Veteran Law Firm

Criminal Defense

THREATS

WHAT IS CRIMINAL THREATENING?

WHAT IS CRIMINAL THREATENING?

Criminal threatening is an offense under Article 283 of Korea’s Criminal Act that may be established where a person communicates a threat of harm in a manner capable of causing fear in another person.

The threatened harm does not have to be expressed in direct terms such as “I will kill you” or “I will hurt you.” The legal assessment depends on the content of the words or conduct, the relationship between the parties, the surrounding circumstances, and the context before and after the statement.

The Supreme Court has also held that the victim does not necessarily have to prove that he or she actually experienced fear. Depending on the circumstances, the offense may be established where the victim recognized the communication of harm and the expression was objectively capable of causing fear.

Accordingly, a threat case should not be evaluated by isolating a single sentence. It is necessary to examine the circumstances in which the expression was made, the relationship between the accused and the victim, whether similar conduct was repeated, and whether there were surrounding facts suggesting that the threatened harm could realistically be carried out.

Depending on the manner of conduct and the relationship between the parties, threat offenses may include ordinary threats, threats against a lineal ascendant, aggravated threats involving a dangerous object or collective force, and habitual threats. Where the threat is made for retaliatory purposes in connection with a criminal case, more serious liability may arise under Korea’s Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes.

MAJOR TYPES OF THREATS AND PENALTIES

ORDINARY THREATS

Ordinary threats may arise where a person communicates harm concerning another person’s life, body, liberty, reputation, property, or other legally protected interests in a manner capable of causing fear.

Under Article 283(1) of the Criminal Act, the offense is punishable by:

imprisonment for up to 3 years, a fine of up to KRW 5 million, detention, or a minor fine.

Ordinary threats cannot be prosecuted contrary to the victim’s expressly stated wishes. Accordingly, the victim’s position concerning punishment may have an important effect on the course of the case.

THREATS AGAINST A LINEAL ASCENDANT

A more severe statutory penalty applies where the victim is the offender’s own lineal ascendant or the lineal ascendant of the offender’s spouse.

Under Article 283(2) of the Criminal Act, the offense is punishable by:

imprisonment for up to 5 years or a fine of up to KRW 7 million.

This offense is also subject to the rule that prosecution cannot proceed against the victim’s expressly stated wishes.

AGGRAVATED THREATS

Article 284 of the Criminal Act may apply where a threat is made while demonstrating the collective force of a group or crowd or while carrying a dangerous object.

In an aggravated threat case, the analysis should not focus solely on whether an object happened to be present at the scene.

It is necessary to examine the nature of the object, why and how it was carried, whether it was readily available for use, the accused’s words and conduct, and the overall circumstances of the incident.

Aggravated threats are punishable by:

imprisonment for up to 7 years or a fine of up to KRW 10 million.

Unlike ordinary threats, aggravated threats are not subject to the same rule preventing prosecution against the victim’s wishes. A settlement may still be relevant, but it does not by itself terminate the criminal proceedings.

HABITUAL THREATS

Where threat offenses are committed repeatedly and habituality is legally established, habitual threats may be at issue.

Under Article 285 of the Criminal Act, where ordinary threats, threats against a lineal ascendant, or aggravated threats are committed habitually, the punishment prescribed for the underlying offense may be increased by up to one-half.

Habituality is not determined merely because multiple calls or messages were made.

The number and duration of the incidents, method of conduct, repetition, prior criminal history, and other circumstances must be considered together.

RETALIATORY THREATS

More serious criminal liability may arise where a person threatens another in connection with a criminal case for the purpose of preventing a complaint, accusation, statement, testimony, or submission of evidence, or retaliating for such conduct that has already occurred.

Under Article 5-9(2) of Korea’s Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes, retaliatory threats of this kind are punishable by:

imprisonment for at least 1 year.

Accordingly, conduct such as threatening a person to withdraw a criminal complaint or retaliating against someone for a statement made to police or in court should not automatically be treated as an ordinary threat case.

VETERAN LAW FIRM’S PROCESS FOR THREAT CASES

FOR SUSPECTS AND DEFENDANTS

STEP 01 | Identify the Alleged Threat and Reconstruct the Incident

We determine precisely which words or conduct are alleged to constitute a threat and organize the circumstances leading to the incident, the relationship between the parties, and the events before and after the expression in chronological order.

STEP 02 | Analyze the Full Context and Whether a Threat of Harm Was Communicated

We do not isolate a particular phrase from the surrounding conversation.

We review the entire interaction and the circumstances at the time to determine whether the expression legally amounted to a communication of harm capable of causing fear.

STEP 03 | Compare Statements with Objective Evidence

We examine call recordings, message histories, CCTV footage, scene recordings, witness statements, and other relevant materials to determine whether the complainant’s account is consistent with the objective evidence.

STEP 04 | Distinguish Ordinary, Aggravated, Habitual, and Retaliatory Threats

We examine whether a dangerous object was carried, whether collective force was involved, whether similar conduct was repeated, and whether there was any retaliatory purpose connected to a criminal complaint, statement, testimony, or other participation in criminal proceedings.

STEP 05 | Develop a Strategy for the First Police Interview and Settlement

We prepare the client’s statement around the meaning of the disputed words, the surrounding circumstances, and the relationship between the parties.

Where the offense is one in which the victim’s stated wishes concerning punishment may have legal effect, we also assess whether and when settlement should be considered based on the facts and allegations.

STEP 06 | Respond Through Prosecution and Trial

Where the allegation is disputed, we focus on whether a legally sufficient threat of harm was made, the accused’s intent, and the full context of the communication.

Where responsibility is acknowledged, we prepare materials concerning victim recovery, settlement, the circumstances of the offense, and other matters relevant to prosecution and sentencing.

FOR VICTIMS

STEP 01 | Document the Threat and the Circumstances

We organize when, where, and how the threat was made, what harm was communicated, and whether similar conduct occurred previously.

STEP 02 | Secure and Preserve Evidence

We preserve call recordings, messages, emails, CCTV footage, scene video or audio recordings, witness statements, and other materials showing the content and circumstances of the threat, preferably in their original form.

STEP 03 | Assess the Type and Seriousness of the Threat

We examine whether the conduct involves an ordinary threat, a dangerous object or collective force, repeated threatening conduct, or retaliatory intent connected to a criminal complaint, statement, testimony, or other participation in criminal proceedings.

STEP 04 | Prepare the Criminal Complaint and Victim Interview

We connect the specific threatened harm and surrounding circumstances with the objective evidence and prepare the criminal complaint accordingly.

We also prepare for the police interview so that the chronology and resulting fear or harm are presented clearly and accurately.

STEP 05 | Prevent Further Harm and Pursue Recovery

Where threatening conduct continues or there is a realistic risk of further harm, we review protective measures that may be available based on the nature of the case.

Where emotional or financial loss has resulted, we also consider potential civil claims for damages or other appropriate recovery measures.

HOW VETERAN LAW FIRM CAN HELP

Former Police Officer Attorneys Who Examine the Situation Behind the Words, Not Just the Words Themselves

A threat case is not determined by a single sentence in isolation.

The same words may be evaluated differently depending on who said them, to whom they were directed, the relationship between the parties, and the circumstances in which they were spoken.

Conversely, even without an explicit statement such as “I will harm you,” the combination of words, conduct, and surrounding circumstances may still amount to a legally sufficient threat.

Where a dangerous object is involved, threatening conduct is repeated, or retaliatory intent connected to a criminal complaint or statement is alleged, the applicable offense may extend beyond ordinary threats to aggravated, habitual, or retaliatory threats.

Veteran Law Firm draws on the investigative experience of its former police officer attorneys to analyze the initial report, the statements of the parties, objective evidence, and conduct before and after the incident as one continuous sequence and to identify the issues investigators are likely to examine.

01 | Review the Initial Emergency Report and Circumstances at the Scene

Where an emergency call was made, we examine the initial report, the condition and statements of the parties when police arrived, and other circumstances immediately following the incident.

02 | Analyze the Context Before and After the Alleged Threat

We do not review only the disputed words.

We examine what was said and done before and after the expression to determine whether, in context, the communication amounted to a legally relevant threat of harm.

03 | Compare Recordings and Objective Evidence with the Parties’ Statements

We compare call recordings, scene materials, messages, CCTV footage, and other objective evidence with the parties’ accounts to reconstruct what was actually said and how the situation developed.

04 | Identify Whether More Serious Threat Charges May Apply

We examine whether a dangerous object was carried, whether collective force was involved, whether the threats were repeated, and whether there was any retaliatory purpose connected to a criminal complaint, police statement, testimony, or other participation in criminal proceedings.

05 | Distinguish Cases Requiring Settlement from Cases Requiring a Factual or Legal Defense

We distinguish offenses such as ordinary threats, where the victim’s stated wishes concerning punishment may have direct legal significance, from offenses such as aggravated threats, where settlement alone does not terminate the case.

We then develop the response strategy accordingly.

06 | Respond from the First Police Interview Through Prosecution and Trial

Drawing on practical investigative experience, Veteran Law Firm’s former police officer attorneys analyze how investigators assess the content of the alleged threat, the relationship between the parties, the surrounding circumstances, the involvement of dangerous objects, repetition, and retaliatory purpose, and develop a coordinated strategy from the first police interview through prosecution and trial.

Where the same conduct also gives rise to stalking allegations, civil claims, family proceedings, workplace or disciplinary matters, school-related proceedings, or other disputes, we also consider how statements and evidence in the criminal case may affect those proceedings and coordinate the response accordingly.

IN A THREAT CASE, THE CENTRAL QUESTION IS NOT SIMPLY WHAT WORDS WERE USED, BUT WHAT HARM WAS COMMUNICATED, IN WHAT CONTEXT, BETWEEN WHOM, AND WHETHER THE CONDUCT WAS OBJECTIVELY CAPABLE OF CAUSING FEAR.

Reconstructing the full conversation, the relationship between the parties, the surrounding conduct, and the objective evidence can be critical to determining whether criminal threatening is established and whether a more serious form of the offense applies.

Lawyers

View all →

Request a consultation

Use the form to send a consultation request.