Veteran Law Firm

Civil Litigation

PURCHASE PRICE DISPUTES

If You Have Delivered the Property but Have Not Been Paid, Both Contract Rescission and the Possibility of Recovery Should Be Considered

If You Have Delivered the Property but Have Not Been Paid, Both Contract Rescission and the Possibility of Recovery Should Be Considered

Disputes may arise after the sale of real estate, vehicles, machinery, equipment, or goods when the buyer fails to pay the deposit, an installment, or the remaining purchase price.

Conversely, a buyer may have paid all or part of the purchase price but still not have received ownership or possession of the property.

A purchase price dispute cannot be resolved simply by confirming that payment remains outstanding.

The validity of the contract, payment deadlines, the seller’s obligations to deliver the property and transfer ownership, and whether those obligations must be performed concurrently with the buyer’s payment obligation should all be examined together.

Veteran Law Firm analyzes the contract and the parties’ course of performance to develop a practical strategy involving claims for the purchase price, contract rescission, provisional attachment, and compulsory enforcement.

WHAT IS A PURCHASE PRICE CLAIM?

Under Article 563 of the Korean Civil Act, a sale is a contract under which one party agrees to transfer a property right to another and the other party agrees to pay the purchase price.

Once a valid sale agreement is formed, the seller must deliver the subject matter and transfer the agreed ownership or other property right, while the buyer must pay the purchase price at the agreed time.

A claim for an unpaid purchase price will generally require proof of the following:

formation of a valid sale agreement;

identification of the property sold and the agreed purchase price;

arrival of the agreed payment date;

performance or tender of performance by the seller; and

the amount of the purchase price that remains unpaid.

COMMON TYPES OF PURCHASE PRICE DISPUTES

Unpaid Balance in a Real Estate Sale

A key issue is often the concurrent performance of the seller’s obligation to transfer title and the buyer’s obligation to pay the remaining purchase price.

Unpaid Price for Goods

Relevant issues may include whether the goods were actually delivered, the quantity and quality of the goods, and whether inspection or acceptance was completed.

Sales of Vehicles, Machinery, and Equipment

Disputes may concern the condition of the property at delivery, alleged defects, transfer of title or registration, and unpaid amounts.

Contract Deposit Disputes

These disputes may involve the legal nature of the deposit and the point at which either party may still exercise a contractual right to withdraw from or rescind the transaction.

Oral Sale Agreements

Where no written contract exists, the parties may dispute whether there was a definite agreement concerning the property and purchase price.

Defect Claims

These disputes may concern whether a defect existed, whether it was disclosed, and whether the buyer is entitled to a price reduction, damages, or another remedy.

Ongoing Commercial Transactions

Where goods are repeatedly ordered and supplied, each purchase order, delivery, payment, and account reconciliation may need to be reviewed separately.

Unpaid Installments or Intermediate Payments

Relevant issues may include acceleration clauses, loss of the benefit of time, and whether the seller may demand the remaining balance immediately.

CAN THE PURCHASE PRICE BE CLAIMED WITHOUT A WRITTEN CONTRACT?

Unless the law requires otherwise in a particular situation, a sale agreement may generally be formed through the parties’ agreement without a formal written contract.

However, if the other party denies the existence of the agreement or disputes the purchase price, the seller must establish the underlying sales relationship.

Relevant evidence may include:

quotations, purchase orders, and contracts;

tax invoices and transaction statements;

bank transfers and records of partial payment;

delivery receipts, acceptance records, and inspection confirmations;

text messages, emails, and messenger communications;

shipping records and warehouse release records;

documents relating to transfer of ownership or registration; and

payment promises or written acknowledgments of debt from the buyer.

The issuance of a tax invoice alone does not necessarily establish every element of the sale or the exact unpaid balance.

Evidence of the actual order, delivery, inspection, and payment history should therefore be considered together.

CAN THE SELLER DEMAND PAYMENT BEFORE TRANSFERRING OWNERSHIP?

Under Article 568 of the Korean Civil Act, unless otherwise agreed or established by custom, the seller’s obligation to transfer the relevant property right and the buyer’s obligation to pay the purchase price are to be performed concurrently.

In a real estate transaction, for example, a seller seeking payment of the remaining balance may need to establish that the seller has performed—or is ready and able to perform—the obligations necessary to transfer title, including preparation of the required registration documents.

Seller’s Obligations

deliver the property;

transfer ownership or other agreed rights;

provide required registration or transfer documents; and

provide the property in the condition required by the agreement.

Buyer’s Obligations

pay the deposit, intermediate payments, and remaining balance;

cooperate with registration or title-transfer procedures;

perform agreed obligations concerning taxes and expenses; and

receive and inspect the property where required.

If the seller has not prepared to perform the seller’s own obligations, the buyer may raise a defense based on concurrent performance.

Conversely, where the seller is ready to perform but the buyer fails to pay the balance, issues involving payment delay and rescission of the contract may arise.

CAN THE SELLER RESCIND THE CONTRACT IF THE BUYER DOES NOT PAY?

The fact that the buyer missed the payment deadline does not mean that every sale agreement can immediately be rescinded.

As a general rule, where one party fails to perform an obligation, the other party may need to demand performance within a reasonable additional period before exercising the right of rescission.

Different rules may apply where performance by a specific date was essential to achieving the purpose of the contract, where the debtor has made clear in advance that performance will not occur, or where the agreement contains a separate rescission provision.

Before rescinding a sale agreement, the following should be reviewed:

whether the payment deadline has arrived;

whether the seller performed or validly tendered the seller’s own obligations;

whether payment was demanded within a reasonable additional period where required;

whether notice of rescission reached the other party; and

whether the agreement contains separate conditions governing rescission.

If the seller disposes of the property to a third party before the requirements for rescission have been satisfied, the seller may instead face allegations of breach of contract.

CLAIMING THE PURCHASE PRICE VS. RESCINDING THE CONTRACT

Claim for the Purchase Price

The purpose is to keep the contract in effect and obtain payment.

Relevant issues include whether the payment date has arrived and whether the seller performed or tendered concurrent performance.

The seller may seek the unpaid amount together with applicable default interest.

Rescission of the Contract

The purpose is to bring the contractual relationship to an end.

Relevant issues may include the other party’s breach, any required demand for performance, and a valid declaration of rescission.

The resulting claims may involve restitution and damages.

Which Approach Is Appropriate?

A purchase price claim may be appropriate where the seller still wants the transaction to be completed.

Rescission may be considered where completion of the transaction has become impracticable or the contractual relationship has broken down.

A claim for the entire purchase price and rescission of the contract have different legal consequences and should be selected according to the objective of the particular case.

CAN A CONTRACT DEPOSIT ALWAYS BE FORFEITED OR RETURNED?

The legal effect of a contract deposit depends on the wording of the agreement and the circumstances in which the payment was made.

Depending on the circumstances, a payment described as a “deposit” may function as evidence of contract formation, as earnest money permitting cancellation under specified conditions, or as an agreed contractual remedy for breach.

Where the payment qualifies as earnest money under Article 565 of the Korean Civil Act, and unless the parties agreed otherwise, the party who paid it may generally rescind the contract by forfeiting the amount, while the party who received it may generally rescind by returning twice the amount.

This statutory right generally exists only until one of the parties has commenced performance of the contract.

Accordingly, once an intermediate payment has been made or a party has otherwise commenced performance, the agreement may no longer be terminated simply by forfeiting the deposit or returning twice its amount.

Where the contract also contains a provision concerning a contractual penalty, it is necessary to determine whether the provision constitutes an agreed measure of damages or a separate penalty.

The legal effect is determined by the actual contractual language and circumstances rather than the title given to the payment alone.

CAN THE BUYER REFUSE TO PAY THE ENTIRE PURCHASE PRICE BECAUSE OF A DEFECT?

An allegation that the property is defective does not automatically entitle the buyer to withhold the entire unpaid purchase price.

Depending on the nature and seriousness of the defect and its effect on the purpose of the transaction, potential remedies may include repair or replacement where applicable, reduction of the price, damages, or rescission of the contract.

Relevant issues may include:

whether the alleged defect existed at the legally relevant time;

whether the property lacked the quality or performance ordinarily expected or specifically agreed upon;

whether the defect resulted from the buyer’s subsequent use or management;

whether notice was given within the period required by applicable law or contract;

the reasonable cost of repair; and

the reduction, if any, in the value of the property.

The seller should likewise preserve evidence concerning the condition of the property when delivered, inspection or acceptance results, operating instructions, and the cause of any alleged defect.

LIMITATION PERIODS FOR PURCHASE PRICE CLAIMS

The limitation period applicable to a purchase price claim may vary according to the parties and the nature of the transaction.

An ordinary civil claim may generally be subject to a 10-year limitation period from the time the right can be exercised.

A claim arising from a commercial transaction may be subject to the five-year commercial limitation period.

In addition, under the Korean Civil Act, claims for the price of products or goods sold by producers or merchants may be subject to a three-year short-term limitation period.

Accordingly, the limitation period should not be calculated solely from the date the contract was signed.

The due date of each payment, the nature of the transaction, any acknowledgment of the debt, and any judicial claim or other event affecting the limitation period should be reviewed individually.

PURCHASE PRICE RECOVERY PROCESS

STEP 01 | Confirm the Sales Relationship

Review contracts, purchase orders, delivery records, and other transaction materials to establish the underlying agreement.

STEP 02 | Calculate the Outstanding Amount and Payment Deadlines

Determine the unpaid principal, applicable interest, amounts already paid, and the relevant due dates.

STEP 03 | Make a Formal Demand and Review the Possibility of Rescission

Send a formal demand for payment and determine whether the requirements for rescission may be satisfied if payment is not made.

STEP 04 | Consider Provisional Attachment

Where there is a risk that the debtor may dispose of assets before judgment, consider provisional attachment of available assets.

STEP 05 | Apply for a Payment Order or File a Purchase Price Lawsuit

Select the appropriate procedure based on the available evidence and the likelihood of a substantive dispute.

STEP 06 | Pursue Enforcement Following Judgment or Settlement

After obtaining an enforceable title, consider attachment and collection of receivables, enforcement against bank deposits, or compulsory auction of real estate.

PAYMENT ORDER VS. PURCHASE PRICE LAWSUIT

Payment Order

A payment order may be appropriate where the sales agreement and unpaid amount are relatively clear.

The process generally begins through written review, and the debtor may file an objection after service.

If a timely objection is filed, the matter ordinarily proceeds through litigation.

Purchase Price Lawsuit

Ordinary litigation may be more appropriate where the parties dispute the existence or terms of the agreement, delivery, inspection, defects, or the amount due.

The proceedings may involve written submissions, hearings, documentary evidence, expert appraisal, or witness examination.

Which Procedure Is More Appropriate?

If the buyer is likely to raise substantial defenses involving defects, non-delivery, or performance of the seller’s obligations, filing an ordinary lawsuit from the outset may be more efficient than first seeking a payment order.

WHAT SHOULD BE CHECKED BEFORE PURSUING A PURCHASE PRICE CLAIM?

the sale agreement and any special provisions;

the specific property sold and the agreed purchase price;

payment dates for the deposit, installments, and remaining balance;

whether delivery and transfer of ownership have occurred;

tax invoices and transaction statements;

inspection records, defect notices, and repair history;

amounts already paid and the remaining balance;

prior demands for performance and notices concerning rescission;

information concerning the debtor’s real estate, bank accounts, or other assets; and

the possibility that an applicable limitation period may expire.

A formal demand letter can preserve evidence that payment was requested or that an intention to rescind was communicated, but it does not by itself secure the debtor’s property.

Where there is a genuine risk that assets may be disposed of, the need for provisional attachment should be considered separately.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

01. We Analyze the Sale Agreement and the Parties’ Responsibilities

We review the written agreement and the actual course of the transaction to determine whether a sale was formed, when payment became due, and what obligations each party was required to perform.

We organize the deposit, intermediate payments, remaining balance, and amounts already paid and calculate contractual interest and applicable default interest.

03. We Address Concurrent Performance and Defect Claims

We examine whether delivery or transfer-of-title obligations were performed or tendered and respond to claims involving non-delivery, defects, price reduction, or withholding of payment.

04. We Preserve Assets Through Provisional Measures

We analyze available information concerning the debtor’s real estate, bank deposits, accounts receivable, and other assets and consider provisional attachment where necessary.

05. We Select and Pursue the Appropriate Recovery Procedure

We determine whether a payment order or ordinary civil litigation is more appropriate based on the available evidence and the defenses the opposing party is likely to raise.

06. We Assist with Compulsory Enforcement After Judgment

Based on an enforceable judgment, settlement, or payment order, we assist with attachment of bank accounts, wages, and commercial receivables and, where appropriate, compulsory auction of real estate.

A PURCHASE PRICE DISPUTE REQUIRES REVIEW OF BOTH THE CONTRACT AND THE ACTUAL COURSE OF PERFORMANCE.

Failure to receive the purchase price does not necessarily mean that payment is the only legal issue.

The seller’s obligations to deliver the property and transfer ownership, the buyer’s defect claims, rescission of the contract, and damages may all arise within the same dispute.

Prompt preservation of the contract, delivery records, and other transaction evidence—together with review of the debtor’s assets and applicable limitation periods—can significantly affect the possibility of actual recovery.

Veteran Law Firm carefully analyzes the formation and performance of the transaction, the reason payment remains outstanding, and the assets potentially available for recovery in order to develop an appropriate strategy for resolving a purchase price dispute.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.