A Sexual Expression Alone Does Not Determine the Offense—the Purpose, Context, and Manner of Communication Must Be Examined Together
WHAT ARE SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATIONS?
Article 13 of Korea’s Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes prohibits the use of a telephone, mail, computer, or other means of communication to cause another person to receive words, sounds, writings, pictures, images, or other material capable of causing sexual shame or aversion, when done for the purpose of arousing or satisfying the sexual desires of the sender or another person.
The offense may arise through various means of communication, including text messages, telephone calls, messaging applications, social media, and email.
Whether the offense is established depends not simply on whether sexually explicit language or material was communicated.
The purpose and circumstances of the conduct, the relationship between the parties, the method of communication, and the content and context of the communication should all be examined together.
The Korean Supreme Court has also held that whether the required purpose of arousing or satisfying sexual desire exists should be determined reasonably according to social norms by considering the relationship between the accused and the alleged victim, the motive and circumstances of the conduct, the means and method used, and the nature and manner of the communication.
PENALTIES FOR SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATIONS
Under Article 13 of the Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Sexual Crimes, the offense is punishable by:
Imprisonment for up to 2 years or a fine of up to KRW 20 million
The Korean Sentencing Commission currently provides the following sentencing guideline ranges:
Mitigated: up to 6 months
Standard: 4 months to 10 months
Aggravated: 8 months to 1 year 6 months
These are sentencing guideline ranges rather than penalties automatically imposed in every case.
The actual outcome may vary depending on the content and circumstances of the conduct, repetition, degree of harm, relationship between the parties, conduct following the incident, and other applicable sentencing factors.
KEY ISSUES IN SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATION CASES
01. WAS THERE A PURPOSE TO AROUSE OR SATISFY SEXUAL DESIRE?
The offense is not automatically established merely because a message contains sexual language or expressions.
The purpose and motive at the time of the communication, the overall course of the conversation, and the relationship between the parties must be considered together.
The required “sexual desire” is not necessarily limited to a desire for sexual intercourse or direct sexual activity.
Depending on the circumstances, an intent to obtain psychological satisfaction by sexually humiliating or degrading another person may also become relevant to the legal analysis.
02. WAS THE CONTENT CAPABLE OF CAUSING SEXUAL SHAME OR AVERSION?
The analysis should not be limited to an isolated word, photograph, or video.
The entire content of the communication, the surrounding conversation, and the circumstances in which the material was sent should be examined to determine whether it objectively falls within the statutory standard.
03. WHAT WAS THE OVERALL CONTEXT OF THE COMMUNICATION?
The prior relationship between the parties, how the conversation began, what was communicated before and after the material at issue, and the circumstances in which it was sent may all be important.
A partial screenshot or isolated message may not necessarily reveal the complete context of the communication.
04. WAS THE CONDUCT REPEATED?
Whether the same or similar material was sent repeatedly, particularly after the recipient expressed a desire for the communications to stop, may affect both the evaluation of the conduct and sentencing.
The complete communication history should therefore be reviewed rather than focusing only on a single transmission.
HOW A FORMER POLICE OFFICER-TURNED-ATTORNEY CAN ASSIST
Cases involving sexually obscene communications often depend heavily on text messages, messenger conversations, social media records, call history, images, and other digital evidence.
For that reason, accurately organizing the facts and evidence from the police investigation stage can be critical.
Drawing on prior experience investigating criminal cases, our former police officer-turned-attorneys examine the issues investigators are likely to focus on and develop an appropriate response from the earliest stage.
In particular, it is important to review the complete conversation rather than allowing the case to be evaluated solely on the basis of selected messages or screenshots.
Veteran Law Firm analyzes the entire communication history, the circumstances of transmission, the relationship between the parties, and the objective evidence to identify the central legal and factual issues before police questioning.
VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATION CASES
STEP 01 | Identify the Incident and How the Investigation Began
We review the criminal complaint, the means of communication involved, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances leading to the alleged incident.
We also identify the current stage of the investigation and the principal issues being examined.
STEP 02 | Analyze the Communications and Evidence
We review relevant materials such as:
text messages;
messenger conversations;
social media communications;
photographs and videos;
call records; and
other digital evidence.
The complete flow of communication before and after the material at issue is examined together with the circumstances in which it was transmitted.
STEP 03 | Prepare for the Initial Police Interview
Before questioning, we organize the relevant facts and identify the issues likely to arise during the investigation.
Because statements made during the initial investigation may later be examined throughout the prosecution and trial, preparation should be based on the actual communication records and objective facts rather than speculation.
STEP 04 | Develop a Response Based on the Key Legal Issues
We examine whether there was a purpose to arouse or satisfy sexual desire, whether the content falls within the statutory standard, the overall context of the communication, the relationship between the parties, and whether the conduct was repeated.
Based on that analysis, we prepare appropriate factual and legal arguments and, where necessary, submit a written attorney opinion.
STEP 05 | Respond Through Investigation and Trial
Depending on the result of the police investigation, we provide the necessary response at the prosecution stage.
If charges are filed, we analyze the evidence and central legal issues and prepare for criminal trial.
Where responsibility is acknowledged, we also review legally relevant sentencing circumstances and prepare appropriate sentencing materials.
IN A SEXUALLY OBSCENE COMMUNICATION CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHETHER SEXUAL WORDS OR IMAGES WERE SENT, BUT WHY THEY WERE SENT, IN WHAT CONTEXT, AND WHAT THE COMPLETE COMMUNICATION RECORD SHOWS.
Text messages, messenger conversations, social media records, call history, and other digital evidence can become central evidence in these cases.
Veteran Law Firm examines the entire course of communication, the relationship between the parties, the purpose and circumstances of the conduct, and the objective record to determine whether the statutory requirements are satisfied and what response is appropriate.
If you are facing an investigation involving sexually obscene communications, preserving the complete communication history and organizing the facts before the first substantive police interview can be critical to protecting your legal rights.