strategy based on that record.
01 | Reexamine the Case from the Original Complaint
We do not analyze the false accusation case in isolation.
We review how the original complaint or report arose, what was stated during the police investigation, what evidence was submitted, and how the original case was ultimately handled.
02 | Analyze Falsity from an Investigative Perspective
Drawing on practical police experience, we consider what statements and evidence investigators are likely to use in determining whether the original report was false and identify the materials that are most significant to that analysis.
03 | Cross-Check Prior Statements Against Objective Evidence
We compare the original complaint, police statements, text and messenger communications, recordings, CCTV footage, entry and access records, and other objective evidence to identify where the statements are consistent with the record and where material contradictions exist.
04 | Prepare the Statement Strategy Before the First Police Interview
A false accusation investigation may involve close scrutiny of statements made in the original case.
We therefore review the relationship between past and present statements in advance and prepare for anticipated questions so that the client’s position remains accurate and internally consistent.
05 | Develop a Strategy Tailored to Suspects and Victims
Where the client is accused of false accusation, we focus on whether the reported facts were objectively false and whether the client knowingly made a false report with the required purpose.
Where the client was the target of an allegedly false report, we focus on objective evidence showing how the report differs from the actual facts and whether the reporting person knew of that discrepancy at the time.
06 | Maintain a Consistent Strategy from Police Investigation Through Prosecution and Trial
We connect the record of the original case with the evidence and statements in the false accusation case so that the central factual and legal position remains consistent through police investigation, prosecution, and criminal trial.
Where the original dispute also involves civil litigation, family proceedings, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, school-related matters, or other legal processes, we also consider how statements and findings in those proceedings may affect the false accusation case and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A FALSE ACCUSATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER THE ORIGINAL ALLEGATION PROVED TO BE WRONG, BUT WHETHER A MATERIALLY FALSE FACT WAS KNOWINGLY REPORTED FOR THE PURPOSE OF SUBJECTING ANOTHER PERSON TO CRIMINAL OR DISCIPLINARY ACTION.
Reconstructing the original complaint, the evidence available at the time, and the reporting person’s actual state of knowledge is often critical to determining whether the offense of false accusation is established.
CRIMINAL ORGANIZATIONS & MEMBERSHIP
WHAT IS MEMBERSHIP IN A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP?
Criminal liability for membership in a criminal organization or group does not arise merely because a person knew people involved in crime or worked alongside them.
Article 114 of Korea’s Criminal Act provides that a person who organizes, joins, or acts as a member of an organization or group formed for the purpose of committing an offense punishable by death, life imprisonment, or imprisonment with a statutory maximum of at least four years is subject to punishment prescribed for the intended offense, although the punishment may be mitigated under the statute.
The Supreme Court has distinguished a criminal organization from an ordinary group of accomplices. A criminal organization generally requires a continuing association of multiple persons formed around a common criminal purpose, together with at least a minimum command structure capable of directing the organization or maintaining its internal order.
A “criminal group” under Article 114 does not require the same degree of command structure as a criminal organization. It must, however, have a sufficiently organized structure to enable its members, through assigned roles, to carry out qualifying crimes repeatedly and systematically. The Supreme Court has explained that such a group must be a continuing association organized around a common criminal purpose and structured in a way that facilitates the planning and execution of repeated offenses.
Accordingly, the central issues are not simply whether the accused appeared on an organizational chart or had contact with other members. It is necessary to determine whether the organization itself legally qualifies as a criminal organization or criminal group, whether the accused understood its criminal purpose when joining or participating, and what role and activities the accused actually performed within it.
In organized offenses such as voice phishing and investment fraud, liability for individual acts of fraud or other offenses may arise separately from allegations of organizing, joining, or acting as a member of a criminal organization or group. Each offense must therefore be analyzed under its own legal requirements.
MAJOR TYPES OF CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OFFENSES AND PENALTIES
ORGANIZING A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP
This may arise where a person establishes the structure and division of roles of an organization, recruits members, or otherwise forms an organization or group for a qualifying criminal purpose.
The fact that several people committed crimes together does not, by itself, make them a criminal organization or group.
It is necessary to examine whether there was a shared purpose of committing qualifying crimes, an ongoing association among the members, a division of roles, and an organizational structure capable of facilitating repeated criminal activity.
Under Article 114 of the Criminal Act, a person who organizes a qualifying criminal organization or group is punished according to the statutory penalty prescribed for the offense that the organization or group was formed to commit, subject to the statutory possibility of mitigation.
JOINING A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP
This involves entering an already existing criminal organization or group as a member.
The key issue is not merely whether the accused communicated or worked with people associated with the organization, but whether the accused joined as a member while understanding the organization’s criminal purpose and character.
Article 114 does not establish a single, separate fixed penalty for membership. Instead, a person who joins a qualifying criminal organization or group is punished according to the statutory penalty for the offense that the organization or group intends to commit, subject to the possibility of mitigation.
The potential penalty may therefore vary significantly depending on the criminal objective of the organization.
ACTING AS A MEMBER OF A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP
Where a person, after joining an organization or group, carries out activities as a member in furtherance of its criminal purpose, criminal liability for participation in the organization’s activities may arise.
Investigators may look beyond formal titles or job descriptions and examine what the person actually did, who gave instructions and received reports, how tasks were divided among members, and whether the person’s activities were connected to the organization’s criminal proceeds or operations.
Here again, Article 114 provides that punishment is based on the statutory penalty for the organization’s intended offense, subject to the statutory possibility of mitigation.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION LIABILITY AND INDIVIDUAL OFFENSES
In a criminal organization case, allegations of organizing, joining, or acting as a member of the organization may arise together with liability for individual offenses actually committed by the organization, such as fraud, robbery, extortion, or other crimes.
Accordingly, the fact that a person did not personally deceive a victim or was not physically present when an offense occurred does not automatically eliminate potential criminal organization liability.
Conversely, the fact that a person performed some work for an organization does not automatically establish that the person knew of and participated in every crime committed by the organization.
The individual’s knowledge, actual role, point of entry, duration of participation, and scope of involvement must be analyzed separately.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Determine How the Client Entered the Organization and What Role Was Actually Performed
We establish who introduced the client to the organization, what the client was told at the time, when the client became involved, and what work was actually performed.
A central issue is whether the relationship was merely employment or another limited association, or whether the client knowingly joined an organization for a criminal purpose.
STEP 02 | Examine Whether a Criminal Organization or Group Legally Existed
We review the membership structure, division of roles, command and reporting relationships, duration of operation, and method of committing offenses to determine whether the organization actually satisfies the legal requirements of a criminal organization or criminal group under the Criminal Act.
STEP 03 | Identify When the Client Became Aware of the Criminal Purpose
We examine whether the client knew of the criminal purpose before joining or only became aware of it later while performing particular tasks.
The existence and timing of this knowledge may be a critical issue in determining liability for joining a criminal organization or group.
STEP 04 | Distinguish the Client’s Role and Scope of Participation
We determine whether the client is alleged to have acted as a leader, manager, recruiter, operative, or other participant, or whether the client merely performed limited tasks at another person’s direction.
We compare those allegations with objective evidence and distinguish the client’s own conduct from the acts of other members.
STEP 05 | Respond to Police Questioning and Detention Proceedings
Organized crime investigations may expand through statements from multiple suspects, seized electronic devices, financial records, and other evidence.
Before the first substantive police interview, we clarify the client’s actual role, knowledge, and period of involvement and prepare for possible arrest or detention proceedings where necessary.
STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Criminal Trial
We determine whether the case should focus on disputing the existence of a criminal organization or group, disputing knowledge or intent regarding membership or activities, or addressing the client’s limited degree of involvement and sentencing considerations.
We then develop the appropriate strategy for prosecution and trial.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Reconstruct How the Organized Crime Caused the Harm
We organize when and how the harm occurred, who first contacted the victim, who directly participated in the offense, and what roles different individuals appeared to perform during the scheme.
STEP 02 | Secure Evidence of Organized Criminal Activity
We collect relevant communications, remittance and financial records, contracts and transaction records, recordings, and records of contact with individual participants to establish the relationship between specific offenders and the broader criminal operation.
STEP 03 | Analyze the Organizational Structure and Division of Roles
We examine whether multiple offenders repeatedly engaged in similar conduct and whether there are indications of instructions, reporting relationships, or divided responsibilities that may demonstrate organized criminal activity beyond an ordinary joint offense.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We organize not only the individual acts committed against the victim but also the apparent organizational structure and division of roles and connect those facts to objective evidence for submission to the investigative authorities.
STEP 05 | Respond to Further Harm or Retaliation
Where members of the organization make additional contact, threats, or other attempts that may cause secondary harm, we preserve the relevant evidence and consider available victim-protection measures based on the circumstances.
STEP 06 | Review Options for Recovery
Alongside the criminal proceedings, we examine potential methods of recovering financial and other legally compensable losses, including civil claims against responsible parties where appropriate.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Distinguish the Organization as a Whole from the Role of Each Individual
One of the most important distinctions in a criminal organization case is between whether the organization itself qualifies as a criminal organization or group and whether a particular person can legally be treated as one of its members.
The involvement of multiple people in the same criminal scheme does not mean that every person necessarily bears the same criminal responsibility.
Individual liability may vary depending on when the person became aware of the organization’s criminal purpose, from whom instructions were received, what duties were actually performed, how long the person participated, and how extensively the person became involved.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the case with an understanding of how organized crime investigations examine organizational charts, command structures, divisions of responsibility, and each suspect’s knowledge and participation.
01 | Reconstruct the Organization’s Actual Structure
We examine the structure identified by investigators, including command and reporting relationships and the roles attributed to individual members, to determine whether an ongoing organizational system actually existed.
02 | Determine What the Client Knew When Joining
We identify who recruited or introduced the client, how the work was described, what the client understood the work to involve, and when the client first became aware of any criminal purpose.
This is critical to analyzing whether the required intent for membership can be established.
03 | Separate the Client’s Actual Conduct from the Organization as a Whole
We distinguish offenses committed across the organization from conduct actually performed by the client and analyze the client’s substantive degree of involvement based on instructions received, the scope of duties, and the duration of participation.
04 | Cross-Check Seized Evidence Against Statements from Other Members
We compare mobile phone and electronic data, account and transaction records, and other objective evidence seized or obtained during the investigation with statements made by other alleged members to determine whether their descriptions accurately reflect the client’s actual role.
05 | Respond to Expanding Investigations and the Risk of Detention
Criminal organization investigations frequently expand from one suspect to others through statements, seized devices, financial records, and communication data.
We identify the likely scope and direction of the investigation from the earliest stage and prepare for police questioning and any detention or warrant proceedings.
06 | Distinguish Individual Responsibility from the First Police Interview
Drawing on experience with organized crime investigations, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators are likely to establish the organization’s structure and command system, knowledge of its criminal purpose, and each individual member’s role and degree of participation, and develop a consistent strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.
IN A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A PERSON WORKED WITH PEOPLE WHO COMMITTED CRIMES, BUT WHETHER A QUALIFYING CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP EXISTED AND WHETHER THAT PERSON KNOWINGLY JOINED OR ACTED AS A MEMBER OF IT.
Carefully distinguishing the organization’s criminal purpose from the individual’s own knowledge, role, timing, and scope of participation can be critical to determining the true extent of criminal responsibility.
FORGERY OF PRIVATE DOCUMENTS
WHAT IS FORGERY OF A PRIVATE DOCUMENT?
Forgery of a private document may be established where a person, without authority and for the purpose of using the document as genuine, forges or alters another person’s document or drawing concerning rights, obligations, or proof of facts.
Article 231 of Korea’s Criminal Act criminalizes the forgery or alteration of such private documents. The key issue is not simply whether the document contains false information. It is necessary to examine who had authority to create the document, whether another person’s name or authorship was used without authority so that the document falsely appeared to have been made by that person, and whether there was an intent to use it as a genuine document.
A wide range of private documents may be involved, including contracts, settlement agreements, confirmations, certificates, and other documents evidencing legal rights, obligations, or material facts.
The same concerns may also arise in digital form. Where electronic records concerning rights, obligations, or proof of facts are falsely created or altered with the purpose of causing errors in the handling of business affairs, separate criminal liability for falsification or alteration of private electronic records may arise under the Criminal Act.
Where a forged or altered document is actually submitted, presented, or otherwise used as genuine, a separate offense of using a forged private document may also apply. The entire sequence—from creation or alteration of the document through its eventual submission or use—must therefore be examined together.
MAJOR TYPES OF PRIVATE DOCUMENT FORGERY AND PENALTIES
FORGERY OR ALTERATION OF A PRIVATE DOCUMENT
This offense may arise where a person creates a document concerning rights, obligations, or proof of facts in another person’s name without authority, or alters an existing document without authorization.
Under Article 231 of the Criminal Act, the offense is punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
Important issues may include whether the accused had authority to prepare the document, whether the named person consented or authorized its preparation, what portion of the document was altered, and whether the document was created or altered for the purpose of using it as genuine.
A document does not become a “forged” document merely because its contents are inaccurate or false. In forgery cases, the authenticity of authorship and the authority to create the document are central issues.
MAKING A PRIVATE DOCUMENT BY FALSELY ASSUMING ANOTHER PERSON’S STATUS OR AUTHORITY
Article 232 of the Criminal Act may apply where a person, for the purpose of using the document, falsely assumes another person’s status, authority, or representative capacity and creates a document concerning rights, obligations, or proof of facts.
For example, depending on the circumstances, this issue may arise where a person prepares a document while falsely presenting himself or herself as holding another person’s corporate position, representative authority, agency authority, or other legal capacity.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
FALSIFICATION OR ALTERATION OF PRIVATE ELECTRONIC RECORDS
Criminal liability is not limited to traditional paper documents.
Under Article 232-2 of the Criminal Act, a person who falsifies or alters another person’s electronic or other special-media record concerning rights, obligations, or proof of facts for the purpose of causing errors in the handling of business affairs may be subject to criminal liability.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
Depending on the case, relevant evidence may include electronic files, revision histories, system records, access data, email transmissions, metadata, and other digital records showing when and how the electronic record was created, modified, or used.
USING A FORGED OR ALTERED PRIVATE DOCUMENT
Where a forged or altered private document, drawing, or qualifying electronic record is actually used as though it were genuine, Article 234 of the Criminal Act may apply separately.
Article 234 provides that a person who uses a document or record created through an offense under Articles 231 through 233 is subject to the penalty prescribed for the corresponding underlying offense.
Accordingly, where an ordinary forged private document under Article 231 is used, the applicable statutory penalty may likewise be:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
Where the same person both forged the document and later used it, the act of forgery and the act of use must be analyzed separately.
UNLAWFUL USE OF AN AUTHENTIC PRIVATE DOCUMENT
A document does not necessarily have to be forged for criminal liability to arise.
Where a person improperly uses another person’s authentic document concerning rights, obligations, or proof of facts without authority and in a manner inconsistent with its proper use, the offense of unlawful use of a private document may be at issue.
Under Article 236 of the Criminal Act, the offense is punishable by:
imprisonment or detention for up to 1 year, or a fine of up to KRW 3 million.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR PRIVATE DOCUMENT FORGERY CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Examine the Document and How It Was Created
We identify the type of document, when it was created, who physically prepared it, whose name appears on it, why it was created, and where it was ultimately used.
We then reconstruct who created or modified each part of the document and through what process.
STEP 02 | Analyze Authority to Prepare the Document and Use Another Person’s Name
We examine whether the client had express or implied authority from the named person to prepare the document and whether prior business dealings, employment practices, agency relationships, or established working arrangements may be relevant to the scope of that authority.
STEP 03 | Analyze Originals, Revised Versions, and Electronic Records
We compare available originals and revised versions with source files, electronic records, printing records, transmission histories, emails, and other available materials to reconstruct how the document was actually created or altered.
STEP 04 | Distinguish Forgery, Alteration, False Assumption of Authority, and Use
We determine whether the conduct involved a simple revision to content, a legally relevant forgery or alteration, the false assumption of another person’s status or authority, falsification of an electronic record, or subsequent use of the resulting document.
Each potentially applicable offense is analyzed separately.
STEP 05 | Prepare for Police Questioning
We review the documents obtained by investigators and statements from relevant persons to identify likely questions and disputed issues.
We prepare the client’s statement with particular focus on authority to prepare the document, the purpose for which it was created, whether the named person consented, and how the document was subsequently used.
STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution, Trial, and Sentencing
Where the allegations are disputed, we organize evidence concerning authority, consent, intent, and the purpose of use.
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we examine the scope of use, the extent of resulting harm, efforts to recover or remedy that harm, and other case-specific circumstances relevant at the prosecution and sentencing stages.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Secure the Suspected Forged Document and Authentic Comparison Materials
We obtain the disputed document together with genuine contracts, signatures, seals, prior documents, or other reliable materials that may be used for comparison.
STEP 02 | Reconstruct How the Document Was Created and Used
We determine when the document appears to have been created, where it was submitted or used, who transmitted or presented it, and how it moved from creation to actual use.
STEP 03 | Secure Objective Evidence
We collect available original documents, electronic files, emails, transmission records, system data, statements from relevant persons, and other materials that may establish how the document was created, modified, or used.
STEP 04 | Identify the Applicable Offenses and Prepare the Criminal Complaint
We consider not only forgery or alteration of a private document, but also whether the facts may support additional allegations involving false assumption of authority, falsification of private electronic records, or use of a forged private document.
We then structure the criminal complaint around the specific conduct and supporting evidence.
STEP 05 | Pursue Recovery and Related Proceedings
Where the forged document has caused financial loss or affected a contractual, ownership, employment, corporate, family, or other legal relationship, we consider whether civil litigation or other proceedings may also be required to recover damages or correct the resulting legal consequences.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Trace How a Document Was Created, Altered, Transmitted, and Used
A private document forgery case cannot be fully understood by looking only at the finished document.
It is necessary to determine who created it, who had authority to do so, whether the named person consented, what was changed, how any signature or seal was applied, and where and how the document was ultimately used.
Private document cases may also involve multiple related offenses, including forgery or alteration, false assumption of another person’s authority, falsification or alteration of electronic records, and use of a forged document.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to examine not only the document itself but also the process by which it was created, transmitted, modified, and used, allowing the central investigative issues to be identified from the earliest stage.
01 | Trace the Document from Its Original Creation
We examine when the document was created, who prepared it, whose name appears as the author, how signatures or seals were added, and whether the document was later revised or modified.
02 | Distinguish “False Content” from “Forgery”
The fact that a document contains inaccurate or false information does not automatically mean that the document itself was forged.
We focus on the identity of the purported author and the authority to create or alter the document in determining whether the conduct constitutes forgery or alteration under Korean criminal law.
03 | Examine Authority and Consent
We determine whether there was an express delegation of authority, whether the named person gave consent or approval, and whether prior business or working practices may show that the client had authority to prepare documents on that person’s behalf.
04 | Separate Creating the Document from Using It
We do not stop at determining whether a document was forged.
We also examine whether and how the document was subsequently submitted to another person, company, financial institution, public authority, court, or other entity in order to determine whether a separate offense involving the use of the forged document may apply.
05 | Reconstruct the Facts Through Digital Evidence
Where electronic documents or files are involved, we examine available data showing the creation, modification, transmission, printing, and use of the document in order to reconstruct the sequence of events.
06 | Anticipate the Applicable Charges Before the First Police Interview
Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators are likely to establish authorship, authority, consent, purpose of use, alteration history, and actual use of the document and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.
Where the disputed document also affects civil litigation, contractual rights, corporate disputes, family proceedings, disciplinary matters, or other legal processes, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A PRIVATE DOCUMENT FORGERY CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER THE DOCUMENT CONTAINS FALSE INFORMATION, BUT WHO PURPORTED TO CREATE IT, WHO HAD AUTHORITY TO DO SO, WHAT WAS ALTERED, AND HOW THE DOCUMENT WAS INTENDED TO BE USED.
Tracing the document from its creation and authorization through modification, transmission, and actual use can be critical to distinguishing a false statement from criminal forgery and determining the true scope of criminal responsibility.
CYBERCRIME
WHAT IS CYBERCRIME?
Cybercrime refers to a broad range of criminal conduct committed through or involving the internet, computers, smartphones, telecommunications networks, and other information and communications technologies.
Common examples include hacking and unauthorized access to information systems, online fraud, account and identity misuse, malware-related offenses, online defamation and insult, unlawful distribution of information, and telecommunications-based financial fraud.
Cybercrime is not a single standalone offense under Korean law. Depending on the specific conduct, the Criminal Act and various special statutes may apply.
For that reason, the first step in a cybercrime case is to identify what conduct actually occurred and which statutes and criminal offenses may apply to each part of that conduct.
Because cybercrime occurs in a digital environment, investigations frequently rely on electronic evidence such as IP access logs, account information, login histories, messenger communications, financial transaction records, and data stored on smartphones, computers, and other digital devices.
The fact that an account, mobile phone, or bank account is registered in a particular person’s name does not necessarily establish that the person committed the alleged act.
It is necessary to examine, together with the objective digital evidence, who actually used the account or device, whether the person personally carried out or participated in the conduct, whether there was an agreement or common plan with others, and whether the person knew that the conduct was criminal.
PENALTIES FOR CYBERCRIME
There is no single statutory penalty applicable to all cybercrime because cybercrime encompasses many different offenses.
The applicable statutory penalty may vary significantly depending on the specific conduct and governing law, including offenses involving hacking or unauthorized access, online fraud, defamation or insult, personal information, malware, and telecommunications-based financial fraud.
A single course of conduct may also give rise to several criminal charges.
For example, where a person unlawfully accesses another person’s account or information and then uses that access to obtain money or facilitate another offense, the conduct may require separate analysis under laws governing unauthorized access and applicable property crimes.
The actual sentence or prosecutorial disposition may also vary depending on the method and duration of the offense, the amount of loss, whether the conduct was repeated, the person’s role, the financial benefit obtained, recovery of the victim’s losses, settlement, prior criminal history, and other circumstances of the individual case.
Accordingly, in a cybercrime case, it is critical to identify the precise type of offense and analyze the legal elements and evidentiary basis of each potential charge separately.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR CYBERCRIME CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Analyze the Potential Charges and Underlying Facts
We review the online activity at issue, the relevant accounts, how access occurred, any financial transactions, the relationship between the parties, and other surrounding circumstances to identify the specific criminal allegations that may apply.
STEP 02 | Review Digital Evidence and Objective Records
We examine messenger communications, emails, account information, access logs, financial transaction records, smartphones, computers, and other digital materials to determine what the client actually did and the extent of any involvement.
STEP 03 | Analyze Intent, Agreement, and Degree of Participation
We examine whether the client personally carried out the conduct, acted under another person’s direction, knew that the conduct was unlawful, or agreed or participated with other suspects in carrying out the offense.
STEP 04 | Respond to Search and Seizure, Digital Forensics, and Police Questioning
Where smartphones, computers, or other devices are searched or seized and subjected to digital forensic examination, we analyze the scope and focus of the investigation.
We then prepare for police questioning based on the digital evidence obtained by investigators and the issues likely to be examined.
STEP 05 | Respond Through Prosecution and Criminal Trial
We analyze the legal elements of each charge together with the digital evidence supporting it and develop the appropriate legal arguments.
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we also prepare materials concerning recovery of the victim’s losses, settlement, recurrence prevention, and other circumstances relevant at the prosecution or sentencing stage.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Document the Harm and Secure Digital Evidence
We preserve, where available, online posts, messages, emails, account information, login or access alerts, financial transaction records, URLs, screenshots, and other materials showing the alleged offense and resulting harm.
STEP 02 | Identify the Type of Offense and Reconstruct How the Harm Occurred
We distinguish among hacking, online fraud, account misuse, online defamation, and other forms of cybercrime and organize chronologically when and how the harm occurred.
STEP 03 | Organize Information Relevant to Identifying the Offender
We collect account identifiers, telephone numbers, email addresses, bank account information, usernames, chat records, and other materials that may assist investigators in identifying the person responsible.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We identify the legal requirements of the relevant offense and prepare a criminal complaint connecting the specific conduct with the available evidence.
We also prepare the victim to explain the chronology and nature of the harm clearly during the police investigation.
STEP 05 | Prevent Further Harm and Pursue Recovery
Where unauthorized account access, online publication, or other continuing conduct creates a risk of further harm, we consider appropriate measures to limit additional damage.
Where financial loss has occurred, we also review available victim-relief procedures and potential civil claims for recovery.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Understand How Digital Evidence Is Connected in an Investigation
A cybercrime case is rarely determined by a single online record.
The actual user of an account, access logs, data stored on smartphones and computers, messenger communications, and financial transaction histories must be examined together to determine what conduct actually occurred and who was responsible.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze how investigators are likely to obtain, compare, and connect digital evidence when assessing criminal allegations and to develop a strategy tailored to the specific case.
01 | Analyze Digital Evidence from an Investigative Perspective
Drawing on practical law-enforcement experience, we review account information, communications data, messenger conversations, access logs, financial records, and other evidence that investigators are likely to examine and identify the central issues in the case.
02 | Distinguish Online Identifiers from the Actual User
The fact that a particular account, mobile phone, or bank account was used does not necessarily establish who actually committed the offense.
We examine the distinction between the registered holder and actual user, together with login, access, device, and usage records.
03 | Respond to Digital Forensics and Search and Seizure
Where investigators search or seize smartphones, computers, or other digital devices, we examine the scope of the seizure, the investigative issues involved, and the relationship between the extracted data and each alleged offense.
04 | Prepare the Statement Strategy Before the First Police Interview
Cybercrime investigations may begin after investigators have already obtained substantial digital evidence.
We therefore organize the chronology and anticipated questions in advance so that the client’s statements do not unnecessarily conflict with objective electronic records.
05 | Distinguish Individual Conduct from Accomplice Liability
Where several people are involved, we separate the overall scheme from the conduct of each individual.
We analyze who gave instructions, who performed which role, when each person became involved, whether there was knowledge of the criminal purpose, and whether an agreement or common plan can actually be established.
06 | Analyze Multiple Charges Separately and Respond at Each Stage
A single cybercrime case may involve several criminal allegations at the same time.
We analyze the legal requirements and evidence for each charge separately and maintain a consistent strategy through police investigation, prosecution, and criminal trial.
Where the same online conduct also gives rise to civil claims, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, family matters, school-related proceedings, or other disputes, we also consider how digital evidence and statements in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A CYBERCRIME CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHICH ACCOUNT OR DEVICE WAS USED, BUT WHO ACTUALLY CONTROLLED IT, WHAT CONDUCT OCCURRED, WHAT THE PERSON KNEW, AND HOW THE DIGITAL EVIDENCE CONNECTS EACH INDIVIDUAL TO THE ALLEGED OFFENSE.
Carefully reconstructing the digital trail from the earliest stage can be critical to identifying the correct charges, distinguishing individual responsibility from broader group activity, and determining the true scope of criminal liability.
MURDER
WHAT IS MURDER?
Murder is the intentional killing of another person and is governed by Article 250 of Korea’s Criminal Act.
One of the most important issues in a murder case is whether the accused had the intent to cause the victim’s death.
The prosecution does not necessarily have to establish that the accused formed an explicit intention to kill from the outset. Intent to kill may also be found where the accused recognized that his or her conduct could result in the victim’s death and nevertheless accepted that possibility.
Accordingly, investigators and courts do not determine intent solely from the fact that the victim died. They examine the circumstances and motive leading to the incident, the weapon or instrument used, the part of the body attacked, the force and repetition of the attack, and the accused’s conduct before and after the incident to determine whether an intent to kill can be established.
Conversely, even where the victim dies, if an intent to kill cannot be established, the conduct may fall under a different offense, such as causing death through bodily injury, rather than murder.
For that reason, accurately reconstructing the circumstances at the time of the incident through objective evidence is particularly important in homicide investigations.
Korean criminal law separately addresses several forms of homicide-related conduct, including murder, murder of a lineal ascendant, killing at the victim’s request or with the victim’s consent, inducing or assisting suicide, obtaining a request or consent to death through deception or coercive influence, attempted murder, and preparation or conspiracy to commit certain forms of murder.
MAJOR TYPES OF MURDER AND PENALTIES
MURDER
A person who intentionally kills another person may be convicted of murder under Article 250(1) of the Criminal Act.
The statutory penalty is:
death, life imprisonment, or imprisonment for at least 5 years.
The sentence imposed in an individual case may depend on a wide range of factors, including the motive, degree of planning, method of the offense, relationship between the accused and victim, number of victims, and conduct before and after the offense.
MURDER OF A LINEAL ASCENDANT
A more severe statutory penalty applies where a person kills his or her own lineal ascendant or a lineal ascendant of his or her spouse.
Under Article 250(2) of the Criminal Act, the statutory penalty is:
death, life imprisonment, or imprisonment for at least 7 years.
KILLING AT THE VICTIM’S REQUEST OR WITH THE VICTIM’S CONSENT
Criminal liability also arises where a person kills another at that person’s request or with that person’s consent.
Under Article 252(1) of the Criminal Act, the statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for 1 to 10 years.
The fact that the victim wished to die does not, by itself, make the act of killing lawful.
INDUCING OR ASSISTING SUICIDE
Article 252(2) of the Criminal Act may apply where a person causes another to decide to commit suicide or assists a person who has already decided to do so.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for 1 to 10 years.
The precise nature of the accused’s conduct, the victim’s decision-making process, and the causal relationship between the assistance or inducement and the resulting death may become important issues.
OBTAINING A REQUEST, CONSENT, OR DECISION TO DIE THROUGH DECEPTION OR COERCIVE INFLUENCE
Where deception or coercive influence is used to obtain another person’s request or consent to being killed, or to cause another person to decide to commit suicide, Article 253 of the Criminal Act may apply.
Such conduct is punished in accordance with Article 250, rather than under the lower statutory range applicable to ordinary killing upon request or consent.
The circumstances in which the victim’s request, consent, or decision was obtained must therefore be examined carefully.
ATTEMPTED MURDER
Where a person begins carrying out an act with the intent to kill but the victim does not die, criminal liability for attempted murder may arise.
Article 254 of the Criminal Act provides that attempts to commit offenses under Articles 250, 252, and 253 are punishable.
In an attempted murder case, the central issue is again whether an intent to kill can be established.
The fact that the victim survived does not automatically reduce the offense to assault or bodily injury. The method of attack, the part of the body targeted, the weapon or instrument used, the force and repetition of the attack, and the circumstances before and after the incident may all be relevant in determining intent.
PREPARATION OR CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT MURDER
Criminal liability may arise even before an attempted killing begins where sufficiently concrete preparation or conspiracy is undertaken for the purpose of committing an offense under Article 250 or 253.
Under Article 255 of the Criminal Act, preparation or conspiracy to commit such an offense is punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 10 years.
The existence of a general hostile thought or abstract discussion is not necessarily sufficient. The specific acts of preparation, communications between the persons involved, acquisition of weapons or other means, and surrounding circumstances may become important in determining whether punishable preparation or conspiracy has occurred.
SENTENCING IN MURDER CASES
The Korean Sentencing Commission does not classify murder cases solely by the formal name of the offense.
Under the sentencing guidelines currently in effect, murder offenses are categorized primarily according to the motive and circumstances of the killing, including murder with mitigating motives, murder with ordinary motives, murder with particularly reprehensible motives, murder committed in connection with another serious offense, and murder demonstrating an extreme disregard for human life.
Whether the crime was planned, whether particularly cruel methods were used, whether the motive is especially blameworthy, the number of victims, and other aggravating or mitigating circumstances may significantly affect sentencing.
The current sentencing guidelines for murder offenses were revised on March 30, 2026 and took effect on July 1, 2026.
The statutory penalty for an offense and the sentencing guideline applicable to an individual case are separate matters and should be analyzed independently.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR MURDER CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Incident and Identify the Alleged Offense
We examine the relationship between the accused and the victim, the events leading to the incident, what occurred immediately beforehand, and the accused’s conduct afterward.
We also identify whether investigators are pursuing allegations of murder, murder of a lineal ascendant, attempted murder, or another homicide-related offense.
STEP 02 | Analyze the Scene and Objective Evidence
We examine evidence appropriate to the case, including CCTV footage, photographs of the scene, witness statements, emergency-call records, autopsy and forensic materials, expert findings, and other objective evidence to assess the sequence of events reconstructed by investigators.
STEP 03 | Focus on Whether Intent to Kill Can Be Established
We analyze the weapon or instrument used, the location of the injuries, the number and force of the attacks, and the accused’s conduct before and after the incident to determine whether direct or conditional intent to kill may be established.
Where intent to kill is disputed, we also examine whether the evidence may instead support a different offense, such as causing death through bodily injury.
STEP 04 | Respond to Detention Proceedings and Police Questioning
Because murder investigations frequently involve custodial investigation and detention proceedings, we identify any conflict between the objective evidence and the accused’s account before the first substantive police interview and organize the key facts that must be addressed during questioning.
STEP 05 | Respond to Referral and Prosecution
We reexamine the evidence and statements obtained during the police investigation.
Where there is a dispute concerning intent to kill, the circumstances of the incident, causation, or the appropriate charge, we organize the relevant evidence and legal arguments for submission at the prosecution stage.
STEP 06 | Respond to Criminal Trial and Sentencing
After indictment, we closely examine the charges and evidentiary record and challenge disputed issues where appropriate.
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we prepare the circumstances surrounding the offense, legally relevant mitigating factors, efforts toward victim compensation or recovery, and other materials that may properly be considered in sentencing.
FOR VICTIMS AND BEREAVED FAMILIES
STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Events and the Victim’s Relationship with the Accused
We review the victim’s activities immediately before the incident, the relationship with the accused, any prior conflicts, and the circumstances before and after the offense to understand the motive and overall sequence of events.
STEP 02 | Secure Objective Evidence
We identify and preserve relevant CCTV footage, scene evidence, witness statements, call records, communications, and other materials and distinguish between evidence already secured by investigators and evidence that may require further preservation or submission.
STEP 03 | Examine Intent, Planning, and Motive
We review whether there were preparatory acts before the offense, what weapon or instrument was used, how the attack was carried out, and whether there was subsequent flight, concealment, destruction of evidence, or other conduct relevant to intent and planning.
STEP 04 | Respond to the Police and Prosecution Investigation
We organize the matters on which statements from the victim’s family may be necessary and determine whether additional evidence, factual issues, or written opinions should be presented to investigators or prosecutors.
STEP 05 | Present the Victim’s and Family’s Position at Trial
Where the accused is indicted, we assist in organizing the harm caused by the offense and the position of the victim or bereaved family and consider available procedures for victim statements and written submissions during the criminal trial.
STEP 06 | Review Civil Compensation and Related Proceedings
In addition to the criminal case, issues such as funeral expenses, emotional distress damages, and other losses may arise.
We consider available civil remedies and other follow-up proceedings based on the outcome of the criminal case and the legally established scope of the offender’s responsibility.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Analyze a Murder Case from the Scene and the First Statement Forward
In a murder case, the sequence of events leading to the death can be as important as the fact that a death occurred.
Whether there was an intent to kill, whether the incident arose suddenly rather than through advance planning, and how the alleged conduct actually caused the victim’s death may substantially affect both the applicable charge and the outcome of the case.
In cases requiring a distinction between murder and causing death through bodily injury, or between attempted murder and bodily injury, the analysis cannot rest solely on the accused’s explanation. The scene, method of attack, forensic evidence, witness statements, and other objective evidence must be examined together.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze how the scene immediately after the incident, the initial emergency report, the first police response, early statements from suspects and witnesses, and objective evidence fit together as the investigation develops.
01 | Review the Initial Emergency Report and First Police Response
We examine the contents of the initial emergency call, what officers observed upon arrival, and the earliest statements of the parties and witnesses to analyze the case from the evidence created immediately after the incident.
02 | Reconstruct the Scene Chronologically
Using available CCTV footage, scene photographs, access and movement records, communications, and other objective materials, we reconstruct the sequence from before the incident through the alleged offense and the conduct that followed.
03 | Analyze the Method of Attack Separately from Intent to Kill
We examine the weapon or instrument used, the body parts attacked, the number and force of the attacks, and the accused’s conduct before and after the incident to determine whether the evidence supports an intent to kill.
04 | Cross-Check Forensic Evidence Against Statements
We compare autopsy findings, the medical cause of death, the location and characteristics of injuries, and other forensic evidence with statements from the accused and witnesses and with the physical circumstances of the scene.
05 | Examine Whether the Evidence Supports Murder, Attempted Murder, Causing Death Through Bodily Injury, or Another Offense
We do not determine the appropriate charge solely from the fact that death or injury occurred.
We analyze intent, the manner of the conduct, causation, and the objective evidence to determine whether the offense alleged by investigators accurately reflects what occurred.
06 | Respond from Detention Proceedings Through Prosecution and Trial
Drawing on practical experience with serious violent-crime investigations, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators evaluate scene evidence, initial statements, weapons or instruments, forensic findings, and conduct before and after the incident and develop a coordinated strategy from the initial police investigation through detention proceedings, prosecution, and criminal trial.
Where the same incident also gives rise to civil claims, family proceedings, disciplinary matters, or other related proceedings, we consider how statements, forensic findings, and other evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A MURDER CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT ONLY THAT A DEATH OCCURRED, BUT WHAT HAPPENED BEFORE, DURING, AND AFTER THE FATAL ACT—AND WHETHER THE OBJECTIVE EVIDENCE ESTABLISHES AN INTENT TO KILL.
Reconstructing the scene, the method of attack, the forensic findings, the earliest statements, and the accused’s conduct as one continuous timeline can be critical to determining the proper charge, the scope of criminal responsibility, and the issues that will ultimately shape the case.
OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS
WHAT IS OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS?
Obstruction of business is an offense under Article 314 of Korea’s Criminal Act that may be established where a person interferes with another person’s business by spreading false information or by using deception, force, or other prohibited means.
The term “business” is not limited to commercial operations conducted by a company or business owner. It may include work or activities that a person continuously performs based on his or her social or professional position, and in a specific case it is first necessary to determine whether the activity at issue qualifies as legally protected “business” under the Criminal Act.
The offense does not necessarily require that the business be completely shut down or that actual financial loss occur. Depending on the circumstances, criminal liability may arise where the conduct creates a concrete risk of interfering with the business.
Cases may involve disruptive conduct at stores or workplaces, interference with ordinary decision-making through false information, the use of force or influence sufficient to overwhelm another person’s freedom of decision, or interference with business operations by damaging, altering, or manipulating computers, electronic records, or other information-processing systems.
Accordingly, an obstruction of business case should not be evaluated solely on the assertion that “the business suffered harm.” It is necessary to examine what business was being conducted, how the alleged interference occurred, and what actual disruption or risk of disruption arose from the conduct.
MAJOR TYPES OF OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS AND PENALTIES
OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS BY SPREADING FALSE INFORMATION
This issue may arise where objectively false information is disseminated to unspecified persons or a broader audience and interferes with another person’s business.
The analysis does not end with whether a statement was inaccurate. It is also necessary to examine whether the information was actually false, whether the person knew of its falsity, and how the dissemination was connected to the alleged interference with the business.
Under Articles 314(1) and 313 of the Criminal Act, obstruction of business by spreading false information may be punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.
OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS BY DECEPTION
Obstruction by deception may arise where a person causes another to make a mistake or form a false understanding and then exploits that misunderstanding in a manner that interferes with the normal performance of business.
This may occur, for example, where false documents, misleading information, or deceptive methods are used to improperly influence an ordinary screening, selection, review, or decision-making process.
Whether particular conduct legally constitutes “deception” under the Criminal Act must be determined based on the specific circumstances of the case.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.
OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS BY FORCE
Obstruction by force may be established where a person uses physical, psychological, social, or other influence of a degree capable of suppressing or confusing another person’s freedom of decision and thereby interferes with business.
This may include prolonged disruptive conduct at a place of business or physical behavior that makes ordinary operations difficult.
However, raising one’s voice or making a protest does not automatically constitute criminal obstruction of business.
It is necessary to examine the method and degree of the conduct, how long it continued, where it occurred, the surrounding circumstances, and the actual effect or risk posed to the business.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.
OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS THROUGH INTERFERENCE WITH COMPUTER OR INFORMATION-PROCESSING SYSTEMS
Article 314(2) of the Criminal Act may apply where a person interferes with another person’s business by damaging a computer or other information-processing device, damaging or altering electronic or other special-media records, entering false information or unauthorized commands, or otherwise causing disruption to information processing.
In this type of case, key issues may include what data or commands were entered, what actual system malfunction or disruption occurred, and whether there is a sufficient connection between that disruption and the alleged interference with business.
The statutory penalty is the same as for general obstruction of business:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Identify the Business at Issue and Reconstruct the Incident
We first determine what business is alleged to have been obstructed and then organize the time and location of the incident, the relationship between the parties, the conduct at issue, and the surrounding events in chronological order.
STEP 02 | Determine the Alleged Method of Obstruction and Review the Legal Requirements
We distinguish whether the allegation involves spreading false information, deception, force, or interference with computers or information-processing systems and analyze the legal requirements applicable to each theory.
STEP 03 | Analyze CCTV, Scene Evidence, and Business Records
We review objective materials appropriate to the case, including CCTV footage, video and audio recordings from the scene, emergency-call records, police response records, business records, and other evidence to determine what actually occurred and how the conduct affected business operations.
STEP 04 | Examine Intent and Whether a Risk of Business Interference Actually Arose
We assess whether the incident arose in the course of a legitimate protest or exercise of rights, whether there was an intent to interfere with another person’s business, and whether the conduct created a legally sufficient risk of obstruction.
STEP 05 | Prepare for Police Questioning
Based on statements from the complainant and witnesses and the available objective evidence, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and prepare for questioning with particular focus on the purpose, method, and circumstances of the conduct.
STEP 06 | Address Victim Recovery, Prosecution, and Trial
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we examine the actual scope of harm and consider recovery and settlement where appropriate.
Where the allegation is disputed, we respond through prosecution and trial based on the legal requirements of obstruction of business and the objective evidentiary record.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Document the Business and the Circumstances of the Interference
We identify what business was being conducted, how it was allegedly interfered with, how long the conduct continued, and what disruption or risk arose to normal operations.
STEP 02 | Secure Evidence of the Obstruction
We preserve objective materials such as CCTV footage, scene video or audio recordings, emergency-call records, witness statements, sales or work records, and other evidence showing the conduct and its impact on the business.
STEP 03 | Analyze the Method of Obstruction and Resulting Harm
We determine whether the alleged conduct involved false information, deception, force, or interference with information-processing systems and organize the operational disruption and any resulting loss.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We connect the alleged conduct to the objective evidence and prepare the criminal complaint so that the manner and course of obstruction are clearly presented.
We also prepare for the police interview so that the business impact and relevant chronology can be explained accurately.
STEP 05 | Pursue Recovery and Related Proceedings
Where actual financial loss has resulted from the obstruction, we organize the supporting evidence and consider whether civil claims for damages or other follow-up proceedings should be pursued separately from the criminal case.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Focus on What Actually Happened, Not Simply the Claim That Business Was “Disrupted”
An obstruction of business case is not automatically established merely because a complainant claims that his or her business was affected.
It is necessary to determine what legally protected business existed, whether the conduct amounted to spreading false information, deception, force, or another prohibited method, and whether the conduct created an actual risk of interfering with that business.
This is particularly important in incidents occurring at a workplace, store, restaurant, hospital, office, or other physical location, where the parties may sharply disagree over whether the conduct was a legitimate complaint or protest, or whether it crossed the line into criminal force.
From the victim’s perspective as well, it is generally more important to demonstrate through objective evidence what actually happened and how operations were affected than simply to assert that the business suffered disruption.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the initial emergency report, the police response, CCTV footage, scene materials, business records, and statements from the parties and witnesses together, with a focus on the issues investigators are likely to examine in an obstruction of business case.
01 | Review the Initial Report and Scene from the Beginning
Where an emergency call was made, we examine the initial report, the circumstances observed when police arrived, the location and conduct of the parties, and other evidence created immediately after the incident.
02 | Reconstruct the Conduct from Beginning to End Through CCTV and Other Evidence
We determine when the conduct began, how long it continued, how the other party responded, and what actually occurred at the business location by reviewing CCTV footage, recordings, and other available evidence chronologically.
03 | Distinguish False Information, Deception, Force, and Ordinary Disputes
We analyze whether the conduct was merely a protest or disagreement, involved dissemination of false information, used deception capable of misleading another person, or involved force sufficient to interfere with free decision-making.
04 | Objectively Analyze the Risk and Actual Impact on Business Operations
We compare business conditions before, during, and after the incident with available sales, operational, work, and other records to assess what disruption or risk actually occurred.
05 | Examine System Records in Computer-Related Obstruction Cases
Where the allegation involves an information-processing device or system, we analyze available data concerning the disputed commands, system activity, timing of any malfunction, and resulting operational disruption to determine the relationship between the alleged conduct and the claimed interference.
06 | Develop a Case-Specific Strategy from the First Police Interview
Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators are likely to examine the existence of protected business, the alleged method of interference, CCTV and witness evidence, and the actual impact on operations, and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.
Where the same incident also gives rise to civil claims, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, family matters, school-related proceedings, or other disputes, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN AN OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER SOMEONE CLAIMS THAT BUSINESS WAS DISRUPTED, BUT WHETHER LEGALLY PROTECTED BUSINESS EXISTED, WHAT METHOD OF INTERFERENCE WAS USED, AND WHETHER THAT CONDUCT CREATED A LEGALLY RELEVANT RISK OR ACTUAL OBSTRUCTION.
Reconstructing the entire incident through objective evidence—including CCTV footage, recordings, business records, system data, and witness statements—can be critical to distinguishing a legitimate dispute or protest from criminal obstruction of business.
TRESPASS
WHAT IS TRESPASS?
Trespass may be established where a person enters another person’s residence, managed building, or other legally protected space without lawful authority and thereby disturbs the actual peace and security of the premises.
Article 319(1) of Korea’s Criminal Act provides criminal punishment for entering another person’s residence, a managed building, vessel or aircraft, or an occupied room without authorization.
The central issue in a trespass case is not simply whether someone physically entered another person’s property.
It is necessary to examine whether the location is one protected under criminal law, whether the person had authority or the occupant’s consent to enter, the purpose and manner of entry, and whether the conduct can be regarded as having infringed the factual peace and security of the residence or premises.
Accordingly, cases involving the home of a former partner or family member who had previously allowed free access, common areas of an apartment building, offices, stores, and other business premises may also raise issues of residential trespass or trespass into a managed building depending on the nature of the space and the circumstances of entry.
In addition, criminal liability may arise even where the initial entry was lawful. If a person is asked to leave and refuses to do so, the separate offense of refusal to leave may apply.
Where the conduct involves carrying a dangerous object or demonstrating the collective force of a group or crowd, the more serious offense of aggravated trespass may also be at issue.
MAJOR TYPES OF TRESPASS AND PENALTIES
GENERAL TRESPASS
This is the basic form of the offense and may apply where a person enters another person’s residence, a managed building, vessel or aircraft, or an occupied room without lawful authority.
In an actual case, the analysis goes beyond the mere fact of entry and may include whether there was authority or consent to enter, the purpose and manner of entry, the time of entry, the nature of the location, and the surrounding circumstances.
Under Article 319(1) of the Criminal Act, the statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 5 million.
REFUSAL TO LEAVE
Even where a person initially entered a location lawfully, criminal liability may arise if that person refuses to leave after receiving a legitimate demand to do so.
Accordingly, a person who initially entered a restaurant, office, residence, or other location with permission may still face criminal liability if he or she remains there after being properly required to leave.
Under Article 319(2) of the Criminal Act, refusal to leave is punishable by the same statutory penalty as general trespass:
imprisonment for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 5 million.
AGGRAVATED TRESPASS
Where a person commits trespass or refusal to leave while demonstrating the collective force of a group or crowd, or while carrying a dangerous object, aggravated trespass may be at issue.
In these cases, it is necessary to examine the nature of the object, why and how it was carried, the circumstances at the scene, and, where multiple persons were involved, whether their conduct actually demonstrated the collective force required by law.
Under Article 320 of the Criminal Act, the statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 5 years.
Unlike ordinary trespass, no fine is provided as a statutory penalty for this offense.
SEARCH OF A RESIDENCE OR PERSON
Article 321 of the Criminal Act may apply where a person, without lawful authority, searches another person’s body, residence, managed building, automobile, vessel or aircraft, or occupied room.
This provision separately criminalizes the act of searching a person or legally protected space, beyond simply entering that location.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 3 years.
ATTEMPTED TRESPASS
Criminal liability for trespass does not always require a completed entry.
Article 322 of the Criminal Act provides that attempts to commit offenses under the chapter governing trespass are also punishable.
Accordingly, even where entry was not successfully completed, criminal responsibility may still arise depending on whether sufficiently concrete acts toward commission of the offense had begun.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR TRESPASS CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Identify the Location and Reconstruct the Circumstances of Entry
We determine whether the location was a residence, managed building, occupied room, or another legally protected space and organize the time, purpose, route of entry, and relationship between the parties in chronological order.
STEP 02 | Examine Authority and Consent to Enter
We review whether the occupant or manager gave express permission, whether there was an existing relationship in which the client had previously been allowed to enter freely, whether the space was jointly used, and whether any legal or factual authority to enter may have existed.
STEP 03 | Analyze CCTV, Access Records, and Other Objective Evidence
We review building and surrounding CCTV footage, common-entry or door access records, photographs of the scene, witness statements, and other evidence to reconstruct the actual method of entry, period of presence, and circumstances of departure or removal.
STEP 04 | Distinguish Trespass, Refusal to Leave, and Aggravated Trespass
We determine whether the allegation involves unauthorized entry from the outset, lawful entry followed by refusal to leave, or circumstances involving a dangerous object or the collective force of multiple persons.
We then analyze the specific offense that may apply.
STEP 05 | Prepare for Police Questioning
Based on the complainant’s statements, CCTV footage, access records, and other evidence likely to be obtained by investigators, we prepare for questioning with particular focus on the purpose and authority for entry, conduct at the scene, and whether and when a request to leave was made.
STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution, Trial, and Sentencing
Where the allegation is disputed, we prepare and submit evidence concerning authority, consent, the nature of the premises, and the surrounding circumstances.
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we organize the circumstances of entry, the extent of harm, recovery efforts, settlement, and other factors relevant at the prosecution or sentencing stage.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Document the Entry and Resulting Harm
We organize when and where the entry occurred, how the person entered, how long the person remained, what conduct occurred inside or around the premises, and whether a demand to leave was made.
STEP 02 | Secure CCTV, Access Records, and Other Evidence
We preserve entrance and building CCTV footage, access-control records, photographs of the scene, the condition of doors or locks, emergency-call records, witness statements, and other objective materials showing the circumstances of entry.
STEP 03 | Identify the Type of Intrusion and Any Additional Risk
We determine whether the case involves ordinary trespass, refusal to leave, carrying a dangerous object, collective force by multiple persons, or other conduct that may give rise to additional charges.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We connect the absence of consent, the method of entry, the circumstances at the scene, and the available objective evidence in preparing the criminal complaint.
We also prepare for the police interview so that the nature of the intrusion and resulting harm are accurately presented.
STEP 05 | Prevent Further Harm and Pursue Recovery
Where there is a risk of repeated entry, retaliation, or other continuing harm, we review protective measures that may be available under the specific circumstances.
Where financial or emotional harm has resulted, we also consider civil claims for damages or other appropriate follow-up proceedings.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Look Beyond the Moment Someone Crossed the Threshold
In a trespass case, why, how, and under what authority a person entered can be just as important as whether the person physically entered.
Some cases involve relatively clear facts, such as forcibly opening a door and entering without permission.
Others require much closer analysis, particularly where the parties are former partners or family members who previously had free access to the premises, or where the incident occurred in an office, store, shared building entrance, hallway, or other common area.
The legal character of the case may also change depending on what happened after entry.
A person who entered lawfully may face liability for refusal to leave if he or she remained after a legitimate demand to leave, while the use of a dangerous object or the collective force of a group may raise issues of aggravated trespass.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the initial report, the scene, the route of entry, CCTV footage, access records, the relationship between the parties, and their statements together from the earliest stage of the case.
01 | Review the Initial Emergency Report and Scene
Where an emergency call was made, we examine the contents of the initial report, the suspect’s location when police arrived, the condition of doors or entry points, statements made at the scene, and other circumstances immediately following the incident.
02 | Reconstruct the Route of Entry Through CCTV and Access Records
We examine the person’s movements from entry into the building through common entrances, hallways, individual doors, and other relevant areas and reconstruct the method of entry, duration of presence, and departure in chronological order.
03 | Examine Authority and Consent in Detail
We determine whether there was a prior pattern of permitted access, whether permission was given on the date in question, whether the area was jointly used, and whether the person had a legitimate right to enter and, if so, how far that authority extended.
04 | Distinguish Unauthorized Entry from Refusal to Leave
A case involving unauthorized entry from the outset raises different issues from one involving lawful entry followed by refusal to comply with a demand to leave.
We analyze the entry itself and the conduct after any demand to leave as separate stages.
05 | Anticipate Aggravated Trespass and Related Charges
We examine whether a dangerous object was carried, whether a group or crowd demonstrated collective force, whether any search of the premises or person occurred, and whether other conduct may support additional charges beyond ordinary trespass.
06 | Develop a Strategy Around the Central Issues Before the First Police Interview
Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators are likely to examine authority to enter, the method and purpose of entry, CCTV footage, initial emergency reports, access records, and statements from the parties, and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.
Where the same incident also gives rise to civil claims, family proceedings, workplace or disciplinary matters, school-related proceedings, or other disputes, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A TRESPASS CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER SOMEONE ENTERED THE PREMISES, BUT WHETHER THAT PERSON HAD AUTHORITY OR CONSENT TO ENTER, HOW THE ENTRY OCCURRED, AND WHETHER THE CONDUCT INFRINGED THE PEACE AND SECURITY OF THE PROTECTED SPACE.
Reconstructing the route of entry, the scope of any permission, the parties’ relationship, the response to any demand to leave, and the objective evidence from the scene can be critical to determining the proper offense and the true scope of criminal responsibility.
ASSAULT
WHAT IS ASSAULT?
Assault is an offense under Article 260 of Korea’s Criminal Act that may be established where a person uses physical force against another person’s body.
The offense does not require that the victim suffer an actual injury. If physical force is used against another person, criminal liability for assault may arise even where no bodily injury results.
In an actual case, it is often difficult to determine what happened based solely on competing claims that one person “hit” the other or “was hit.”
The entire sequence of events must be examined, including who first used physical force, what form of physical contact occurred, whether the incident involved a one-sided assault or a mutual physical confrontation, and whether any force was used to defend against an ongoing attack.
This is particularly important in incidents occurring at bars, on the street, in stores, workplaces, and other crowded settings, where the parties’ accounts frequently conflict.
Objective evidence such as CCTV footage, recordings from the scene, witness statements, emergency-call records, and the circumstances observed by police upon arrival can therefore be critical in reconstructing what actually occurred.
Depending on the relationship between the parties, the manner of the conduct, and the resulting harm, an assault case may involve ordinary assault, assault against a lineal ascendant, aggravated assault involving a dangerous object or collective force, assault resulting in bodily injury or death, or habitual assault.
MAJOR TYPES OF ASSAULT AND PENALTIES
ORDINARY ASSAULT
Ordinary assault is the basic form of the offense and may be established where physical force is used against another person’s body.
An actual injury is not required.
Under Article 260(1) of the Criminal Act, ordinary assault is punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 2 years, a fine of up to KRW 5 million, detention, or a minor fine.
Ordinary assault cannot be prosecuted contrary to the victim’s expressly stated wishes. Accordingly, the victim’s position concerning punishment may significantly affect the course of the case.
ASSAULT AGAINST A LINEAL ASCENDANT
A more severe statutory penalty applies where a person assaults his or her own lineal ascendant or a lineal ascendant of his or her spouse.
Under Article 260(2) of the Criminal Act, the offense is punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 7 million.
This offense is also one that cannot be prosecuted contrary to the victim’s expressly stated wishes.
AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
Article 261 of the Criminal Act may apply where assault is committed by demonstrating the collective force of a group or crowd or while carrying a dangerous object.
Whether an object qualifies as “dangerous” is not determined solely by its ordinary name or category.
The nature of the object, how it was carried or used, the surrounding circumstances, and the manner in which the assault occurred must be examined together.
Aggravated assault is punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
Unlike ordinary assault, aggravated assault is not subject to the same rule preventing prosecution against the victim’s wishes. A settlement may therefore remain highly relevant, but it does not by itself terminate the criminal proceedings.
ASSAULT RESULTING IN BODILY INJURY
Where an assault results in bodily injury, the case may involve assault resulting in injury rather than ordinary assault.
It is necessary to determine not only whether an injury actually occurred, but also whether the required causal connection exists between the assault and the alleged injury.
Under Article 262 of the Criminal Act, the applicable punishment is determined by reference to the provisions governing bodily injury. In an ordinary case, this may result in:
imprisonment for up to 7 years, suspension of qualifications for up to 10 years, or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
Assault resulting in bodily injury is not subject to the same non-prosecution rule as ordinary assault. Criminal proceedings may therefore continue even where the victim later states that punishment is not desired.
ASSAULT RESULTING IN DEATH
Where an assault results in the victim’s death, criminal liability for assault resulting in death may arise.
This offense must be distinguished from murder, which requires an intent to kill.
Important issues may include the causal relationship between the assault and the victim’s death and whether the fatal result was objectively foreseeable in the circumstances.
Under Articles 262 and 259 of the Criminal Act, assault resulting in death may be punishable by:
imprisonment for at least 3 years.
HABITUAL ASSAULT
Where ordinary assault, assault against a lineal ascendant, aggravated assault, or certain related offenses are committed habitually, Article 264 of the Criminal Act may apply.
If habituality is established, the punishment prescribed for the relevant offense may be increased by up to one-half.
Habituality is not determined merely by counting the number of incidents.
The court may consider the repetition and duration of the conduct, the manner in which the offenses were committed, prior criminal history, and other circumstances showing a pattern of similar conduct.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR ASSAULT CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Reconstruct the Incident and Establish the Facts
We examine when and where the incident occurred, the relationship between the parties, how the dispute began, and what each person did from the first physical contact until the confrontation ended.
STEP 02 | Determine the Potential Assault Charge
We assess whether the case involves ordinary assault, assault against a lineal ascendant, aggravated assault, or assault resulting in bodily injury and identify the charge that most accurately corresponds to the conduct and resulting harm.
STEP 03 | Analyze CCTV Footage, Scene Evidence, and Medical Records
We review CCTV footage, recordings from the scene, emergency-call and police response records, witness statements, photographs of injuries, and medical records to reconstruct how the physical confrontation actually developed.
STEP 04 | Distinguish One-Sided Assault, Mutual Confrontation, and Self-Defense
We examine who first used physical force, how the other person responded, whether the attack was continuing, and whether the responsive conduct was necessary and proportionate in the circumstances.
Where self-defense is at issue, each person’s conduct must be analyzed separately rather than assuming that mutual use of force automatically establishes or excludes self-defense.
STEP 05 | Prepare for Police Questioning
Based on the initial report, CCTV footage, and statements from the victim and witnesses, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and prepare the client’s statement so that it is consistent with the objective evidence.
STEP 06 | Address Settlement, Prosecution, and Trial
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we consider victim recovery and settlement based on the applicable form of assault and the extent of harm.
Where the allegation is disputed, we respond through prosecution and criminal trial based on the objective evidence and the legal issues concerning force, causation, and self-defense.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Document the Assault and Resulting Harm
We organize when and where the assault occurred, how the force was used, how many times the conduct occurred, whether any object was involved, and what happened immediately before and after the incident.
STEP 02 | Secure Scene Evidence and Proof of Injury
We preserve CCTV footage, emergency-call records, photographs and recordings from the scene, witness statements, and, where injury occurred, photographs of the affected areas and relevant medical records.
STEP 03 | Determine the Type of Assault and Any Additional Charges
We examine whether the case involves ordinary assault, the use of a dangerous object or collective force, bodily injury, or other circumstances that may support a more serious charge.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We connect the specific manner of assault with the available objective evidence and prepare the criminal complaint so that the sequence of events and resulting harm are clearly presented.
We also prepare for the police interview so that the factual account remains specific and consistent.
STEP 05 | Review Settlement and Recovery
Where the accused proposes a settlement, we examine the applicable offense, extent of injury, course of treatment, and other circumstances in determining whether settlement is appropriate and on what terms.
Where necessary, we also consider civil claims for medical expenses, emotional distress, and other legally compensable loss.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Reconstruct the Case from the Moment the Physical Confrontation Began
An assault incident can change dramatically within a matter of seconds.
What begins as a verbal argument may quickly become a physical confrontation, and it is common for both sides to insist that the other person struck first.
The legal character of the case may also change significantly where a dangerous object is involved or bodily injury occurs.
Conduct initially investigated as ordinary assault may ultimately raise issues of aggravated assault or assault resulting in bodily injury.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to reconstruct the initial emergency report, the scene observed when police arrived, CCTV footage, witness statements, and the resulting injuries as one continuous sequence and to anticipate the charges investigators may consider.
01 | Review the Initial Emergency Report and Police Response
We examine the first report made to police, the position and condition of the parties when officers arrived, the appearance of the scene, and other information obtained immediately after the confrontation.
We then compare those early records with later statements.
02 | Reconstruct the Physical Confrontation Chronologically Through CCTV
We identify when the verbal dispute began, who initiated physical contact, how the other person responded, whether additional force was used, and when the confrontation ended.
03 | Distinguish Ordinary Assault from More Serious Charges
From the earliest stage, we examine whether the conduct should be treated as ordinary assault, aggravated assault involving a dangerous object or collective force, or assault resulting in bodily injury.
04 | Analyze Mutual Physical Confrontation and Self-Defense Separately
The fact that both parties used physical force does not automatically establish self-defense.
We separately analyze who initiated the attack, whether the threat remained ongoing, and whether the nature and degree of the response were justified in the circumstances.
05 | Compare Medical Evidence with the Actual Assault
Where the victim submits a medical certificate or treatment records, we do not evaluate those materials in isolation.
We compare the alleged injuries and course of treatment with CCTV footage, the manner of the assault, the affected body parts, and other objective evidence to assess the relationship between the conduct and the claimed injury.
06 | Develop a Stage-Specific Strategy from the First Police Interview Through Settlement, Prosecution, and Trial
We first determine whether the case requires a factual and legal defense or whether victim recovery and settlement should be prioritized.
Drawing on practical law-enforcement experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys develop a case-specific strategy based on how investigators evaluate initial reports, CCTV footage, witness accounts, medical evidence, and the sequence of physical force from the first police interview through prosecution and criminal trial.
Where the same incident also gives rise to civil claims, family proceedings, workplace or disciplinary matters, school-related proceedings, or other disputes, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN AN ASSAULT CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHO CLAIMS TO HAVE BEEN HIT, BUT WHO USED FORCE, WHEN IT WAS USED, WHY IT WAS USED, AND WHAT THE OBJECTIVE EVIDENCE SHOWS ABOUT THE ENTIRE CONFRONTATION.
Reconstructing the incident from the first physical contact through the final moments of the confrontation can be critical to distinguishing ordinary assault, aggravated assault, injury-related offenses, and lawful self-defense—and to determining the true scope of criminal responsibility.
ABUSE
WHAT IS ABUSE?
Abuse generally refers to physically or psychologically cruel treatment of a person who is under another’s protection or supervision, or conduct that interferes with the safety and normal life of a person who requires care or protection.
Article 273 of Korea’s Criminal Act criminalizes the abuse of a person who is under the offender’s protection or supervision and provides a more severe penalty where the victim is the offender’s own lineal ascendant or the lineal ascendant of the offender’s spouse.
Actual abuse cases, however, are not governed solely by the general abuse provisions of the Criminal Act.
Depending on the victim’s age, condition, relationship with the alleged offender, and the nature of the conduct, separate statutes concerning child abuse, elder abuse, or abuse of persons with disabilities may apply. Other criminal offenses, including assault, bodily injury, abandonment, or neglect, may also arise from the same conduct.
Abuse does not necessarily require direct physical violence. Depending on the applicable statute and the specific facts, repeated threats or degrading treatment, emotional abuse, or a failure to provide legally required care or protection may also constitute abuse.
Accordingly, an abuse case should not be evaluated by isolating a single act. It is necessary to examine the relationship between the parties, the existence and scope of any duty of protection or supervision, the nature and repetition of the conduct, the victim’s condition, and the actual consequences of the alleged abuse.
MAJOR TYPES OF ABUSE AND PENALTIES
GENERAL ABUSE
Article 273(1) of the Criminal Act may apply where a person abuses someone who is under his or her protection or supervision.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 2 years or a fine of up to KRW 5 million.
The key issue is not merely whether the conduct was unpleasant, unfair, or inappropriate.
It is necessary to determine whether a legally relevant relationship of protection or supervision existed and whether the conduct was sufficiently serious to constitute criminal abuse.
ABUSE OF A LINEAL ASCENDANT
Where the victim is the offender’s own lineal ascendant or the lineal ascendant of the offender’s spouse, Article 273(2) of the Criminal Act may apply.
The statutory penalty is:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 7 million.
ABUSE RESULTING IN BODILY INJURY OR DEATH
Where abuse results in bodily injury or death, substantially more serious criminal liability may arise.
Under Article 275 of the Criminal Act, where general abuse or certain related conduct results in bodily injury, the offender may be punished by:
imprisonment for up to 7 years.
Where the conduct results in death, the statutory penalty may be:
imprisonment for at least 3 years.
Separate enhanced punishment applies where bodily injury or death results from abuse of a lineal ascendant.
In these cases, it is necessary to examine not only the underlying abusive conduct but also the causal relationship between that conduct and the injury or death.
CHILD ABUSE
Child abuse is not limited to physical violence.
Depending on the facts, a case may involve physical abuse, emotional abuse, sexual abuse, abandonment, or neglect.
Under Korea’s Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Child Abuse Crimes, certain offenses committed against a child by a person responsible for the child’s care or protection are treated as “child abuse crimes” and are subject to specialized investigative, criminal, and protective procedures.
The applicable punishment therefore depends on what specific abusive conduct occurred and which underlying criminal offense is established.
Where child abuse causes a life-threatening condition or results in a serious disability or an incurable or difficult-to-treat illness, the special offense of serious bodily injury resulting from child abuse may apply, carrying a substantial term of imprisonment under the applicable statute.
Habitual commission of a child abuse crime may result in enhanced punishment. Enhanced punishment may also apply in certain cases where a person subject to a statutory duty to report child abuse commits an abuse offense against a child under that person’s protection.
Child abuse cases may also involve measures separate from criminal punishment, including separation of the alleged offender from the child, restrictions on approaching or contacting the child or household members, placement of the child in a protective facility, and restrictions affecting parental or guardianship authority. Current law provides for emergency measures and court-issued child protection orders for these purposes.
ELDER ABUSE
Elder abuse may involve more than physical assault.
Under Korea’s Welfare of Older Persons Act, prohibited conduct against persons aged 65 or older may include physical abuse, sexual abuse, abandonment or neglect by a person responsible for protection or supervision, misuse of money or property provided for the older person, and emotional abuse through verbal abuse, threats, or intimidation.
Where the alleged offender is a family member, caregiver, or employee of a care facility who had responsibility for protecting or supervising the victim, it may also be necessary to examine whether the conduct constitutes abuse under the Criminal Act, as well as assault, bodily injury, abandonment, neglect, or another offense.
There is no single statutory penalty applicable to every form of “elder abuse.” The governing provision and potential punishment depend on the specific conduct.
Accordingly, the victim’s health, ability to communicate and make decisions, relationship with caregivers, living and care arrangements, financial circumstances, and the frequency and duration of the alleged conduct should all be examined carefully.
ABUSE OF PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES OR OTHERS REQUIRING PROTECTION
Abuse may also arise where the victim is a person with a disability, illness, or other condition that makes independent self-protection difficult.
Where the alleged offender is a facility employee, family member, caregiver, or another person who actually exercised protection or supervision over the victim, the nature of that protective relationship and the specific conduct involved become particularly important.
The legal analysis may extend beyond physical assault.
Depending on the circumstances, intentionally withholding necessary care, exploiting the victim’s vulnerable condition, neglecting essential needs, or engaging in other harmful conduct may require review under statutes protecting persons with disabilities together with the general criminal provisions governing assault, bodily injury, abandonment, neglect, and abuse.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR ABUSE CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Identify the Type of Alleged Abuse and the Relationship Between the Parties
We determine whether the alleged victim is a child, an older person, a person with a disability, or another person requiring protection and examine the nature of any protective or supervisory relationship between the client and the alleged victim.
STEP 02 | Separate and Chronologically Organize the Alleged Conduct
We distinguish among physical conduct, emotional conduct, neglect, abandonment, and other alleged acts and organize when each act is said to have occurred, how often it occurred, and over what period.
STEP 03 | Analyze Objective Evidence and the Victim’s Statements
We review CCTV footage, scene evidence, medical records, witness and caregiver statements, and other materials appropriate to the type of case to determine whether the allegations are consistent with the objective record.
STEP 04 | Distinguish Legitimate Care, Supervision, or Discipline from Abuse
In child-related cases, we examine whether the conduct falls within lawful educational or supervisory activity or crosses the line into abuse.
In cases involving older persons or persons with disabilities, we similarly distinguish ordinary caregiving or protective conduct from treatment that may constitute criminal abuse or neglect.
Under current Korean child abuse law, legitimate educational activities and student guidance by teachers carried out in accordance with applicable education laws are not treated as child abuse.
STEP 05 | Respond to the First Police Interview and Protective Measures
Where separation, restrictions on contact, or other protective measures have already been imposed, we review the legal and factual basis for those measures while preparing a detailed account of the circumstances and each alleged act before substantive police questioning.
STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Trial
Where the allegations are disputed, we address the alleged abusive conduct, intent, causation, and resulting harm based on the available evidence.
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we prepare appropriate materials concerning victim recovery, recurrence prevention, treatment or education, and other circumstances relevant to prosecution and sentencing.
FOR VICTIMS AND PROTECTIVE FAMILY MEMBERS
STEP 01 | Document the Alleged Abuse and Whether It Was Repeated
We identify when the conduct began, what forms of abuse occurred, and whether the matter involves an isolated incident or repeated conduct over time.
STEP 02 | Document the Victim’s Condition and Secure Objective Evidence
We collect photographs of injuries, medical records, CCTV footage, scene evidence, statements from caregivers or other witnesses, and other materials relevant to the case.
We also document the victim’s physical and psychological condition.
STEP 03 | Identify the Type of Abuse and the Applicable Offenses
We distinguish among child abuse, elder abuse, abuse involving a person with a disability, physical or emotional abuse, neglect, abandonment, and related conduct and determine which statutes and criminal offenses may apply.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We organize the specific abusive acts, timing, repetition, and resulting harm and connect those facts to the objective evidence so that the overall course of conduct can be accurately presented to investigators.
STEP 05 | Consider Separation and Measures to Prevent Further Harm
Where there is a continuing risk of abuse, the victim’s immediate safety must be addressed.
We review available measures such as separation, restrictions on approaching or contacting the victim, emergency protection, and other protective procedures appropriate to the type of case. In child abuse cases, current law expressly provides for emergency separation and court-issued protective orders.
STEP 06 | Respond Through Criminal Trial and Pursue Recovery
Where the alleged offender is prosecuted, we assist in presenting the victim’s position concerning the extent and repetition of the harm.
Where appropriate, we also review civil claims for damages and other procedures aimed at securing meaningful recovery.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Understand What Investigators Examine After an Abuse Report
An abuse case cannot be determined solely from the fact that a report was made, nor can it be resolved merely because the accused states that there was no intent to abuse.
This is particularly important where the alleged victim is a child, older person, person with a disability, or another individual requiring protection.
Investigators may consider not only the victim’s statement but also the protective relationship between the parties, the living environment, whether the conduct was repeated, CCTV footage, medical records, and other objective evidence.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the initial report, the scene, statements from the victim, caregivers and other relevant persons, and the objective evidence as one connected record.
01 | Review the Initial Report and First Response
We examine how the emergency or abuse report was made, what police or other authorities observed at the scene, the earliest statements of the alleged victim and accused, and whether separation or other protective measures were immediately imposed.
02 | Examine the Full Context, Not an Isolated Moment
We do not evaluate the case solely from a particular CCTV clip, statement, or incident.
We examine the relationship between the parties and the circumstances before and after the alleged conduct to understand its full context.
03 | Cross-Check the Victim’s Statement Against Objective Evidence
We compare the statements of the victim and accused with CCTV footage, medical records, scene evidence, statements from caregivers and witnesses, and other available materials to establish the facts as accurately as possible.
04 | Distinguish the Applicable Law Based on the Victim and Type of Conduct
We identify the victim’s age and condition, the protective relationship, and the type of alleged conduct to determine whether the case is governed by the general abuse provisions of the Criminal Act, child abuse legislation, elder protection laws, disability-related legislation, or additional criminal provisions.
05 | Examine Repetition, Habitual Conduct, and the Resulting Harm
We determine whether the alleged conduct occurred once or repeatedly and whether it resulted in bodily injury, serious harm, or death.
This distinction may materially affect both the applicable offense and the potential level of criminal responsibility.
06 | Develop the Appropriate Strategy from the First Police Interview
Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators evaluate the initial report, the victim’s statement, the protective or supervisory relationship, CCTV and medical evidence, repetition of the conduct, and resulting harm, and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.
Where the same allegations also give rise to family proceedings, civil claims, school-related proceedings, workplace or disciplinary matters, or other legal processes, we consider how statements, protective measures, and findings in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN AN ABUSE CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT A SINGLE INCIDENT IN ISOLATION, BUT THE RELATIONSHIP OF PROTECTION OR SUPERVISION, THE NATURE AND PATTERN OF THE CONDUCT, THE VICTIM’S VULNERABILITY, AND WHAT THE OBJECTIVE EVIDENCE SHOWS ABOUT THE HARM THAT OCCURRED.
Carefully reconstructing the full course of conduct—from the first reported incident through the victim’s condition, medical evidence, living environment, and protective relationship—can be critical to distinguishing lawful care or supervision from criminal abuse and to protecting the rights and safety of everyone involved.
THREATS
WHAT IS CRIMINAL THREATENING?
Criminal threatening is an offense under Article 283 of Korea’s Criminal Act that may be established where a person communicates a threat of harm in a manner capable of causing fear in another person.
The threatened harm does not have to be expressed in direct terms such as “I will kill you” or “I will hurt you.” The legal assessment depends on the content of the words or conduct, the relationship between the parties, the surrounding circumstances, and the context before and after the statement.
The Supreme Court has also held that the victim does not necessarily have to prove that he or she actually experienced fear. Depending on the circumstances, the offense may be established where the victim recognized the communication of harm and the expression was objectively capable of causing fear.
Accordingly, a threat case should not be evaluated by isolating a single sentence. It is necessary to examine the circumstances in which the expression was made, the relationship between the accused and the victim, whether similar conduct was repeated, and whether there were surrounding facts suggesting that the threatened harm could realistically be carried out.
Depending on the manner of conduct and the relationship between the parties, threat offenses may include ordinary threats, threats against a lineal ascendant, aggravated threats involving a dangerous object or collective force, and habitual threats. Where the threat is made for retaliatory purposes in connection with a criminal case, more serious liability may arise under Korea’s Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes.
MAJOR TYPES OF THREATS AND PENALTIES
ORDINARY THREATS
Ordinary threats may arise where a person communicates harm concerning another person’s life, body, liberty, reputation, property, or other legally protected interests in a manner capable of causing fear.
Under Article 283(1) of the Criminal Act, the offense is punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 3 years, a fine of up to KRW 5 million, detention, or a minor fine.
Ordinary threats cannot be prosecuted contrary to the victim’s expressly stated wishes. Accordingly, the victim’s position concerning punishment may have an important effect on the course of the case.
THREATS AGAINST A LINEAL ASCENDANT
A more severe statutory penalty applies where the victim is the offender’s own lineal ascendant or the lineal ascendant of the offender’s spouse.
Under Article 283(2) of the Criminal Act, the offense is punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 7 million.
This offense is also subject to the rule that prosecution cannot proceed against the victim’s expressly stated wishes.
AGGRAVATED THREATS
Article 284 of the Criminal Act may apply where a threat is made while demonstrating the collective force of a group or crowd or while carrying a dangerous object.
In an aggravated threat case, the analysis should not focus solely on whether an object happened to be present at the scene.
It is necessary to examine the nature of the object, why and how it was carried, whether it was readily available for use, the accused’s words and conduct, and the overall circumstances of the incident.
Aggravated threats are punishable by:
imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.
Unlike ordinary threats, aggravated threats are not subject to the same rule preventing prosecution against the victim’s wishes. A settlement may still be relevant, but it does not by itself terminate the criminal proceedings.
HABITUAL THREATS
Where threat offenses are committed repeatedly and habituality is legally established, habitual threats may be at issue.
Under Article 285 of the Criminal Act, where ordinary threats, threats against a lineal ascendant, or aggravated threats are committed habitually, the punishment prescribed for the underlying offense may be increased by up to one-half.
Habituality is not determined merely because multiple calls or messages were made.
The number and duration of the incidents, method of conduct, repetition, prior criminal history, and other circumstances must be considered together.
RETALIATORY THREATS
More serious criminal liability may arise where a person threatens another in connection with a criminal case for the purpose of preventing a complaint, accusation, statement, testimony, or submission of evidence, or retaliating for such conduct that has already occurred.
Under Article 5-9(2) of Korea’s Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes, retaliatory threats of this kind are punishable by:
imprisonment for at least 1 year.
Accordingly, conduct such as threatening a person to withdraw a criminal complaint or retaliating against someone for a statement made to police or in court should not automatically be treated as an ordinary threat case.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR THREAT CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Identify the Alleged Threat and Reconstruct the Incident
We determine precisely which words or conduct are alleged to constitute a threat and organize the circumstances leading to the incident, the relationship between the parties, and the events before and after the expression in chronological order.
STEP 02 | Analyze the Full Context and Whether a Threat of Harm Was Communicated
We do not isolate a particular phrase from the surrounding conversation.
We review the entire interaction and the circumstances at the time to determine whether the expression legally amounted to a communication of harm capable of causing fear.
STEP 03 | Compare Statements with Objective Evidence
We examine call recordings, message histories, CCTV footage, scene recordings, witness statements, and other relevant materials to determine whether the complainant’s account is consistent with the objective evidence.
STEP 04 | Distinguish Ordinary, Aggravated, Habitual, and Retaliatory Threats
We examine whether a dangerous object was carried, whether collective force was involved, whether similar conduct was repeated, and whether there was any retaliatory purpose connected to a criminal complaint, statement, testimony, or other participation in criminal proceedings.
STEP 05 | Develop a Strategy for the First Police Interview and Settlement
We prepare the client’s statement around the meaning of the disputed words, the surrounding circumstances, and the relationship between the parties.
Where the offense is one in which the victim’s stated wishes concerning punishment may have legal effect, we also assess whether and when settlement should be considered based on the facts and allegations.
STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Trial
Where the allegation is disputed, we focus on whether a legally sufficient threat of harm was made, the accused’s intent, and the full context of the communication.
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we prepare materials concerning victim recovery, settlement, the circumstances of the offense, and other matters relevant to prosecution and sentencing.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Document the Threat and the Circumstances
We organize when, where, and how the threat was made, what harm was communicated, and whether similar conduct occurred previously.
STEP 02 | Secure and Preserve Evidence
We preserve call recordings, messages, emails, CCTV footage, scene video or audio recordings, witness statements, and other materials showing the content and circumstances of the threat, preferably in their original form.
STEP 03 | Assess the Type and Seriousness of the Threat
We examine whether the conduct involves an ordinary threat, a dangerous object or collective force, repeated threatening conduct, or retaliatory intent connected to a criminal complaint, statement, testimony, or other participation in criminal proceedings.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We connect the specific threatened harm and surrounding circumstances with the objective evidence and prepare the criminal complaint accordingly.
We also prepare for the police interview so that the chronology and resulting fear or harm are presented clearly and accurately.
STEP 05 | Prevent Further Harm and Pursue Recovery
Where threatening conduct continues or there is a realistic risk of further harm, we review protective measures that may be available based on the nature of the case.
Where emotional or financial loss has resulted, we also consider potential civil claims for damages or other appropriate recovery measures.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Examine the Situation Behind the Words, Not Just the Words Themselves
A threat case is not determined by a single sentence in isolation.
The same words may be evaluated differently depending on who said them, to whom they were directed, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances in which they were spoken.
Conversely, even without an explicit statement such as “I will harm you,” the combination of words, conduct, and surrounding circumstances may still amount to a legally sufficient threat.
Where a dangerous object is involved, threatening conduct is repeated, or retaliatory intent connected to a criminal complaint or statement is alleged, the applicable offense may extend beyond ordinary threats to aggravated, habitual, or retaliatory threats.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the initial report, the statements of the parties, objective evidence, and conduct before and after the incident as one continuous sequence and to identify the issues investigators are likely to examine.
01 | Review the Initial Emergency Report and Circumstances at the Scene
Where an emergency call was made, we examine the initial report, the condition and statements of the parties when police arrived, and other circumstances immediately following the incident.
02 | Analyze the Context Before and After the Alleged Threat
We do not review only the disputed words.
We examine what was said and done before and after the expression to determine whether, in context, the communication amounted to a legally relevant threat of harm.
03 | Compare Recordings and Objective Evidence with the Parties’ Statements
We compare call recordings, scene materials, messages, CCTV footage, and other objective evidence with the parties’ accounts to reconstruct what was actually said and how the situation developed.
04 | Identify Whether More Serious Threat Charges May Apply
We examine whether a dangerous object was carried, whether collective force was involved, whether the threats were repeated, and whether there was any retaliatory purpose connected to a criminal complaint, police statement, testimony, or other participation in criminal proceedings.
05 | Distinguish Cases Requiring Settlement from Cases Requiring a Factual or Legal Defense
We distinguish offenses such as ordinary threats, where the victim’s stated wishes concerning punishment may have direct legal significance, from offenses such as aggravated threats, where settlement alone does not terminate the case.
We then develop the response strategy accordingly.
06 | Respond from the First Police Interview Through Prosecution and Trial
Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators assess the content of the alleged threat, the relationship between the parties, the surrounding circumstances, the involvement of dangerous objects, repetition, and retaliatory purpose, and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.
Where the same conduct also gives rise to stalking allegations, civil claims, family proceedings, workplace or disciplinary matters, school-related proceedings, or other disputes, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A THREAT CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHAT WORDS WERE USED, BUT WHAT HARM WAS COMMUNICATED, IN WHAT CONTEXT, BETWEEN WHOM, AND WHETHER THE CONDUCT WAS OBJECTIVELY CAPABLE OF CAUSING FEAR.
Reconstructing the full conversation, the relationship between the parties, the surrounding conduct, and the objective evidence can be critical to determining whether criminal threatening is established and whether a more serious form of the offense applies.
Abuse (Child Abuse)
We respond to child abuse-related criminal cases by closely analyzing the child's age, the damage sustained, the circumstances of the act, and whether it constitutes abuse. Child Abuse · Violation of the Child Welfare Act · Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment, etc. of Child Abuse Crimes
Child abuse refers to physical, mental, or sexual violence or cruel acts committed by an adult, including a guardian, that may harm the health or welfare of a child or impede the child's normal development, as well as the abandonment or neglect of a child by their guardian.
Child abuse can occur not only in the home, but also in diverse environments such as daycare centers, kindergartens, schools, and child welfare facilities. The applicable laws and severity of punishment vary depending on the specifics of the act in question, the child's age, and their developmental status.
In particular, child abuse cases may involve emergency measures, urgent temporary measures, temporary measures, and victimized child protection orders for the safety of the victimized child separately from criminal punishment, requiring both criminal procedures and protective procedures to be reviewed together.
