WHAT IS MEMBERSHIP IN A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP?
Criminal liability for membership in a criminal organization or group does not arise merely because a person knew people involved in crime or worked alongside them.
Article 114 of Korea’s Criminal Act provides that a person who organizes, joins, or acts as a member of an organization or group formed for the purpose of committing an offense punishable by death, life imprisonment, or imprisonment with a statutory maximum of at least four years is subject to punishment prescribed for the intended offense, although the punishment may be mitigated under the statute.
The Supreme Court has distinguished a criminal organization from an ordinary group of accomplices. A criminal organization generally requires a continuing association of multiple persons formed around a common criminal purpose, together with at least a minimum command structure capable of directing the organization or maintaining its internal order.
A “criminal group” under Article 114 does not require the same degree of command structure as a criminal organization. It must, however, have a sufficiently organized structure to enable its members, through assigned roles, to carry out qualifying crimes repeatedly and systematically. The Supreme Court has explained that such a group must be a continuing association organized around a common criminal purpose and structured in a way that facilitates the planning and execution of repeated offenses.
Accordingly, the central issues are not simply whether the accused appeared on an organizational chart or had contact with other members. It is necessary to determine whether the organization itself legally qualifies as a criminal organization or criminal group, whether the accused understood its criminal purpose when joining or participating, and what role and activities the accused actually performed within it.
In organized offenses such as voice phishing and investment fraud, liability for individual acts of fraud or other offenses may arise separately from allegations of organizing, joining, or acting as a member of a criminal organization or group. Each offense must therefore be analyzed under its own legal requirements.
MAJOR TYPES OF CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OFFENSES AND PENALTIES
ORGANIZING A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP
This may arise where a person establishes the structure and division of roles of an organization, recruits members, or otherwise forms an organization or group for a qualifying criminal purpose.
The fact that several people committed crimes together does not, by itself, make them a criminal organization or group.
It is necessary to examine whether there was a shared purpose of committing qualifying crimes, an ongoing association among the members, a division of roles, and an organizational structure capable of facilitating repeated criminal activity.
Under Article 114 of the Criminal Act, a person who organizes a qualifying criminal organization or group is punished according to the statutory penalty prescribed for the offense that the organization or group was formed to commit, subject to the statutory possibility of mitigation.
JOINING A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP
This involves entering an already existing criminal organization or group as a member.
The key issue is not merely whether the accused communicated or worked with people associated with the organization, but whether the accused joined as a member while understanding the organization’s criminal purpose and character.
Article 114 does not establish a single, separate fixed penalty for membership. Instead, a person who joins a qualifying criminal organization or group is punished according to the statutory penalty for the offense that the organization or group intends to commit, subject to the possibility of mitigation.
The potential penalty may therefore vary significantly depending on the criminal objective of the organization.
ACTING AS A MEMBER OF A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP
Where a person, after joining an organization or group, carries out activities as a member in furtherance of its criminal purpose, criminal liability for participation in the organization’s activities may arise.
Investigators may look beyond formal titles or job descriptions and examine what the person actually did, who gave instructions and received reports, how tasks were divided among members, and whether the person’s activities were connected to the organization’s criminal proceeds or operations.
Here again, Article 114 provides that punishment is based on the statutory penalty for the organization’s intended offense, subject to the statutory possibility of mitigation.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION LIABILITY AND INDIVIDUAL OFFENSES
In a criminal organization case, allegations of organizing, joining, or acting as a member of the organization may arise together with liability for individual offenses actually committed by the organization, such as fraud, robbery, extortion, or other crimes.
Accordingly, the fact that a person did not personally deceive a victim or was not physically present when an offense occurred does not automatically eliminate potential criminal organization liability.
Conversely, the fact that a person performed some work for an organization does not automatically establish that the person knew of and participated in every crime committed by the organization.
The individual’s knowledge, actual role, point of entry, duration of participation, and scope of involvement must be analyzed separately.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Determine How the Client Entered the Organization and What Role Was Actually Performed
We establish who introduced the client to the organization, what the client was told at the time, when the client became involved, and what work was actually performed.
A central issue is whether the relationship was merely employment or another limited association, or whether the client knowingly joined an organization for a criminal purpose.
STEP 02 | Examine Whether a Criminal Organization or Group Legally Existed
We review the membership structure, division of roles, command and reporting relationships, duration of operation, and method of committing offenses to determine whether the organization actually satisfies the legal requirements of a criminal organization or criminal group under the Criminal Act.
STEP 03 | Identify When the Client Became Aware of the Criminal Purpose
We examine whether the client knew of the criminal purpose before joining or only became aware of it later while performing particular tasks.
The existence and timing of this knowledge may be a critical issue in determining liability for joining a criminal organization or group.
STEP 04 | Distinguish the Client’s Role and Scope of Participation
We determine whether the client is alleged to have acted as a leader, manager, recruiter, operative, or other participant, or whether the client merely performed limited tasks at another person’s direction.
We compare those allegations with objective evidence and distinguish the client’s own conduct from the acts of other members.
STEP 05 | Respond to Police Questioning and Detention Proceedings
Organized crime investigations may expand through statements from multiple suspects, seized electronic devices, financial records, and other evidence.
Before the first substantive police interview, we clarify the client’s actual role, knowledge, and period of involvement and prepare for possible arrest or detention proceedings where necessary.
STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Criminal Trial
We determine whether the case should focus on disputing the existence of a criminal organization or group, disputing knowledge or intent regarding membership or activities, or addressing the client’s limited degree of involvement and sentencing considerations.
We then develop the appropriate strategy for prosecution and trial.
FOR VICTIMS
STEP 01 | Reconstruct How the Organized Crime Caused the Harm
We organize when and how the harm occurred, who first contacted the victim, who directly participated in the offense, and what roles different individuals appeared to perform during the scheme.
STEP 02 | Secure Evidence of Organized Criminal Activity
We collect relevant communications, remittance and financial records, contracts and transaction records, recordings, and records of contact with individual participants to establish the relationship between specific offenders and the broader criminal operation.
STEP 03 | Analyze the Organizational Structure and Division of Roles
We examine whether multiple offenders repeatedly engaged in similar conduct and whether there are indications of instructions, reporting relationships, or divided responsibilities that may demonstrate organized criminal activity beyond an ordinary joint offense.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview
We organize not only the individual acts committed against the victim but also the apparent organizational structure and division of roles and connect those facts to objective evidence for submission to the investigative authorities.
STEP 05 | Respond to Further Harm or Retaliation
Where members of the organization make additional contact, threats, or other attempts that may cause secondary harm, we preserve the relevant evidence and consider available victim-protection measures based on the circumstances.
STEP 06 | Review Options for Recovery
Alongside the criminal proceedings, we examine potential methods of recovering financial and other legally compensable losses, including civil claims against responsible parties where appropriate.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Distinguish the Organization as a Whole from the Role of Each Individual
One of the most important distinctions in a criminal organization case is between whether the organization itself qualifies as a criminal organization or group and whether a particular person can legally be treated as one of its members.
The involvement of multiple people in the same criminal scheme does not mean that every person necessarily bears the same criminal responsibility.
Individual liability may vary depending on when the person became aware of the organization’s criminal purpose, from whom instructions were received, what duties were actually performed, how long the person participated, and how extensively the person became involved.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the case with an understanding of how organized crime investigations examine organizational charts, command structures, divisions of responsibility, and each suspect’s knowledge and participation.
01 | Reconstruct the Organization’s Actual Structure
We examine the structure identified by investigators, including command and reporting relationships and the roles attributed to individual members, to determine whether an ongoing organizational system actually existed.
02 | Determine What the Client Knew When Joining
We identify who recruited or introduced the client, how the work was described, what the client understood the work to involve, and when the client first became aware of any criminal purpose.
This is critical to analyzing whether the required intent for membership can be established.
03 | Separate the Client’s Actual Conduct from the Organization as a Whole
We distinguish offenses committed across the organization from conduct actually performed by the client and analyze the client’s substantive degree of involvement based on instructions received, the scope of duties, and the duration of participation.
04 | Cross-Check Seized Evidence Against Statements from Other Members
We compare mobile phone and electronic data, account and transaction records, and other objective evidence seized or obtained during the investigation with statements made by other alleged members to determine whether their descriptions accurately reflect the client’s actual role.
05 | Respond to Expanding Investigations and the Risk of Detention
Criminal organization investigations frequently expand from one suspect to others through statements, seized devices, financial records, and communication data.
We identify the likely scope and direction of the investigation from the earliest stage and prepare for police questioning and any detention or warrant proceedings.
06 | Distinguish Individual Responsibility from the First Police Interview
Drawing on experience with organized crime investigations, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators are likely to establish the organization’s structure and command system, knowledge of its criminal purpose, and each individual member’s role and degree of participation, and develop a consistent strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.
IN A CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A PERSON WORKED WITH PEOPLE WHO COMMITTED CRIMES, BUT WHETHER A QUALIFYING CRIMINAL ORGANIZATION OR GROUP EXISTED AND WHETHER THAT PERSON KNOWINGLY JOINED OR ACTED AS A MEMBER OF IT.
Carefully distinguishing the organization’s criminal purpose from the individual’s own knowledge, role, timing, and scope of participation can be critical to determining the true extent of criminal responsibility.