A Single Contract Provision—or a Single Moment at the Construction Site—Can Change the Outcome of a Dispute
Construction disputes often involve multiple issues at the same time, including unpaid construction costs, additional work, design changes, project delays, defects, and termination of the construction contract.
The contractual documents alone may not be enough to determine the parties’ actual rights and responsibilities. Quotations, drawings, construction schedules, daily work reports, progress-payment records, photographs, and communications exchanged at the site may all be critical to understanding how the work was actually performed.
Veteran Law Firm provides comprehensive assistance in construction disputes, from the contract stage through suspension of work, payment claims, defect repairs, provisional attachment, and litigation.
WHAT IS A CONSTRUCTION DISPUTE?
Construction disputes are legal disputes arising among project owners, contractors, prime contractors, subcontractors, designers, construction supervisors, and other parties involved in a construction project concerning the terms and performance of construction contracts.
Under a construction contract, one party agrees to complete specified work and the other agrees to pay the contract price for the completed work.
In practice, however, construction contracts do not always describe every aspect of the work in detail, and the design or scope of construction may change as the project proceeds.
For this reason, construction disputes often require an examination not only of the written contract but also of how the project actually progressed and what occurred at the construction site.
COMMON LEGAL ISSUES IN CONSTRUCTION DISPUTES
“The Work Has Been Completed, but We Have Not Been Paid.”
To pursue a claim for unpaid construction costs, it is generally necessary to establish the existence of the construction contract, the agreed contract price, completion of the work or the value of work completed, and the date on which payment became due.
Even where there is no formal written contract, the existence and performance of a construction agreement may be established through evidence such as quotations, tax invoices, bank records, daily work reports, before-and-after photographs, material purchase records, and text or messenger communications.
Applicable limitation periods may also become an issue in construction payment claims. If payment continues to be delayed, the claim should therefore be reviewed promptly.
“Can We Recover the Cost of Additional Work?”
Where the parties agreed on a fixed total construction price, the contractor generally cannot demand an amount exceeding the agreed price merely because the actual cost of performing the project increased.
However, a separate claim for additional construction costs may be available where work outside the original contractual scope was performed pursuant to the owner’s instruction or agreement.
In determining whether particular work constitutes additional or changed work, relevant circumstances may include:
the purpose and original scope of the construction contract;
the circumstances that led to the additional or changed work;
whether the project owner expressly instructed or implicitly agreed to the additional work;
differences between the contractual drawings or quotations and the work actually performed; and
the proportion of the additional cost in relation to the total contract price.
Where additional work was performed based only on oral instructions, it is particularly important to preserve site communications, revised drawings, photographs, daily work reports, and material-order records as early as possible.
“If There Are Defects, Can the Owner Refuse to Pay the Entire Contract Price?”
Where the completed work contains defects, the project owner may seek repair of those defects and, in appropriate circumstances, may seek damages instead of or together with defect repair.
However, the existence of relatively minor defects does not automatically entitle the owner to withhold the entire unpaid construction price.
The nature and extent of the defects, appropriate method of repair, reasonable repair cost, any omitted or improperly performed work, and whether the purpose of the contract can still be achieved must be examined individually.
In construction litigation, the existence and cost of defects are often determined through a court-appointed expert appraisal.
For that reason, photographs, video footage, professional opinions, and other evidence of the original condition should be secured before defective work is removed, altered, or repaired.
“If Completion Was Delayed, Can the Owner Recover All Liquidated Damages for Delay?”
Where the construction contract provides for liquidated damages for delay, the owner may seek the agreed amount for a period of delay attributable to the contractor.
However, periods of delay caused by circumstances not attributable to the contractor may need to be excluded.
Such circumstances may include natural disasters, design changes requested by the owner, delays in selecting materials, incomplete preceding work, or the owner’s failure to make required payments.
Where the agreed amount of liquidated damages is excessively high, reduction by the court may also become an issue.
If the contract is terminated after work has stopped, the relevant delay period may not necessarily end on the date of termination. Depending on the circumstances, consideration may also be given to the reasonable period necessary for the owner to retain another contractor and complete the remaining work.
“Can the Project Owner Unilaterally Terminate the Construction Contract?”
Before completion of the work, a project owner may have the right to terminate the construction contract, but may be required to compensate the contractor for resulting loss.
Separately, if the contractor materially breaches the contract or circumstances demonstrate that completion is no longer reasonably expected, termination based on breach and a claim for damages may also be considered.
When a construction contract is terminated, a number of financial and practical issues may need to be settled together, including:
the value of work actually completed as of the termination date;
advance payments and progress payments already made;
ownership of materials brought onto the construction site;
omitted or defective work and anticipated repair costs;
additional costs required to retain a replacement contractor;
losses caused by delay; and
any applicable liquidated damages for delay.
A notice that work has stopped does not always clearly terminate the contractual relationship.
The basis for termination, its effective date, and the method of settling outstanding amounts should therefore be clearly documented in writing.
“Can a Subcontractor Demand Payment Directly from the Project Owner?”
As a general rule, a subcontractor claims payment from the contractor or prime contractor with whom it entered into the subcontract.
However, Korean construction law provides circumstances in which payment for subcontracted work may be made or required to be made directly by the project owner.
Depending on the applicable provision and circumstances, these may include the prime contractor’s suspension of payments or bankruptcy, qualifying delays in subcontract payments, a direct-payment agreement among the relevant parties, or other conditions prescribed by law.
The timing at which a right to direct payment arises can also affect its relationship with provisional attachments or seizures obtained by other creditors.
If the prime contractor’s financial condition begins to deteriorate, the requirements for a direct-payment claim should therefore be reviewed without delay.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR CONSTRUCTION DISPUTES
FOR CONTRACTORS AND SUBCONTRACTORS
STEP 01 | Review the Contract and Scope of Work
We examine the construction contract, quotations, design drawings, and specifications to determine the agreed scope of work and the conditions governing payment.
STEP 02 | Determine the Value of Completed Work and Additional Work
We distinguish completed work from unfinished items and organize objective evidence concerning additional or changed work performed at the project owner’s instruction, together with the resulting costs.
STEP 03 | Consider Measures to Preserve the Construction Payment Claim
We review the other party’s financial condition and ability to pay and, where appropriate, consider provisional attachment of real estate, bank accounts, construction receivables, or other assets.
STEP 04 | Send a Formal Demand and Pursue Negotiation
We calculate unpaid construction costs and additional work charges, make a formal demand for payment, and negotiate issues such as whether construction will continue and how outstanding amounts will be settled.
STEP 05 | Pursue Construction Payment Litigation and Enforcement
If the dispute cannot be resolved through negotiation, we pursue litigation for unpaid construction costs.
After the claim is established through judgment or settlement, we consider compulsory enforcement against available assets.
FOR OWNERS, PROJECT CLIENTS, AND PRIME CONTRACTORS
STEP 01 | Review the Status of Contract Performance
We compare the contractual drawings and specifications with the work actually performed and identify omitted work, defective work, construction defects, project delays, and any unauthorized suspension of construction.
STEP 02 | Determine the Scope and Cost of Defects
We review photographs from the site, construction supervision records, repair estimates, and opinions from relevant professionals to identify individual defects and assess reasonable repair costs.
STEP 03 | Reconcile Construction Payments and Delay Damages
We compare the value of completed work, advance payments, unpaid construction costs, defect-repair expenses, replacement construction costs, and liquidated damages for delay to determine the appropriate final settlement.
STEP 04 | Demand Repair or Consider Termination of the Contract
Where appropriate, we provide a reasonable period for the contractor to repair defects or resume contractual performance.
If adequate performance is not provided, we review whether termination and claims for damages are legally available.
STEP 05 | Respond to Litigation, Expert Appraisal, and Counterclaims
We respond to construction payment claims and, where appropriate, pursue counterclaims for defect-repair costs, liquidated damages for delay, and other losses.
We also prepare for and respond to the court-appointed expert appraisal process.
HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP
01. We Analyze Site Evidence Together with the Contract
Construction disputes cannot always be resolved from the written contract alone.
Veteran Law Firm organizes drawings, bills of quantities, progress-payment records, site photographs, daily work reports, and communications between the parties chronologically to determine the actual scope of construction and the respective responsibilities of the parties.
02. We Analyze Additional Work and Defects Item by Item
We do not simply accept or reject the other party’s claimed amount as a whole.
For each category of work, we examine whether it was included within the original contract, whether additional instructions were given, the condition of the work actually performed, and the reasonable cost of repair.
This allows us to distinguish amounts that may properly be claimed from amounts that should be challenged.
03. We Consider Recoverability Before Litigation Begins
In a construction payment dispute, obtaining a favorable judgment is only part of the objective. Actual recovery of the construction costs is equally important.
From the early stages of the case, we review the other party’s assets and business structure and consider measures such as provisional attachment, direct payment of subcontract amounts, rights of retention where legally available, and compulsory enforcement.
04. We Take an Active Approach to Court-Appointed Expert Appraisals
In disputes concerning construction defects or the value of completed work, the court-appointed expert’s findings can have a substantial effect on the outcome of the case.
We organize the issues to be addressed by the expert and the supporting site materials in advance.
Where necessary, we also submit specific objections and requests for supplementation, additional factual inquiries, or clarification regarding items that have been omitted or overstated.
05. We Develop Solutions That Address the Project Beyond the Lawsuit
Where a construction project is still underway, litigation alone may not resolve the practical problems at the site.
We consider the full range of issues—including resumption of construction, settlement upon early termination, handover of the site, removal of materials, defect repairs, and completion by a replacement contractor—to develop a solution that addresses the client’s actual business needs.
CONSTRUCTION DISPUTES SHOULD BE ADDRESSED BEFORE THE CONDITION OF THE SITE CHANGES.
Once construction has stopped or another contractor takes control of the site, it may become much more difficult to establish the scope of the original contractor’s work or the condition of alleged defects.
When issues arise concerning unpaid construction costs, additional work, defects, liquidated damages for delay, or termination of a construction contract, the relevant site evidence should be preserved and the parties’ legal responsibilities and settlement positions should be reviewed promptly.
Veteran Law Firm analyzes both the construction site and the contractual structure to provide an appropriate response—from recovery of unpaid construction costs to the defense of defect and damages claims.