Veteran Law Firm

Criminal Defense

OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS

WHAT IS OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS?

WHAT IS OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS?

Obstruction of business is an offense under Article 314 of Korea’s Criminal Act that may be established where a person interferes with another person’s business by spreading false information or by using deception, force, or other prohibited means.

The term “business” is not limited to commercial operations conducted by a company or business owner. It may include work or activities that a person continuously performs based on his or her social or professional position, and in a specific case it is first necessary to determine whether the activity at issue qualifies as legally protected “business” under the Criminal Act.

The offense does not necessarily require that the business be completely shut down or that actual financial loss occur. Depending on the circumstances, criminal liability may arise where the conduct creates a concrete risk of interfering with the business.

Cases may involve disruptive conduct at stores or workplaces, interference with ordinary decision-making through false information, the use of force or influence sufficient to overwhelm another person’s freedom of decision, or interference with business operations by damaging, altering, or manipulating computers, electronic records, or other information-processing systems.

Accordingly, an obstruction of business case should not be evaluated solely on the assertion that “the business suffered harm.” It is necessary to examine what business was being conducted, how the alleged interference occurred, and what actual disruption or risk of disruption arose from the conduct.

MAJOR TYPES OF OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS AND PENALTIES

OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS BY SPREADING FALSE INFORMATION

This issue may arise where objectively false information is disseminated to unspecified persons or a broader audience and interferes with another person’s business.

The analysis does not end with whether a statement was inaccurate. It is also necessary to examine whether the information was actually false, whether the person knew of its falsity, and how the dissemination was connected to the alleged interference with the business.

Under Articles 314(1) and 313 of the Criminal Act, obstruction of business by spreading false information may be punishable by:

imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.

OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS BY DECEPTION

Obstruction by deception may arise where a person causes another to make a mistake or form a false understanding and then exploits that misunderstanding in a manner that interferes with the normal performance of business.

This may occur, for example, where false documents, misleading information, or deceptive methods are used to improperly influence an ordinary screening, selection, review, or decision-making process.

Whether particular conduct legally constitutes “deception” under the Criminal Act must be determined based on the specific circumstances of the case.

The statutory penalty is:

imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.

OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS BY FORCE

Obstruction by force may be established where a person uses physical, psychological, social, or other influence of a degree capable of suppressing or confusing another person’s freedom of decision and thereby interferes with business.

This may include prolonged disruptive conduct at a place of business or physical behavior that makes ordinary operations difficult.

However, raising one’s voice or making a protest does not automatically constitute criminal obstruction of business.

It is necessary to examine the method and degree of the conduct, how long it continued, where it occurred, the surrounding circumstances, and the actual effect or risk posed to the business.

The statutory penalty is:

imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.

OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS THROUGH INTERFERENCE WITH COMPUTER OR INFORMATION-PROCESSING SYSTEMS

Article 314(2) of the Criminal Act may apply where a person interferes with another person’s business by damaging a computer or other information-processing device, damaging or altering electronic or other special-media records, entering false information or unauthorized commands, or otherwise causing disruption to information processing.

In this type of case, key issues may include what data or commands were entered, what actual system malfunction or disruption occurred, and whether there is a sufficient connection between that disruption and the alleged interference with business.

The statutory penalty is the same as for general obstruction of business:

imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Identify the Business at Issue and Reconstruct the Incident

We first determine what business is alleged to have been obstructed and then organize the time and location of the incident, the relationship between the parties, the conduct at issue, and the surrounding events in chronological order.

STEP 02 | Determine the Alleged Method of Obstruction and Review the Legal Requirements

We distinguish whether the allegation involves spreading false information, deception, force, or interference with computers or information-processing systems and analyze the legal requirements applicable to each theory.

STEP 03 | Analyze CCTV, Scene Evidence, and Business Records

We review objective materials appropriate to the case, including CCTV footage, video and audio recordings from the scene, emergency-call records, police response records, business records, and other evidence to determine what actually occurred and how the conduct affected business operations.

STEP 04 | Examine Intent and Whether a Risk of Business Interference Actually Arose

We assess whether the incident arose in the course of a legitimate protest or exercise of rights, whether there was an intent to interfere with another person’s business, and whether the conduct created a legally sufficient risk of obstruction.

STEP 05 | Prepare for Police Questioning

Based on statements from the complainant and witnesses and the available objective evidence, we identify the issues investigators are likely to examine and prepare for questioning with particular focus on the purpose, method, and circumstances of the conduct.

STEP 06 | Address Victim Recovery, Prosecution, and Trial

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we examine the actual scope of harm and consider recovery and settlement where appropriate.

Where the allegation is disputed, we respond through prosecution and trial based on the legal requirements of obstruction of business and the objective evidentiary record.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Document the Business and the Circumstances of the Interference

We identify what business was being conducted, how it was allegedly interfered with, how long the conduct continued, and what disruption or risk arose to normal operations.

STEP 02 | Secure Evidence of the Obstruction

We preserve objective materials such as CCTV footage, scene video or audio recordings, emergency-call records, witness statements, sales or work records, and other evidence showing the conduct and its impact on the business.

STEP 03 | Analyze the Method of Obstruction and Resulting Harm

We determine whether the alleged conduct involved false information, deception, force, or interference with information-processing systems and organize the operational disruption and any resulting loss.

STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview

We connect the alleged conduct to the objective evidence and prepare the criminal complaint so that the manner and course of obstruction are clearly presented.

We also prepare for the police interview so that the business impact and relevant chronology can be explained accurately.

Where actual financial loss has resulted from the obstruction, we organize the supporting evidence and consider whether civil claims for damages or other follow-up proceedings should be pursued separately from the criminal case.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Focus on What Actually Happened, Not Simply the Claim That Business Was “Disrupted”

An obstruction of business case is not automatically established merely because a complainant claims that his or her business was affected.

It is necessary to determine what legally protected business existed, whether the conduct amounted to spreading false information, deception, force, or another prohibited method, and whether the conduct created an actual risk of interfering with that business.

This is particularly important in incidents occurring at a workplace, store, restaurant, hospital, office, or other physical location, where the parties may sharply disagree over whether the conduct was a legitimate complaint or protest, or whether it crossed the line into criminal force.

From the victim’s perspective as well, it is generally more important to demonstrate through objective evidence what actually happened and how operations were affected than simply to assert that the business suffered disruption.

Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the initial emergency report, the police response, CCTV footage, scene materials, business records, and statements from the parties and witnesses together, with a focus on the issues investigators are likely to examine in an obstruction of business case.

01 | Review the Initial Report and Scene from the Beginning

Where an emergency call was made, we examine the initial report, the circumstances observed when police arrived, the location and conduct of the parties, and other evidence created immediately after the incident.

02 | Reconstruct the Conduct from Beginning to End Through CCTV and Other Evidence

We determine when the conduct began, how long it continued, how the other party responded, and what actually occurred at the business location by reviewing CCTV footage, recordings, and other available evidence chronologically.

03 | Distinguish False Information, Deception, Force, and Ordinary Disputes

We analyze whether the conduct was merely a protest or disagreement, involved dissemination of false information, used deception capable of misleading another person, or involved force sufficient to interfere with free decision-making.

04 | Objectively Analyze the Risk and Actual Impact on Business Operations

We compare business conditions before, during, and after the incident with available sales, operational, work, and other records to assess what disruption or risk actually occurred.

05 | Examine System Records in Computer-Related Obstruction Cases

Where the allegation involves an information-processing device or system, we analyze available data concerning the disputed commands, system activity, timing of any malfunction, and resulting operational disruption to determine the relationship between the alleged conduct and the claimed interference.

06 | Develop a Case-Specific Strategy from the First Police Interview

Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators are likely to examine the existence of protected business, the alleged method of interference, CCTV and witness evidence, and the actual impact on operations, and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.

Where the same incident also gives rise to civil claims, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, family matters, school-related proceedings, or other disputes, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.

IN AN OBSTRUCTION OF BUSINESS CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER SOMEONE CLAIMS THAT BUSINESS WAS DISRUPTED, BUT WHETHER LEGALLY PROTECTED BUSINESS EXISTED, WHAT METHOD OF INTERFERENCE WAS USED, AND WHETHER THAT CONDUCT CREATED A LEGALLY RELEVANT RISK OR ACTUAL OBSTRUCTION.

Reconstructing the entire incident through objective evidence—including CCTV footage, recordings, business records, system data, and witness statements—can be critical to distinguishing a legitimate dispute or protest from criminal obstruction of business.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.