WHAT IS THE OFFENSE OF FALSE ACCUSATION?
The offense of false accusation is established under Article 156 of Korea’s Criminal Act when a person reports false facts to a public office or public official for the purpose of causing another person to be subjected to criminal punishment or disciplinary action.
The offense is not established merely because a report later turns out to be inconsistent with the actual facts.
It is necessary to examine whether the reported facts were objectively false, whether the person making the report knew that they were false, and whether the report was made for the purpose of causing another person to face criminal or disciplinary action.
Even where part of a complaint or report is inaccurate, the offense may not be established if the discrepancy concerns only a minor exaggeration or a detail that does not materially affect whether the alleged offense occurred.
Likewise, where a person accurately reports the underlying facts but reaches an incorrect legal conclusion about those facts, that does not automatically amount to reporting false facts.
For that reason, a false accusation case requires a careful comparison between the original complaint or report and the objective evidence, with particular attention to what the reporting person actually knew and believed at the time the report was made.
PENALTIES FOR FALSE ACCUSATION
Under Article 156 of the Criminal Act, a person who reports false facts to a public office or public official for the purpose of causing another person to be subjected to criminal punishment or disciplinary action may be punished by:
imprisonment for up to 10 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.
Under the Korean Sentencing Commission’s sentencing guidelines for general false accusation offenses, the recommended ranges are:
Mitigated: up to 1 year
Standard: 6 months to 2 years
Aggravated: 1 year to 4 years
The statutory penalty and the sentencing guideline range must be distinguished from the actual sentence imposed in an individual case.
The outcome may vary depending on the nature and seriousness of the false report, the circumstances in which it was made, the extent of harm caused, conduct after the offense, voluntary surrender or confession, recovery of harm, prior criminal history, and other case-specific sentencing factors.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR FALSE ACCUSATION CASES
FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS
STEP 01 | Analyze the Original Complaint, Report, and Evidence
We obtain and review the original criminal complaint, petition, or other report that gave rise to the false accusation allegation, together with text messages, messenger communications, call records, photographs, videos, and other materials submitted at the time.
We then compare the reported facts with the objective record.
STEP 02 | Examine Falsity and Intent
We determine whether the reported facts were objectively false and whether, at the time of reporting, the client had a reasonable factual basis for believing them to be true.
This analysis is central to determining whether the legal requirements for false accusation are satisfied.
STEP 03 | Reconstruct the Circumstances and the Client’s State of Knowledge at the Time of the Report
We examine why the original complaint or report was made, what the client knew at the time, what evidence was then available, and the relationship between the parties.
We identify circumstances that may distinguish a mistake, misunderstanding, or subjective interpretation from a knowingly false report.
STEP 04 | Develop a Strategy for Police Questioning
We organize the facts to avoid unnecessary inconsistencies between the original report and statements made during the false accusation investigation.
We prepare for anticipated questions with particular focus on objective falsity, the client’s knowledge and belief at the time of reporting, and the purpose of the original complaint.
STEP 05 | Respond to Prosecution and Criminal Trial
We analyze the evidence obtained during the investigation together with the record of the original case and challenge whether the elements of false accusation are actually established.
If charges are filed, we develop the defense around the objective truth or falsity of the reported facts, the client’s knowledge at the time, and the required intent.
FOR VICTIMS OF AN ALLEGED FALSE ACCUSATION
STEP 01 | Analyze the Original Criminal Case and Its Procedural History
We review the allegations made against the client in the original criminal matter, the outcome of that case, and the complaint, statements, and other materials submitted by the reporting person.
We identify the specific portions that may constitute a knowingly false report.
STEP 02 | Secure Evidence Establishing Falsity
We collect and analyze objective evidence that contradicts the original allegations, including CCTV footage, recordings, text and messenger communications, location or access records, and statements from third parties.
STEP 03 | Assess Whether the Requirements for False Accusation Are Satisfied
The fact that the original case ended without charges or resulted in an acquittal does not, by itself, establish that the reporting person committed false accusation.
We also examine whether the person knew the relevant allegations were false when the report was made and whether the other statutory elements can be established.
STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Respond to the Police Investigation
We identify precisely which reported facts are alleged to be false and connect each allegation with the objective evidence that contradicts it.
We then prepare for police questioning so that the background of the original case and the circumstances indicating a knowingly false report can be explained clearly and consistently.
STEP 05 | Pursue Criminal Proceedings and Recovery of Harm
As the investigation proceeds, we submit additional evidence and legal arguments where necessary.
Where the false report caused identifiable financial, reputational, or other legally compensable harm, we also review whether separate civil remedies may be available.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Reconstruct the Investigation from the Original Case Forward
A false accusation case cannot be properly analyzed by looking only at the new allegation of false reporting.
It is necessary to examine what was originally alleged, what statements were made during the first police investigation, how those statements compare with the objective evidence, and what the reporting person actually knew at the time of the original complaint.
Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to review the entire sequence from the original complaint through the subsequent false accusation investigation and develop a consistent strategy based on that record.
01 | Reexamine the Case from the Original Complaint
We do not analyze the false accusation case in isolation.
We review how the original complaint or report arose, what was stated during the police investigation, what evidence was submitted, and how the original case was ultimately handled.
02 | Analyze Falsity from an Investigative Perspective
Drawing on practical police experience, we consider what statements and evidence investigators are likely to use in determining whether the original report was false and identify the materials that are most significant to that analysis.
03 | Cross-Check Prior Statements Against Objective Evidence
We compare the original complaint, police statements, text and messenger communications, recordings, CCTV footage, entry and access records, and other objective evidence to identify where the statements are consistent with the record and where material contradictions exist.
04 | Prepare the Statement Strategy Before the First Police Interview
A false accusation investigation may involve close scrutiny of statements made in the original case.
We therefore review the relationship between past and present statements in advance and prepare for anticipated questions so that the client’s position remains accurate and internally consistent.
05 | Develop a Strategy Tailored to Suspects and Victims
Where the client is accused of false accusation, we focus on whether the reported facts were objectively false and whether the client knowingly made a false report with the required purpose.
Where the client was the target of an allegedly false report, we focus on objective evidence showing how the report differs from the actual facts and whether the reporting person knew of that discrepancy at the time.
06 | Maintain a Consistent Strategy from Police Investigation Through Prosecution and Trial
We connect the record of the original case with the evidence and statements in the false accusation case so that the central factual and legal position remains consistent through police investigation, prosecution, and criminal trial.
Where the original dispute also involves civil litigation, family proceedings, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, school-related matters, or other legal processes, we also consider how statements and findings in those proceedings may affect the false accusation case and coordinate the response accordingly.
IN A FALSE ACCUSATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER THE ORIGINAL ALLEGATION PROVED TO BE WRONG, BUT WHETHER A MATERIALLY FALSE FACT WAS KNOWINGLY REPORTED FOR THE PURPOSE OF SUBJECTING ANOTHER PERSON TO CRIMINAL OR DISCIPLINARY ACTION.
Reconstructing the original complaint, the evidence available at the time, and the reporting person’s actual state of knowledge is often critical to determining whether the offense of false accusation is established.