Veteran Law Firm

Criminal Defense

ABUSE

WHAT IS ABUSE?

WHAT IS ABUSE?

Abuse generally refers to physically or psychologically cruel treatment of a person who is under another’s protection or supervision, or conduct that interferes with the safety and normal life of a person who requires care or protection.

Article 273 of Korea’s Criminal Act criminalizes the abuse of a person who is under the offender’s protection or supervision and provides a more severe penalty where the victim is the offender’s own lineal ascendant or the lineal ascendant of the offender’s spouse.

Actual abuse cases, however, are not governed solely by the general abuse provisions of the Criminal Act.

Depending on the victim’s age, condition, relationship with the alleged offender, and the nature of the conduct, separate statutes concerning child abuse, elder abuse, or abuse of persons with disabilities may apply. Other criminal offenses, including assault, bodily injury, abandonment, or neglect, may also arise from the same conduct.

Abuse does not necessarily require direct physical violence. Depending on the applicable statute and the specific facts, repeated threats or degrading treatment, emotional abuse, or a failure to provide legally required care or protection may also constitute abuse.

Accordingly, an abuse case should not be evaluated by isolating a single act. It is necessary to examine the relationship between the parties, the existence and scope of any duty of protection or supervision, the nature and repetition of the conduct, the victim’s condition, and the actual consequences of the alleged abuse.

MAJOR TYPES OF ABUSE AND PENALTIES

GENERAL ABUSE

Article 273(1) of the Criminal Act may apply where a person abuses someone who is under his or her protection or supervision.

The statutory penalty is:

imprisonment for up to 2 years or a fine of up to KRW 5 million.

The key issue is not merely whether the conduct was unpleasant, unfair, or inappropriate.

It is necessary to determine whether a legally relevant relationship of protection or supervision existed and whether the conduct was sufficiently serious to constitute criminal abuse.

ABUSE OF A LINEAL ASCENDANT

Where the victim is the offender’s own lineal ascendant or the lineal ascendant of the offender’s spouse, Article 273(2) of the Criminal Act may apply.

The statutory penalty is:

imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 7 million.

ABUSE RESULTING IN BODILY INJURY OR DEATH

Where abuse results in bodily injury or death, substantially more serious criminal liability may arise.

Under Article 275 of the Criminal Act, where general abuse or certain related conduct results in bodily injury, the offender may be punished by:

imprisonment for up to 7 years.

Where the conduct results in death, the statutory penalty may be:

imprisonment for at least 3 years.

Separate enhanced punishment applies where bodily injury or death results from abuse of a lineal ascendant.

In these cases, it is necessary to examine not only the underlying abusive conduct but also the causal relationship between that conduct and the injury or death.

CHILD ABUSE

Child abuse is not limited to physical violence.

Depending on the facts, a case may involve physical abuse, emotional abuse, sexual abuse, abandonment, or neglect.

Under Korea’s Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Child Abuse Crimes, certain offenses committed against a child by a person responsible for the child’s care or protection are treated as “child abuse crimes” and are subject to specialized investigative, criminal, and protective procedures.

The applicable punishment therefore depends on what specific abusive conduct occurred and which underlying criminal offense is established.

Where child abuse causes a life-threatening condition or results in a serious disability or an incurable or difficult-to-treat illness, the special offense of serious bodily injury resulting from child abuse may apply, carrying a substantial term of imprisonment under the applicable statute.

Habitual commission of a child abuse crime may result in enhanced punishment. Enhanced punishment may also apply in certain cases where a person subject to a statutory duty to report child abuse commits an abuse offense against a child under that person’s protection.

Child abuse cases may also involve measures separate from criminal punishment, including separation of the alleged offender from the child, restrictions on approaching or contacting the child or household members, placement of the child in a protective facility, and restrictions affecting parental or guardianship authority. Current law provides for emergency measures and court-issued child protection orders for these purposes.

ELDER ABUSE

Elder abuse may involve more than physical assault.

Under Korea’s Welfare of Older Persons Act, prohibited conduct against persons aged 65 or older may include physical abuse, sexual abuse, abandonment or neglect by a person responsible for protection or supervision, misuse of money or property provided for the older person, and emotional abuse through verbal abuse, threats, or intimidation.

Where the alleged offender is a family member, caregiver, or employee of a care facility who had responsibility for protecting or supervising the victim, it may also be necessary to examine whether the conduct constitutes abuse under the Criminal Act, as well as assault, bodily injury, abandonment, neglect, or another offense.

There is no single statutory penalty applicable to every form of “elder abuse.” The governing provision and potential punishment depend on the specific conduct.

Accordingly, the victim’s health, ability to communicate and make decisions, relationship with caregivers, living and care arrangements, financial circumstances, and the frequency and duration of the alleged conduct should all be examined carefully.

ABUSE OF PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES OR OTHERS REQUIRING PROTECTION

Abuse may also arise where the victim is a person with a disability, illness, or other condition that makes independent self-protection difficult.

Where the alleged offender is a facility employee, family member, caregiver, or another person who actually exercised protection or supervision over the victim, the nature of that protective relationship and the specific conduct involved become particularly important.

The legal analysis may extend beyond physical assault.

Depending on the circumstances, intentionally withholding necessary care, exploiting the victim’s vulnerable condition, neglecting essential needs, or engaging in other harmful conduct may require review under statutes protecting persons with disabilities together with the general criminal provisions governing assault, bodily injury, abandonment, neglect, and abuse.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR ABUSE CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Identify the Type of Alleged Abuse and the Relationship Between the Parties

We determine whether the alleged victim is a child, an older person, a person with a disability, or another person requiring protection and examine the nature of any protective or supervisory relationship between the client and the alleged victim.

STEP 02 | Separate and Chronologically Organize the Alleged Conduct

We distinguish among physical conduct, emotional conduct, neglect, abandonment, and other alleged acts and organize when each act is said to have occurred, how often it occurred, and over what period.

STEP 03 | Analyze Objective Evidence and the Victim’s Statements

We review CCTV footage, scene evidence, medical records, witness and caregiver statements, and other materials appropriate to the type of case to determine whether the allegations are consistent with the objective record.

STEP 04 | Distinguish Legitimate Care, Supervision, or Discipline from Abuse

In child-related cases, we examine whether the conduct falls within lawful educational or supervisory activity or crosses the line into abuse.

In cases involving older persons or persons with disabilities, we similarly distinguish ordinary caregiving or protective conduct from treatment that may constitute criminal abuse or neglect.

Under current Korean child abuse law, legitimate educational activities and student guidance by teachers carried out in accordance with applicable education laws are not treated as child abuse.

STEP 05 | Respond to the First Police Interview and Protective Measures

Where separation, restrictions on contact, or other protective measures have already been imposed, we review the legal and factual basis for those measures while preparing a detailed account of the circumstances and each alleged act before substantive police questioning.

STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Trial

Where the allegations are disputed, we address the alleged abusive conduct, intent, causation, and resulting harm based on the available evidence.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we prepare appropriate materials concerning victim recovery, recurrence prevention, treatment or education, and other circumstances relevant to prosecution and sentencing.

FOR VICTIMS AND PROTECTIVE FAMILY MEMBERS

STEP 01 | Document the Alleged Abuse and Whether It Was Repeated

We identify when the conduct began, what forms of abuse occurred, and whether the matter involves an isolated incident or repeated conduct over time.

STEP 02 | Document the Victim’s Condition and Secure Objective Evidence

We collect photographs of injuries, medical records, CCTV footage, scene evidence, statements from caregivers or other witnesses, and other materials relevant to the case.

We also document the victim’s physical and psychological condition.

STEP 03 | Identify the Type of Abuse and the Applicable Offenses

We distinguish among child abuse, elder abuse, abuse involving a person with a disability, physical or emotional abuse, neglect, abandonment, and related conduct and determine which statutes and criminal offenses may apply.

STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview

We organize the specific abusive acts, timing, repetition, and resulting harm and connect those facts to the objective evidence so that the overall course of conduct can be accurately presented to investigators.

STEP 05 | Consider Separation and Measures to Prevent Further Harm

Where there is a continuing risk of abuse, the victim’s immediate safety must be addressed.

We review available measures such as separation, restrictions on approaching or contacting the victim, emergency protection, and other protective procedures appropriate to the type of case. In child abuse cases, current law expressly provides for emergency separation and court-issued protective orders.

STEP 06 | Respond Through Criminal Trial and Pursue Recovery

Where the alleged offender is prosecuted, we assist in presenting the victim’s position concerning the extent and repetition of the harm.

Where appropriate, we also review civil claims for damages and other procedures aimed at securing meaningful recovery.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Understand What Investigators Examine After an Abuse Report

An abuse case cannot be determined solely from the fact that a report was made, nor can it be resolved merely because the accused states that there was no intent to abuse.

This is particularly important where the alleged victim is a child, older person, person with a disability, or another individual requiring protection.

Investigators may consider not only the victim’s statement but also the protective relationship between the parties, the living environment, whether the conduct was repeated, CCTV footage, medical records, and other objective evidence.

Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the initial report, the scene, statements from the victim, caregivers and other relevant persons, and the objective evidence as one connected record.

01 | Review the Initial Report and First Response

We examine how the emergency or abuse report was made, what police or other authorities observed at the scene, the earliest statements of the alleged victim and accused, and whether separation or other protective measures were immediately imposed.

02 | Examine the Full Context, Not an Isolated Moment

We do not evaluate the case solely from a particular CCTV clip, statement, or incident.

We examine the relationship between the parties and the circumstances before and after the alleged conduct to understand its full context.

03 | Cross-Check the Victim’s Statement Against Objective Evidence

We compare the statements of the victim and accused with CCTV footage, medical records, scene evidence, statements from caregivers and witnesses, and other available materials to establish the facts as accurately as possible.

04 | Distinguish the Applicable Law Based on the Victim and Type of Conduct

We identify the victim’s age and condition, the protective relationship, and the type of alleged conduct to determine whether the case is governed by the general abuse provisions of the Criminal Act, child abuse legislation, elder protection laws, disability-related legislation, or additional criminal provisions.

05 | Examine Repetition, Habitual Conduct, and the Resulting Harm

We determine whether the alleged conduct occurred once or repeatedly and whether it resulted in bodily injury, serious harm, or death.

This distinction may materially affect both the applicable offense and the potential level of criminal responsibility.

06 | Develop the Appropriate Strategy from the First Police Interview

Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators evaluate the initial report, the victim’s statement, the protective or supervisory relationship, CCTV and medical evidence, repetition of the conduct, and resulting harm, and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.

Where the same allegations also give rise to family proceedings, civil claims, school-related proceedings, workplace or disciplinary matters, or other legal processes, we consider how statements, protective measures, and findings in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.

IN AN ABUSE CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT A SINGLE INCIDENT IN ISOLATION, BUT THE RELATIONSHIP OF PROTECTION OR SUPERVISION, THE NATURE AND PATTERN OF THE CONDUCT, THE VICTIM’S VULNERABILITY, AND WHAT THE OBJECTIVE EVIDENCE SHOWS ABOUT THE HARM THAT OCCURRED.

Carefully reconstructing the full course of conduct—from the first reported incident through the victim’s condition, medical evidence, living environment, and protective relationship—can be critical to distinguishing lawful care or supervision from criminal abuse and to protecting the rights and safety of everyone involved.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.