Veteran Law Firm

Criminal Defense

DEFAMATION

WHAT IS DEFAMATION?

WHAT IS DEFAMATION?

Defamation may arise where a person publicly alleges facts or false facts concerning another person in a manner capable of harming that person’s social reputation.

Under Korea’s Criminal Act, defamation based on true factual allegations and defamation based on false factual allegations are treated separately. The legal analysis therefore extends beyond the wording of the statement or post itself and may include who received it, how widely it was disseminated, and whether the expression alleged a specific fact or instead amounted primarily to an opinion, evaluation, or value judgment.

Expressions made through online posts, social media, group chats, videos, comments, and other channels capable of rapid dissemination require particular attention to the actual and potential scope of distribution and the circumstances in which the content was created and shared.

The fact that a statement is true does not automatically eliminate criminal liability under Korean law. Article 310 of the Criminal Act, however, provides that conduct falling under Article 307(1) is not punishable where the alleged facts are true and relate solely to the public interest. Both truthfulness and public-interest considerations must therefore be carefully examined.

A defamation case should not be evaluated by isolating a single sentence from the broader communication.

The background of the statement, the surrounding conversation or context, the intended audience, and the actual or potential scope of dissemination should all be considered together.

For a suspect or defendant, key issues may include whether the statement was true or false, whether it alleged a sufficiently specific fact rather than merely expressing an opinion or evaluation, and whether a truthful statement may fall within the public-interest exception under Korean law.

For a victim, it is important to identify precisely what was said or posted, when and where it was communicated, who received it, and how widely it was disseminated. Objective evidence such as screenshots, URLs, messages, video files, and recordings should be preserved wherever possible.

Defamation under Articles 307 and 309 of the Criminal Act is an offense that cannot be prosecuted against the victim’s clearly expressed wishes. If the victim expressly states that punishment is not desired, prosecution cannot proceed contrary to that position.

PENALTIES FOR DEFAMATION

Under Article 307(1) of the Criminal Act, publicly alleging facts in a manner that defames another person is punishable by imprisonment or detention for up to 2 years or a fine of up to KRW 5 million.

Where false facts are publicly alleged, Article 307(2) provides for imprisonment for up to 5 years, suspension of qualifications for up to 10 years, or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.

Where defamation is committed through a newspaper, magazine, radio, or other publication with the purpose of disparaging another person, Article 309 may apply. Defamation based on true facts is punishable by imprisonment or detention for up to 3 years or a fine of up to KRW 7 million, while defamation based on false facts is punishable by imprisonment for up to 7 years, suspension of qualifications for up to 10 years, or a fine of up to KRW 15 million.

The statutory penalty range must be distinguished from the actual prosecutorial disposition or sentence imposed in an individual case.

The outcome may vary depending on the content and manner of the expression, whether the statement was false, the extent of dissemination, the degree of harm caused, whether the content was later deleted or corrected, whether an apology was made, whether a settlement was reached, and other case-specific circumstances.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR DEFAMATION CASES

WHEN FACING DEFAMATION ALLEGATIONS

STEP 01 | Analyze the Expression and the Circumstances in Which It Was Made

We review the content of the statement or post, when it was made, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances leading to the expression to identify precisely what aspect is alleged to be defamatory.

STEP 02 | Examine Truth or Falsity and the Nature of the Expression

We determine whether the expression alleges a specific fact or is closer to an opinion or evaluation and, where it concerns factual allegations, review whether objective materials support their truthfulness.

STEP 03 | Analyze Public-Interest Considerations and the Evidence

We examine posts, messenger communications, recordings, related documents, and other materials to determine whether a truthful factual statement may qualify as an expression made in the public interest.

STEP 04 | Respond to the Police Investigation and Trial

We prepare statements around the issues likely to be examined by investigators and, where appropriate, consider case-specific measures such as deletion or correction of the content, an apology, settlement, or other efforts to address the alleged harm.

WHEN YOU HAVE BEEN THE VICTIM OF DEFAMATION

STEP 01 | Document the Defamatory Content and Its Dissemination

We identify what was said or posted, when and where it was communicated, who received it, and how widely it was distributed or shared.

STEP 02 | Secure Relevant Evidence

We preserve screenshots, URLs, videos, recordings, text messages, messenger communications, and other materials showing both the defamatory content and the circumstances of its dissemination.

STEP 03 | Respond Through the Criminal Process

We assess whether the facts support a criminal complaint, identify the potentially applicable offense, and prepare the complaint and supporting materials describing the alleged harm.

STEP 04 | Pursue Removal, Damage Recovery, and Civil Remedies

We review measures to remove the content or limit further dissemination and, where appropriate, consider a civil claim for compensation for emotional or financial harm.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP WITH DEFAMATION CASES

A defamation case cannot be resolved simply by arguing that “the statement was true” or “the statement was false.”

Veteran Law Firm examines the full context of the expression, including what was said, why it was said, who received it, the surrounding communications, and the actual scope of dissemination.

For suspects and defendants, we distinguish among truth, falsity, factual allegations, opinions or evaluations, and public-interest considerations to identify the central legal issues.

For victims, we connect the defamatory content, the circumstances of dissemination, and the resulting harm with objective evidence to develop an appropriate response strategy.

We also consider issues that may arise alongside the criminal case, including removal of online content, prevention of further dissemination, settlement, and civil claims for damages.

DISTINCTIVE REPRESENTATION BY FORMER POLICE OFFICER ATTORNEYS

In a defamation case, understanding how investigators are likely to evaluate the circumstances of the expression, the accused’s intent, and the possibility of dissemination can be just as important as reviewing the statement itself.

Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys draw on practical experience analyzing statements and digital evidence to examine the relationship among online posts, messenger communications, recordings, communication records, and the statements of the parties.

In online defamation cases in particular, we do not rely solely on a single screenshot. We reconstruct the broader sequence of events by reviewing communications before and after the post, the timing of publication, the intended and actual audience, and any subsequent deletion, correction, or modification of the content.

Where the same expression also gives rise to civil claims, workplace or disciplinary proceedings, school-related matters, family disputes, or other legal proceedings, we consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.

Based on this analysis of the facts and evidence, Veteran Law Firm develops a case-specific strategy from the preparation of a criminal complaint or initial police investigation through criminal trial, content removal, civil damages claims, and any necessary follow-up proceedings.

IN A DEFAMATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER A STATEMENT WAS TRUE OR FALSE, BUT WHAT WAS COMMUNICATED, IN WHAT CONTEXT, TO WHOM, AND WITH WHAT EFFECT ON THE OTHER PERSON’S REPUTATION.

Carefully preserving the full context of the communication and the evidence of how it was created, transmitted, and disseminated can be critical to determining whether criminal defamation is established and to protecting the rights of both the accused and the victim.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.